Show II IIII II III I I i OPE O REED I GAL CAL INSULTS f tiN SENATE Solon Moves to Expunge Presidents President's Letter Prom From Record HARSH WAR IS ON Gifford Pinchot Implicated ed In Mellon Attack Charge arge By Dr n 1 K IC IU REYNOLDS Y OLDS I I es cs n Ice jl April 12 s 12 A tho climax ic of ot one of ot the tho most harsh I fand and bitter attacks to which a n pret- pret dent of the United States State has ever I been subjected Senator James A Reed Heed Democrat of oC o Missouri to tonight night offered o a 0 resolution la lu the senate to expunge from the th con con con- con record the th sI pedal ecial mes mes- mes meso mes-hase mes e o ot of President Coolidge con condemning con con- the th investigation ot of o Secretary Secre- Secre I tary ot of the Treasury Mellon and the Bureau of o Internal Declaring that the tho th pre should never have hav been given the courtesy or o beIng re- re re ceh celled cd Reed described Ita It a as an n i offensive ofen ivo document which ws as as asan on an Insult t to the senate 1 Reed Reed announced that he h euId 1 Monday demand action on the th resolution I The resolution Tins as as as ns Resolved That the th llon lion of the tha president of the th United States State of date dot of April 11 ii ISH 1924 and the letter to th th secretary ecret ry of the treasury of date daf of ot April 10 1924 be r ond are hereby expunged j ft flom om tho th record of ot the th senate The Tho of the treasury's letter was as sas transmitted to the senate by the th president con con- con condemned government by investigation Investigation tion and severely criticized the th courto of t tho internal revenue r In In- In i Instead of cooling the h I tion by hI his warm defense e of et Secre Secretary tary ty MelLon Melton and his hie hi sharp harp r buk to to 10 the whole holo holo senate onate nate it developed tonIght that the tho president hail had ha un stirred cd up Do a i veritable eon l sra- sra l tion ATTACK AVrACK 1 The Tho attack In the senate was wa led ltd by b Reed Rood Tho Thos J 1 Walsh of ot Mon MoO Montana Montana tana lana and Kenneth enneth Dera- Dera Democrat of Tennessee after Senator ins Jas U Watson S alcoa atson Republican of ot In- In Idiana diana dlana had delivered a stirring de da- da d fens of ot the th president and Mellon and aud repeated repealed the tho th president s a charge chare that benator Senator James Cousens Republican Re- Re publican of Michigan was wa actuated actuated ed cd by a l personal In hi his II of ot the tho th lr tury do- do de department Reed need charged that the ih he had made mad h a false fahe tab slat state meat ment In hi his message when he h stat stat- stai- stai stated ed ad the tho treasury department is sas s asunder under attack Walsh said the th prest- prest I president dent a message was waa the th m mot most st ar- ar r- r sinco inco tho days ot at t the th Tudors Tudora and ond It seem scorns said laid Walsh that the president Is denouncing the senate enat It exposed Albert rail Fall RII the th horrible administration ot of the th Yet vet crall s 8 bureau and ond t Is 11 nor no exposing cot I In Ule tue th of 01 I Justice C DISTILLER Ul i McKellar who line has A d resolution challenging Mellon light 10 o hold office oftie Because of his large business holdings that Mellon was as as one one of ot the big big- biggest Kest bic-Kest jest gest distillers of whisky hisky in ene United Hatt'S lid end that this ibis SC- SC accounted SCouted ac accounted counted for no real effort at pro pro- pro prohibition enforcement en In his of the th Coolidge mel mc Sage c Senator benator He 1 said Mid that It should should hould never ner n er have hav been given elven the tb I COUl of a reception b the Ule sen- sen senate en-at en ate ote and that It It should hould be Ignored lenored As to the Inquiry of ot the tho th Couzens committee ho said aldi it The Tho Th committee had a 0 special pedal i roson tor for an ling to look took Into the th 1 I books of ot the Mellon companies It If of ot fo favors ors had b ben been en ad- ad adduced a there thero would ou Id I lise li vc e cause for tor ousting Mellon Mollon fro tro ii 1 i If of office f fice flee It If business is straight It If busI- busI busIness ne busl-ne ness neI a Is I honest honed the man mall It would welcome welcom an lion It IC the man has something to hide ho ho- i fars l ar an investigation FL ChOP TL j In his