Show MAN WHO fiXED UP DEAL IS S NO AfiE AGENT JT Supreme Court Dismisses Dismisses' John A. A McAllister From All Responsibility In tho the State Supreme Court Tuesday an un opinion was handed down In time the case casc of oC A. A g 13 11 Cranney and unit others respondents dents against John A. A McAllister lc appellant ap aJl ap- ap I reversing time the Judgment of or J Judge W. W W. W V. V Maughan Iau of oC tho the 11 First District Court Lo Logan an the tho ease case Involving wing vinE the time title to a u portion of oC a 1 block of oC 1 shares shar's of or time the capital stock of ot the time Silver Copper Mining compan com cons pan pany Time The opinion was written by Justice William McCarthy and is Ig concurred con con- currell in b by the other oilier Justices The rhe persons named as ns plaintiffs in inthe inthe the tho original case all 0 of whom resided at Logan LOJan at the time time of tho time transactions are arc A. A r E. E N. N W W. Kim Kim- ball Joseph E. E E Cardon CuIlon Melvin Melvln J. J Bel- Bel lard Louis S. S Cardon CUIdon Jn Jacob oh West Vet John JohnP P P. Cardon Robert Murdock l I I. I. I C. C FarrA Farr Fan A If II H. Palmer and W. W V. V O. O Davis About November 8 S 1906 1900 Hob Robert rt Murdock moot met R. R H. H Wilson 1 limn Wilson lIson representing himself himself him him- self as the time owner of or an un option to purchase pur pur- chase valuable mining property in Nalla Nevada Nevada Ne Ne- vada alla for fOI Murdock entered Into an agreement to raise in Logan on tIm till understanding that the subscribers sub Rub sell scribers should ha have haC C a U one one-h one orie h Interest for each 1000 in the tho mining property Several of oC the persons named took tool stock In the company compan In all an to the amount of or and was turned over to Wilson Subsequently McAllister l who had Invested In went to Wilson to ascertain when the time deal would be he closed and learned that Wilson Wilson Wil VII son hind had ha only an agreement giving him himan himan himan an option opton A controversy contrO later luter arose nrose between Wilson and the holders of the written option litigation bein being threatened and McAlIster offered to fix up matters for Wilson VIson with tho timo other oilier people I Wilson on offered McAllister shar shares of or stock stock- to fix maters matters On account of the tact fact that time they alleged 1 that McAllister McAlster was waR acting a as their agent th time tho Logan loJan people demanded of oC McAllister that he account to him for the time entre entire shares which had hall been given l to Wilson lson in including In- In eluding 00 shares sharIs which J A. A B. B Cranno Cran Gran ne ney no- noone one of or the complainants purchased purchased purchased pur pur- pur- pur chased from Wilson McAllister re refused refused re- re fused and the suit HUI was vas entered Time The district court gave Kave e a Jud Judgment ment against a. McAllister for Cor a pro rata shuro share of oC shares McAllister then appealed The Time court ourt decides that tho the record does not miot uphold time the contention of time the other Logan people that McAllister r acted as 18 their a agent or trustee The Time Judgment of oC the lower court Is IN reversed and the time case remanded to the tho court below with wih directions to dismiss It I. I Costs are pl placed ced on Cranney and amid others othel |