Show I II UI lII i FARMERS WIN OUT IN IM SMELTER CASE GASE nor Circuit Court of Appeals Sustains Sustains Sustains Sus Sus- Injunction Issued by Judge Marshall NOW FOR SUPREME COURT I If Decision Is Aga Again n I Big Plants Must Move From V Valley ley i i The smelters In Iii Salt Lake Lako valley I I will viii have o to move That Thal In effect Is time the sub substance tance of or oran an aLl opinion n handed down own this lila week by th the tho circuit court of or appeals at St. St Paul Notice of this tILls order sustaining tho ito opinion of or Judge John A. A Marshall Marshall Mar Mar- shall of or the federal court wa was r re received ie cd in a n. letter to An Andrew 4 rew Howat Friday a afternoon It IL is not nut known what action tho the smeller companies will take but bUl It Is generally en rull believed that the they will ap appeal ap ap- peal to the supreme court of ur tho the United States Sta Thy The case cape has been be before be- be fore COIC the courts for fOl nearly two years and amid Its Hs termination will be watched walche with Interest by farmers all ull over oyer tho the valley ns os well veil as Ol by smelter men muon who arc are Interested In time tilt three plants af af- af the the Highland Do Boy at nt Murray and time the United States Slates and amid Bingham Consolidated at Junction Time Tiro of if Smoke Suits Suit I IThe The TIme history of or the case case- is interestIng interest- interest Ing lug For years e r tho the farmers of or tho the valley have brou ht suits sulb lh I I three smelters rs zis zi's us well as against A A. A S. S It H II at Murray for damages to live 11 stock und and crops Hundreds of ur thousands of ur dollars have b bt ben en paid out b by liy tho ho smelter m He companies to farmers farm tarm ers CL'S for several rn years ca caA A movement was Vas finally filially set on foot Coot whereby tho the farmers Joined han hands s In bringing suit against the thC smelters r to enjoin them from operating on account of or the time del deleterious dele effects A fund was created and V W. II If lUng King and J J. J L Li L. were engaged as counts counsel b by the thc farmers who had ben been Injured Tho rho case caso was aM fought stubbornly stub stub- in Judge Marshalls Marshall's court butI but butan an cllon was fiR van d rt- rt C- C Cun un for r- r the smelter rc companies was v s Dickson Ellis Kills Ems Sutherland Van Colt Cott AlIl Allison on Street D.-arnel D. au anti ana Howat MacMIllan Ono Ommo hits Hug lou Houses Thou Though h the time original l light vas vias against un alu t time tho Arnert American nn Soliciting H Se c Re tOuting A ta t much at nu against oilier 9 f rg thIs c com company man m- m puny pany an uRi to 10 put liv tn bag baj house and to mal other otlie u In 11 in lt it Its at nt Hurray Muriah would do 10 3 u away a in iii large Jare measure UlO with the emIssion omission ernie omis sion of or pol smoke from rain the Sri great lent sm smokestacks ke to tu the ac nc action action ac- ac tion Uon of this imP company the time furni farmers rs of or orthe the lie scratched it H front from rom the UstanlI list arid continued tho light against tho other three companies When hun the injunction was grant granted by y Judge ral Marshall holl the time smelter Interests ga gave gass ganotice notice of or appeal and filed tiled a u. bond bone of oC for tor a stay ot of execution for tor forSO toro SO o da days 8 In which time line to prepare an appeal I. I The rhe decision of or the ho court of appeals I l a signal vIctor victory for em time the farmers of or the he thea a valley H e and as ns soon as a cop copy of or the tho papers is i received here they hex wIllbe will wUl willbo bo be tiled Hied in Ia Ju Judge go Marshalls Marshall's court fr the purpose of instating insIsting on the en enforcement enforcement en- en of the time Injunction Jf if this action Is Js taken thu the smelters will bo bc forced to close chose down perIn permanently |