Show 1 Experts Differ Materially t I on on American All-American Eleven S 5 DY uv MANHATTAN I New York or Jan Jail 5 While i UK- UK football football foot foot- ball Ni season on lm over i some ome lit little i I tie tle o how now the I discussion as aN to which of oC the We players rA have v most moat t distinguished themselves cs huts has not coa ceased od A 4 study of or th selections of or tho ho va various va- va iOuS rious exports experts for fol the theU American All U I elevens shows ShO this result for tor first and amI second teams First team Princeton I L L. E E. I Drapor Draper Pennsylvania l I L. L T. T 1 Thompson I Cornell L C J. J G. G Grant Harvard confer codler Ziegler P Pennsylvania It n. G. G Yale Yale- It n. T. T i Ex Carlisle R R. R E. E I harlan Princeton I I. II H. Carlisle Carlisle Car Car- lisle R R. II n. Co Coy Yale F. F B. B Tad Jonca Jones i Yale Q B. B Second team Hague Navy y 1 I I J. 13 Il Cornell I J. Ii T. T ErwIn Army I L G. G Phillips Princeton center conter Dunn Burr Harvard nJ It U. G G. Syracuse StI R. R T. T I Alcott Yale It H. E. E Wendell J Harvard r 1 J. J II LI Pennsylvania R. R II If McCormIck Princeton 1 P. P 15 n. Dillon Princeton Q II n. I I These certainly do make two t mi mighty hl good tennis teams un Walter Camp whoso Judgment Judg mon mont ment t of a n football ll player Is as good oo as ns that o of any man mall In America and whose I opportunity for Judging ln the playing plain capacity of oC the men is unsurpassed I makes maltes a somewhat som different lineup Ills selections are arc interesting and aro are as ns follows rollow First team eam eam Dogue Annapolis L. L E. E 1 Draper Drapor Pennsylvania I I. I b. b T. T 1 1 Ziegler Pennsylvania I I. I G. G Michigan lIch nn Is-nn center Erwin West cst Point R. R G. G BIlow BIglow Big Big- low Yale R. R T. T Alcott Yale R. R 13 E. T Jones Yale Yal Q B. B Wendell Hu Harvard Hurr rr I Ii I. B. B Harlan Princeton R. R B. B MeCot Princeton P. P B. B Second I team oam me Carl Carll Carlisle Isle le L. L 13 E. horn Harr Syracuse L. L T. T Rich Dartmouth Dartmouth Dartmouth Dart Dart- mouth I J. G- G Grant Harvard center centor I Thompson Cornell R. R G. G I Cornell R. R T. T Scarlett Pennsylvania R. R D. D Dillon I Princeton Q B. B Dartmouth I 1 L. L It n. Hollen Pennsylvania Penn I sylvania unla 1 It ft B. B Coy Yale Y P. P B. B 1 notice that President David Starr r lords Jordan rt a Hi i t 1 Stanford university I In lit out In u it violent attack cl on football and I sings sing the old song about tho brutality of oC ho tho game amo and the tho premium It places place on brute strength th It must have havo been beena a lon long n ago o that Professor Jordan was a 0 boy When a blooded lull healthy young oun follow does 1005 not feel reel the disposition to measure strength th o of muscle mus mus- cle do and nd against his fellows It its it's to send for tor the doctor for Cor there thore is la surel surely something tho matter with him As a n. n matter of ot fact tact American football is neither brutal not nor is 19 it a amere amere mere meto question of or brute strength It U u. of course no game for tor weaklings weak weak- lings hins or 1 what a a. distinguished man mati has called colled mollycoddles in a J. J while whilo a n player lr Is hurt pretty pratt badly but it I Is Isa isa a rare tImIng thing that a 11 well trained player r plarIs Is seriously I hurt certainly as rare anIn an anIn In un any other out of ioor sports which are arc not denounced as brutal and I t am amnot amnot amnot not at nt all sure suro thai hint it does docs not do a aboy abuy ahoy buy boy good to be hurt once In lii a 3 way war It teaches him fortitude anti and strengthens his courage o. o As to the bruto brute strength proposition let Professor Jordan pick eleven cloven of or the tho strongest men bo ho can Mini and pit pH them a against any of the American All elevens which have been picked out t and see Reo the score would he SIt S It Il has 1138 been heen a n. source of comment that the lie wonderful showing of the Carlisle team learn on the gridiron Is duo In a a. largo large measure to the tho ho fact that tho eligibility rule which cuts short tho ho football ca career career en- en reer neon of ot tho men In In Inthe the other colleges does not apply to tho the In Indian Now V the rules at nl Carlisle are arc to ho bo chan changed pl and the lie Indians will be C on all fours with the tho colleges against which they play The he Carlisle Athletic tlc association I has hils Is Issued Is- Is sued s a statement which says Rays among other thin timings things s It lt is a fact that not a n. single test protest has come como to Carlisle from rom a a. cr lt or oa college cOllego that has hns met tho the Indians n this year car either as ns to their eligibility or tho the conduct of or tho the players Tho The term of or enrollment at Carll Carlisle lc I I ib five years and students often orton rema remain In longer and hare havo been allowed to rep rp resent Carlisle in athletics n as long Ion ns s they thoy have havo been boen here There Thero were two t members of this years year's football tomi who had played more moro than four years ear This being tho thin case caso and there having haying hay hav ing been perhaps somo some unjust nl as 89 to the tho length of or line players were allowed to represent Carlisle C nn and alsoto also I to tho the custom of or playing Indian em cm- it has boon been decided to enact and I enforce eligibility ru c rules ules preventing sm any Iny student representing Carlisle In football football foot Coot ball more than four years and providIng pro provid- Ing that only regularly enrolled students sib stu dents anti and not shrill shall bo Lo permitted POI per milled to pIn play |