Show A Ri t RECEIVES mm Judge Morse 1 ells Easterner Few Things Thin s After Court h t Session r ALLISON GETS DAMAGES S Joseph Martin Says Practices Need Aid of Metropolis Talent i Eastern lawyers are aro far and away better than those of the West accord accord- lug hip to former Judge Joseph Martin attorney for or Russell So S go Raphael and nd others who lio ma made do the tho declaration before be be- fore ore Judge Morse yesterday In a suit to recover costs of recent litigation In which Martin was not onty defeated hut but was severely rebuked by the court for his questionable methods The Tho affair came Caine U up when E. E M. M Al Allison A- A lison jr ir of Allison van an Colt anti and attorneys for the Rio itlo ando th-ando Western sought to have the tho costs taxed against Martins Martin's clients Martin came back with witha n a motion to reLax the cost against the legal department of the tho Could system s st m Martin had been appearing for Raphael Ra Ita- and and others in an action against tho Wasatch and Jordan Valley rail rall- road load tho branch of the Rio Grande Judge Morse recently granted their application for the appointment of 11 a receiver for the road to satisfy an old Judgment arid a V T t- t Inter ho re his decision on theS the S ground that he had not been properly Informed in the matter Notwithstanding ing this reversal Martin took charge of the road and advertised ad zt its sale He Hewn wn wait later held In contempt of court by Judge and was roundly rebuked for his work O er Costs During Martins Martin's examination cross of Allison the New York k attorney sought id to make Allison admit that ho know very little ot of law hut the tho Salt alt Luke Lake sidestepped every law point and put them up to the tho for opinions Martin said Raid that the tho Western liar needed some New York attorney to come out hero anti and show the members the tho way to practice law The procedure pro pin he held was bad In the tho West WesL All of Martins Martin's attempts to show that Allison knew knos' nothing of the entire matter were carefully dodged He Its paid aid that his office had signed the bill of costs and assumed that it wn n correct It developed that A A. L L. Mullins a specia special cia cial agent for the Rio Grande had Imd charged mileage to Junction three times whereas he should have charged tot for only one trip Upon point Martin secured a slight reduction hut but otherwise he ho lost last out entirely The Tho Upshot of it nit all v. v was aa that the court awarded Martin in costs and ordered hi to pity pay Allison 24 2450 SO Bi B the transaction the New Nw York at attorney cit torney torrey loses 2010 20 10 Court Him Do flown n. n That the tho decorum i of courts Is Li looser In New York than In the West if Martins Martin's Martins Martin's Mar Mar- tins tin's actions may be taken as on ex example ox- ox ample was shown after Judge Morse had made the entry regarding costs He lie tried to argue argue- his case caseIn casein In asking Questions of the he w Attorney Attorney At At- torney Allison and the tho grown impatient him hini to desist When it was nil all over Martin remarked ed that 1 v fae be vry glad wh n tho whole sinIc the tho 1 a Then Martin continued to talk about the ease case keeping other attorneys watt watt- tag Inc for the for tho court to take up their matters mat mat- Judge Moras told the tho attorney several times that thai his hail had been settled lint but It didn't seem acorn to pierce the understanding ot of the wise wiseman man of the East The court lo lost t nl all tolerance anti and told him him to quit talking about it and give some one clo a chance chalice and the New York attorney left promising to appeal the tho whole business but busi Attorney AllIsOn the tho ness antI and pay money Monday vis MUST ANs' ANs Men In Con Con- holds Hold OH Oil Morup for to 0 Talk A. A V. V Taylor of J. J IT Richards and Salt Lake Oil company the contempt declared in were yesterday for refusing to answer questions questions ques ques- of court Smith In inthe before Referee Dana T T. the suit stilt of William M. M S against their company Judge Morse said SaIh of the matter The Tho court finds with relation to the first proceeding for contempt that the proceedings under which the tho deposition deposition tion was sought to he be taken wore were Ir Irregular irS ir- ir regular antI and not sufficient to constitute constituteS S S the tho parties In contempt With refer refer- cuce to the latter proceeding one thai wan argued taut last Saturday and submitted sub sub- the court finds linus that the witnesses wit wIt- nesses should have answered the oue cues cues- ions The court finds those questions were material The order of the court courtS S would be hail had the proceeding not been dismissed with reference to that matter mat mat- for ter that they be required to answer those questions or be committed to jail S until they saw lit fit to answer The necessity ne no- for the further taking of the deposition and the answering of the th questions has passed the proceeding In which the depositions wore wor being taken having been dismissed It further that the tho witnesses wit wit- nesses flosses acted under the advice of counsel court coun sel sl cud and able ablo counsel The counsel so far as the court is able ablo to view the tho was acting in good faith and advising them believing and still stUl be- be that the questions were not ant proper question though the lie court thirties thinks the questions wore were In view of that tle situation the court IB is not disposed ed ml to Inflict a punishment on the parties partIes par par- ties as for a it wilful contempt and the tho order may be that they pay the tho costs of the tho proceeding While the witnesses wore not punished pun pun- they will ill now have to answer the questions before the referee This S testimony Involves a stock transaction In which is Interested HP lie sued the company for for far re refusing refusing re- re fusing to issue to him certain stock and to deprive him of certain rights be lie claims to hold In the properties prop of the company |