Show CHILD HILD LABOR LABORI LABOR LABORI I SIDES TAKEN Arguments Pro and Con Can Given By Speaker At Rotary Dinner T Tao 0 side sIdes of or the lie child controversy were ere pie pie- pie Ogden and ladle ladies at al a the meeting In h bp club Wednesday b bAdim Adam S of oC Ij 1 1 D P Si S schools school IOn I OK Jl t 1 The rho considerations urged b J proponents of or the Iho amendment as cited 0 b Mr The rho census enus of or 1920 eho shows that I 1069 1061 S S 15 10 l out ot or a total ot or 12 l lr r children or of 81 ages iges In Itt the hue Slates them e e a engaged ii 1 in gainful occupations occupations lIons Of ur these or I 61 per were ere In la pursuits I lIte lie he othes were store distributed as n foi- foi fol follows low lows s a l on ona rl 1 html cults 4 54 rOI 1 h 3 50 messenger m bundle and office bo bos and girls 4 28 0 salesmen and stoics clerIcs andI I except clerks In lit stores cotton colton mill op ne boy 2070 20 iO Iron and HI Sl el Ind 12 cloth cloth- Ins cloth lag Ing industry i lumber and I I operatives 10 I 0 58 SIt sl silk sill mill opel- opel aches athes 10 shoe hoe factor oper t ea elites woolen wooten and worsted mIll coal mine operatives all ions occupations un 1 I ij The Tho elfa e of ot Is a aI I question h that hat italic hull concerns the Interests of or the countr itt al it large Health education and the lile light tight to normally al ale aie e American rights rhe the efforts of or states an anxious anious lolls to 10 protect are annuled I the tho fact that thai children hildren may be betaken I from from na such a state into oln a f fJ aO lr state I with J lax laws s saO or with h an In- In IndIfferent In Indifferent different attitude I to child I labor la M Stiles les already having adequate chIld labor la laws will HI not be Inter litter Interfered I fored with by Jy federal legislation Such Ouch stales states may well lend their t to correcting coi Ills s in other I states All 11 American children are entitled to equal protection i 0 VI lii CI lIIL 1 onie ome backward ard states Slates will Ill not or cannot at least do tIe not protect their Mho ho ato ac handicapped In lit theli thelt preparation for Cor life Jile and who 10 therefore ate aie a menace to 10 l both In the state stale and In the nation in states stales which rigidly enrol ee child hild laboi abo laws is handi handi- handicapped handicapped capped In is with lIlt busl- busl business busi business ness conducted in states slates which tot tot- tol tolerate crate erate child laborI labor I he 0 pi laborI amendment 11 I nol hot destroy state otate initiative in child I II elrae legislation nor will it take lake I I from states the i Ignis lights to lo I Ilor or prohibit child chillI laboi I llie giving of or it to 10 con con- con congress on- on lor gross gress to 10 legislate on this question I toes not Commit congress to 10 lull c exercise pro j of or that Pro Pro-j slon Is 10 elastic clastic to pro Ide for the I de that ma Ina inai attend out oui ou I progress I II j I inc lne pi child labor amend amend- ment hag lias b been en sponsored and Isnow IS isnow I now noVo b by leading Amen Ameri- Americans cans Ameri-cans cans organizations and amid leadIng organ organ- G S1 M G 81 1 IC fUI flushed ti b those ed ed ed to the amendment were ere summed up a aa as follows lollos by byAll alt 11 B j hose who ushio ho object to 10 the 1 pio 0 posed pOd do not nol den that thai child laboi abuses may milay they oust lt e t object et etC to the federal I tion ordo rr C lot foi the lie abuses Ir r i or do the go BO on record reed as fa the capitalizing ot or child J bo I I- I be because cause it Is heap cheap for the sake oake or of financial gain 10 lo chaise them bent themI I with such ouch motives Is as ns unwar Ulmar- unwarranted ranted as to 10 charge to 10 proponents lor of the amendment a 0 deslie e la to pro pro- I pro pro-lubit all nil labor by persons persona U UI up to the tho las ago age of o 18 IllI VIS 1 I constitute rh Time e major I tOte tute the else oe llie lie amend amendment ment It 11 li Ii The fhe states slates amend I aI- aI al lead ell hate hll e 1 to I tutU I t Jo Ilp 1 I Ie h ret fuel that sonic sale a ate ales ma limit mav not ilot fully rully have haic I laws lasts s I Is not sufficient g gt IOu Ii ring such uch fluent to 10 Such a ati ati ti 10 lifter sutter I Is no of or m cc- cc fit nt uI J I tie lie c of or 1920 I bho S SIdn an Ait improvement n Ic ie e maUti mattu of orlI the or of o chill 1 ibor 1 ot or orl I 4 Ie pel cent o er the census of or 1010 A d d emease front from to mo 1 I- I II Ito O ass J 5 I 1 I ha has not been Jen s to dale date ii indicates iii 11 it t all am state slate cannot or will III nut not l I LOO copo with o w ith Its lis child notI hi- hi 1 boi I but JOI situation I III Lit IU 11 I 1 OC OCL OCI I I It is h onta to 10 the ginius genius or of orI American It olves the fedal go In I poll pollee o duties dutler The I or of I lie he details of or ment is essen- essen IL a a local problem such an I anI amendment would he lie one more I step al 10 tow aid 1 national I with Inthe Ith all II its attendant dangers ut In I face tace of or threatening threatening- I Control l progress will ll be mom 1110 e OUI ely guaranteed and more Jel built it If each state Is educated into nto a 0 consciousness or of oIts Its solution 0 ow own it II local problems and cud their ISI It IL would involve ohe an plan plait of or l procedure The Tho proposed ignores the n between and by bv establIshing the ago oge or of 18 legislation as os the thc he basis bais of or child labor tens legis le lo bureaus lation It is 1 create ne new nets bu- bu bu centered In Ic- Ic 0 mote mole c from ron their problems l hug heo a a Iet of I Is Inevitable Pot 10 adequate quate enforcement it II would involve olve hen expense U Ct i ci AI KH IW President John Carter Carler resided Presided at the tue dinner dance I 1 I aeh achi woman oman In lit attendance received a gilt giC I 1 two wo vocal selections by airs l John Leonard I-eonard were features of or the I program Dancing followed follow tollo rd ed the dinner di n nor |