Ills defense of the th presidents president's attitude Senator Watson Vatson old the senate that Senator Couzens em plo ed ell Francis J Henc Hency Heney II a Call- Call fornia attorney as a an n Investigator at the sUgGestion of Governor Olf foid Od ot of o PennI Penn long II tile tho outs with Mellon lollon 1 and that had Injected himself In- In Into into In Into to the Investigation The Tha revenue and all nil thee ther other t I lions bre aimed at President Cool Cool Cool- j- j Idle Id go The Tha Th whole thing Is an a aulton on the th president These arron Ii g Continued Oi Oil On Page P BO T o 4 X REED CLAIMS OAL INSULTS U S SENATE Continued From Page Pie One have all aU been aimed at hIs hi Cool Cool- CoolIdge Cool Idge II a breast bre but today the they th y lie broken at his hi feet The Thy They have found no flaw In his armor and armor they wll find none nn While this debate was wal In r teas ss the th ral real Issue over which the tho president and the senate tell fell out was h held ld In abeyance that Is 10 the employment of Honey Hene by Couzens at his own expense Th The resolution of Senator Wat Wet Watson Watson Wetson son th the Inv investIgating committee was held over because e of th the serious Illness tunes of Couzen Cuzens while hll a resolution by Senator Sentor Jones Democrat of t New Mexico authorizing th the employment of Zeney Heney was Wu sent went to f th the committee on audit and control where an er of- of fort will III he mid mide t to pigeonhole tt It WANO SPEAKS I WASHINGTON April 12 12 W A Senator Senator Watson Vatson today Informed his colleagues that Senator Couz- Couz Cousens Cou ens I ens had bad told him the th Suggestion I for Honey Heney ys y's employment had como come from Governor The Th mch- mch Ill n MIch-lian MIch senator las nas a still confined d to his home Iome horn by ty serious and no attempt to t bring brine any resolution pending In the th controversy wee was made In his absence t The Th Indiana In lana senator said Benz Sena- Senator tor r Couzens Couzen would confirm the statement that Pinchot had hod Intervened Int In th the situation end added that hat both h he a and nd d Mellon Mollon knew w what that meant ment H Ito He knew know and anel I k know ow said Id Senator Watson that from that moment th the ho purpose pur o of th the In inquiry ulry became and not CD con con con- The Indiana senator said paid that the lie change of scenery cen ry which Pinchot and Into the picture meant ment not only the ex- ex exploration cx ot of Secretary E cr tary Mellons Mellon's vat rl-vat vate affairs but S I that every activIty activity ity of the th prohibition 11 unit nIt would b be brought before this commit committee committee tee Ever bod knows that with ith S1 Sir It q Pinchot and Mr Heney Heny bacK of It there would be b no end to the reso- reso resolution r lution Senator Warren con tin u i There Thera woul b be thrown out a dragnet of so gossip lp and nd scandal l iu and corn come about an era ern of vituperation unequalled In th the political annals of AmerIca At another r point Senator Watson Wet Wet- Wetson son said sald Mellon lellon Is not being attacked at- at attacked attacked tacked for Mollon's Mollen sake I e but h i a An effort to get th the tho president Mr Mellon Is th the main support or of Mr and Mr f fr Coolidge will undoubtedly be b the tb leader Isador r on this side aide In the tho th corning comIng campaign he l Investigation of the tho Internal ro nu bureau burcu had thus far shown that organization to be effIcient capable and eaSy eady tor for the tho th huge huz tasks with which It deals dealo Sella Senator tor Warr n said Bald No good p pur- pur pur r- r pose poso could come corn from front continUing the Inquiry he be a added ded and end much evil might result Ho H served no no- no notice tice that he ho would press pres his resolution resolution tion Ion to 10 discharge the th committee I from It Its task asIc Renewed Democratic onslaught i ended finally when Senator Cara ra Caraway Caraway way Democrat Arkansas Inter Inter- Interjected n tI a warning to his patti party col col- col coli i leagues that from Wat- Wat Watson at son oon on s statement It appeared app that this was os a Republican family row with Pinchot hitting o er 0 or cllon's head at President Cool Cool Cool- idge Tn Tao Arkansas senator el raid aid 1 It might b be well ell for tor th the to keep kep out of It |