Show FIVE VOTES FOR COMMISSiON BILl BIU U Robinson Grows Excited Over Critchlow's Arguments in ill House WARMEST DAY OF SESSION Smoot Resolutions Criticizing State Senate is Withdrawn U by Thompson U Factions clashed yesterday In lh tho Utah Uw house of rc representatives i pl cs and on the floor of or th the li house use a battle royal royalIn In 10 n words took place After the f smoke c cand and iad cleared a away wa after representatives tn- tn tives haJ had sai said mean things about each cach other after uter the 11 decision chion of the chair had hail h been en appealed al from rom and after the final Onal vote ote had been announced tile the hOll house ico had practically killed the railroad commission bill n Representative had bad his vote 01 changed e d the n final nn I vote vole was announced anti and moved 1110 for fOl a 0 10 rc con of the hill bill to today tolay The Theote vote ote stood 34 to Ii 5 In favor mor o of adapting adapt ing lug the unanimous I report of ot 1 the lIw railroad rail road committee committe a against aln l the passage of tho the bill In lit the heat o of the argument Representative Rep flop rl Robinson beat hi his hll fist upon Ills is desk des an and demanded that Representative s e a lh lc to the truth Their dl disagreement ment threatened action but was brought to a n. close b by bytho tho ho speakers speaker's gavel Representative Kuchler ma made e a ater bitter bit t ter r attack upon th the bill and Representative made matie a n. long lon sp speech In favor a 0 l' l of the measure in h he hO rc recited ced th the railroad conditions concH condi as they exist at present sent I j I I I 1 From Decision icU lie nl al aHo ahto o was ivan called to an account for foran foran an all ae alleged ml nl A number I of motions motions- were vere made Haell and arid ruled out nut of Order although they were sere put hOt again nOd and again Warmed mme up b by the action Representative r e tat I ye hot holl hotly ly demanded de th landed n-landed an appeal Jeal from from the tIll decision ion ionI of or If the chair an and Ii WJ was defeated T the door thrown open Opel lJ by Mr iti Critchlow de h Ilg that tie Uie report of oj the committee be le rejected the he bill was op opened nell up for discussion jn on 00 H its merits Many of the members member tell fell cli to th Ia a lip UP line r l J j iy i 1 Ik to lo d lII rl iJ ii- ii n Is toj li I Vi t I WL taken not a co CO member re 1 registered IC- IC red t a 1 vote fI In Jn favor lavor of or the bill Dining the me arguments the speaker p l' l and thu tho numbers l and squab squabbles bles bie over w-re w After m making r a. a statement before the h house OLISe YI tl r 1 te rt t ta he Thompson asked that hii hi rt resolutions the state tah senate for Tor not passing paR resolutions resolution of congratulations s to the United States for rOl senate enat sus- sus sus-I sus taming Senator Reed 11 Smoot and ul also o congratulating the tho senator upon U I taming hl his seat ut seat b be withdrawn Tuu Tiu house u rd eth the action to 0 h b. b t taken t l ln The Thc trouble 0 over Ove 1 the tilE i COIn COIn- com coin mission bin bill commenced wh when a molion mo 1110 lion tion was wis made mad to tn have l all the hG cum cumi l i mittet- mittet J j C adopted tI as its A Hy By B tIle the t of or Mr Mi- Critchlow IT 11 1 n B. B 1 16 G. G the thit commission lon bill was i. i an nil exception I ton I I Ts uns un's to 14 After th the motion had carried tal Mr Critchlow secured the floor and anti moed moved mo ed ell that the report of or th tilt the committee on the hill bill be bt I rejected jl and ami that the bill lull ho placed on II the calendar Rep Rep- rN e Maughan th then moved alia as ali asa asa a tub substitute that tho the of the committee be IH a adopted I have t a petition from Crom people a asking asling for fOI this his measure I 41 Mr Ir Ci I I do 10 not believe e It Is f fair rr ih that l they should hI not ha have haa a lo to see sec why we ta tak taice 01 this ac cc- tiC tion oNo No O one e ought to lo be ashamed I ac-I to stand standup Up tip bore bent all and an answer anel el to lo roll call callon on In thI measure All ought to have tie the manhood to vote vole l Representative e Tolton declared that he was In jn favor of a roll 1011 call on tile the t measure nn and that if five members i should hould ask it would wO be granted II lie declared that he bc believed lI lIe e It would be 10 bean ben an n lp to tile the committee to lo r reject the t h repOt report 1 U j I 1 im afraid ld no not to stand up us and tell the peOple wh why I J sign signed U d that r re- re lP Jl poi lb I Isaid said n Representative H I Kuchler I t want vant to say y that J I am ant not he here representing Ie nU rig a a- a few ew merchants but bu t all all the people of or state 4 1 2 Ogden at the e present nt time lime has s a many 11 railroads aa as i ne needs d but ll I have eliminated m my own pcr onal In int In- In t tt and am 1111 lick here h. h to vote ott ott for fOI what I the majority of the tile people of f the state de desire he I 11 J want tant to 81 say iy that r T have ha tion lion gained from a diligent t l rt auto to the success o of the railroad oath commis sion u. u Wi as t to tp Its success In lItal states and failure allure Ir in m more moio I Are we not riot hI here iier to b build nil up y-thO y tho trite state and tala take no chances chalce Hill Hn It was AVOS then that thiat pJ r U IT S 'S C C Jensen n secured the floor hIt Ife told toI of the commission now flow b being n lIR used used used-ui in it 33 states tates a and n asserted that it i was Was' e t sue sue- I. I jf Kuchler w wanted to 1 now know from the 8 l p t the he success a of or the railroad In the sute of ot Tc as tn that h he was wai opt fire fire- nn pared to lo an ver Crichlow a J that h he might answer and did cUd SJ with witha wih l a a- a question que ton h WU AVas n i ou out of ur jf tuh order rel U I cn IJ then thep thol w went ent nt on ni 01 to Li- explain explain- th it t It the tw Uli was Wn sine one Of- Of of gI ance and that At t ire tin y was waH In II the grasp of th the the- railroads r He Ic Heat at VC IH that th the Ut railroads 1 could a aV nay onY tIme lime make malco Denver the point of shipment In Instead o of Suit Salt Sui Lol Lake t CH City Cily and anti thereby discriminate te ut the tile In Interstate In- In C commission would b. b be hi- s lO to to t top stop it It 1 lie further l lt c that hat at the present time hue somo c are un from frol the theand lr and tp the smaller towns r tah tl t H Hi It i could cnut Il he hlll- hlll Sll Lal LI Lake lt I. I leI lee J iII an On 11 instance n shouted 1 Koch Kuch- 1 VV by 11 r bM can h l be l Continued oi on oi page 2 FIVE VOTES FOR COMMISSION BILL Continued from from paso page 1 I. Omaha to Green River for less lut than It can he be shipped from rom Salt Lake City declared Jensen It SIt now costs five o cents a keg more from Salt Snit Lako Lak than from Omaha Croft wanted to know If the state Commerce commission could not nol remedy that Jensen replied d that a state commission commission com corn mission could remedy It Robinson's Robinsons Ready Retort That hug boo was exploded in tho committee said flo Robinson inon Tho Thin matter mutter was taken talen up several da days s 's agas ug ag ago as to the tilt rate and it was found to bo lH false raise and Salt Lake beer belr shippers are not charged more moio Kuchler demanded that J Jensen produce pro pro- duce records on his statements Jensen th then thon n nent went ent on to declare that I Ithe the tho poop people Ie should have some seine one 11 protect I heir theil rights Ho lIo declared tJ that Wide under the commission tho the commissioners commis would have the right to In Investigate investigate in- in all wrecks and ascertain whether the rights of or th the people had been infringed ed upon At th the tho pre present ent time he said ald railroads discriminated d against the small and drove him out of or business lIe He declared that the they could n against the small cities and II in preference to lo the tho large largo cities Critchlow then secured tho the floor and declared that thai he lie had been treated treated treat treat- ed cd discourteously In not hot being appointed appointed appointed ap ap- ap- ap pointed a n member of or the railroad but bitt further statements along this line were cut short by Kuchler raising a point of or order Jensen Jonsen moved that the matter betaken bo be taken up UI Monday This motion wa was ruled out of order ordel as there wa was wa a t substitute substitute sub sub- motion before bore the house Left Out of tho lie Part Party Mr Critchlow then thon went vent on nn to ex explain tx cx- plain that he was tol told that he should be Invited to the Ow m meeting eting of the tho committee com coin on the question He lie declared that he was only asked ell to one meeting meeting meet meet- ing InS which he supposed was to be bp a aL L private one nt af the committee Much luch to his surprise he lie declared he found round one of the greatest railroad in Salt Lake City there I J. should have been Invited to these meetings h ho he commented In a second Representative Robinson Robin Robin- son was on th the floor and shouted I r demand that Mr sir Critchlow adhere to 0 the truth He Tic was invited ll to the meetings Tho first meeting was not notto notto notto to be a n private meeting He should not say tay what he Is saying Robinson beat his hi fist upon his desk esl an and looked defiantly at Mr Mi Critchlow again as attempted to reiterate his but bill was ruled out of or order er by the speaker In III a C few WOI words 8 Helne Representative Cle Clegg gd g- g d declared that he ho was unprepared to vote ote and declared it would be cowardly coward coward- I ly to a adopt opt the report A motion to again have hare the matter laid over o was declared out of or order er J. J M. M 1 Mills lills then spoke against the bill 4 A surprise was sprung when Representative Representative Tolton declared that hint the tho proper time to make objections ha had passed and that the bill had been laid open for foi discussion by the Critchlow motion and anti that the men ha had exhausted exhausted ex ex- hausted their time in discussing the no i-no motion t 10 n. n I Not ot Ready Ready to to Vote Yote A squabble then started over o some of the members not being being- read ready to vote Tolton replied that the bIB had b been en In their files tiles for forty days as a's rind and tho they should be prepared bd-prepared prepared at nt any time Marks s asked th that action be deferred It was ruled out of order b by the chair and Representative Critchlow demanded demanded de tIe- an appeal Tolton was called to the chair and put the motion which was as lost When the speaker again resume resumed the chair there was another clash between between between be be- tween the speaker sneaker and Critchlow In a short address Maughan l closed the debate In voting fi five o of the members asked that they be allowed to explain their vote The motion to adopt the hc report was adopted b by the thc following followings Ayes Acs Carnett Darnell Benson Bower Dower Cottam Critchlow Croft Davis Dean Dyreng El dredge Fuller Puller Giles Hanson hansen Hendricks Holt Hott Jackson Ku Larson Lanon Long McMillan McRae Maughan Mills Parry Pany Pedersen Randall Robinson on Sutton Sulton Thompson Tolton Weston Yeston Westphal l. l and Joseph Clegg g. Nephi Jensen Marks larks Miller and Rich Rich- ards Ab Absent ent and not voting yoUng Downs Dorms Dorius s. s Mecks Meeks Hone and Taft Those voting yoUng against the adoption of the re report report report re- re I port were welo Clegg Jensen N U U. S S. S C. C Marks larks Miller and Richards |