OCR Text |
Show TIIE JIORXINU' EXAMIXEI!: OUDKX, UTAH, WEDNESDAY, OECHAfiD IS BY HAYWOOD'S Orchard denied In turn haring nix.le 3ieunnlrg R. Redd, W. lo a fevij Oaates. F. Earteriy and V. F. Davit. The JefeiUf here offered In evidence two of the rogue!' guller? picture of Orchard taken after hi tor the murder oT Guvernur The picture bhow Urehaid in a garb iwmbliug that of a tramp, unahaveu and unkempt. . Attorney Klchardaon aaid the picture were offered to ahow the jury the condition vf Orchard at the time the murder a contrasted with hi apptarauce today. Wood admitted the photograph Juige and they were handed to the jurors, who examined them c lovely. Another picture of Orchard, in a group of three men, one holding a smoking revolver, was alto introduced In evidence by the defenae. The picture was taken la 19ul. Orchard said the picture was taken as a nov-thCoeur d'Alenes trouble tiover-no- r Bteunenberg and that this nun had driven you out of the count r) and you Intended to kill him?" "No. air. 1 didn't say just that, neither la aubatanre nor effect. There w converaation in w hich Governor , a Steunenberg's name was mentioned. Orchard next was confronted by Charles A. Sullivan, a miner from Cripple Creek. He aaid he knew Sullivan, but denied having a couverua-- ; tion with him la which he said Gov- -' eraor Bteunenberg ought to be killed, or would be killed, and If he was not killed. Orchard would kill him himself. Orchard successively denied having had similar cou versa lion with Fred Hough of Wallace. Janice Rainey, a suge driver, and Lottie Day, a woman he knew in Denver. "Did you tell lxttrte Day that you ' had some money In Petti bone's store that you had got from gambling?" "No, air. elry. His companions were Andy and Peter Christiansen. In bia direct testimony Orchard told of making a trip into the Vindicator mine with a man named Joe Bcholtx. Confronted today by a man giving his name aa Sctaolta, Orchard said he was , not the person of whom he had spoken. Then came the first witness for the defense Mrs. Marv J. King, who formerly conducted a rooming house in Cripple Creek. Mrs. King, an elderly, refined woman, with gray pompadour, was examined by Clarence Dar-raShe first told of her family, saying she' had several grown son who are miners, hut are not now and never were members of the union. Mrs. King aaid that K. C. Sterling, chief of detectives for the Mine Owners' association of Colorado, lived at her house In Cripple Creek. Bhe saw Orchard visit his room seven or more times, generally in the evening. Sterling engaged and paid for a room enpied by Mrs. McKinney, the wife of the man charged with pulling the , spikes on the Florence A Crlpplq Creek railroad the attempted wreck .which the union claims the railroad officials and Mine Owners undertook themaeirea with the Intent of placing the blame on the Western Federation of Miners. Mr. King said she saw Orchard knocking several tlniea on i.Mra. McKinney's door. of the witi, The ness conainted of but afew question tending closely to fix tha date of the King house. Sterling's atay Mias Frances K. King, n daughter of the preceding witness, took the stand and Identified pictures of Orchard aa !.ihe man she had seen In the vicinity of the house in Cripple Creek several times. She was not end gave way to Mrs. Alice Fltshugh, who succeeded Mrs. King aa proprietress of the Star rooming house. that Detective Mrs. Fitrhugh said Sterling continued to live In the house for some time after she took charge. She saw Harry Orchard go to Sterling's room at least a dosen time. She also saw McKinney, accused of the spike pulling, in Sterling' room following his release from jail. On cross examination, Mrs. Fits-hng- h aaid ahe kept no record of her roomers and was testifying wholly from memory. C. W. Alter of LeadvlUe, Colorado, formerly a telegraph operator in the employ of the Florence A Cripple Creek Railway, was the next witness. He told of seeing Harry Orchard, K. C. Sterling and D. C. Scott, a detective of the railway company, together In Scott's room at the Cripple Creek depot. He saw him there twice before the attempted train wreck. Alter said he On could not rememlier what time of day it was that Orchard first rame to the depot, tie did not know whether Scott and Orchard bad ever met before. Aliev said his recollection was not very clear, as the matter had made no particular impression on him. Alter said he could not remember the dates of Orchanl'a visits even aa to the approximate time with reference to the train wreck. "You are just guessing a built the matter, aren't you?" aaid Attorney Haaley, for the state, and you are not sure about anything? I am only sure about it being Orchard, replied the witness. Two of the wilneaaes desired by the defense were not in the room and an early luncheon adjournment until ' 1:80 p. m. was ordered. Ira Bllsard of Cripple Creek, a railway conductor and yard master, was called to the stand, aa the first witness' after recess. "Did you testify before the United State ram mission appointed to investigate the Cripple Creek disturb ance!? asked Mr. D arrow. No, air, replied the witness. Do you know K. C. Sterling? Tea, air The witness aaid he understood Sterling was In the employ of the Mine Owners' Association and he had communicated with Sterling. at the headquarters of the asaoclatkin. Bill-ar- d was contracting freight agent of the Florence A Cripple Creek railroad at the time of the Independence depot explosion. He immediately went there and saw the wire and chair rung whieh served aa dues.-Th- e defense claims the Independence depot was all but an abandoned affair, and that Its destruction might have been planned by others than the Western Federation of Miners. What sort of a depot was it?" nak ed Mr. Harrow of the witness. The depot was in good eondft.it replied. Bllxard. It was n nice, ur date station with a good wail morn. It had a platform in front ur-re- e 3 SCENE FROM THE TOY MAKERS GRAND THI Wood allowed the question to go in. Bllxard detailed the route taken by the dogs, who went toward Colorado Springs. At a water tank Biliard called up K. C. Sterling on the telephone. Senator Borah objected to any conversation between the witness aa hearsay. He declared that the defense had the right to show that asm one other than Orchard blew up tha Independence depot if It could, but the evidence must be competent and not hearsay, We expect to show, said Attorney Harrow In reply, that K. C. Sterling was responsible for the blowing up of the depot, that he knew all about it anl we expect to connect Orchard with the Mine Owners association. Upon that showing the evidence will be admitted;" declared Judge Wood. . BU-v- e n . cross-examine- cross-examinati- -- do not sWm to bp dioturbed. It is staled most positively (hai and relmitul will sliuw that the ha built up a clever fabrication that will fall uu.ltr reburial like a house of card. Ii is intimated that the surprises in this rase are not at an md, but that if the defense brings in witnesses to prove the claims tuade by counsel in the opening statement, the case for the state will be materially strer.gthened. A number of important witnesses for the Mate will be here within the next week sud wilt be called lu rebuttal. These will include possibly Cover nor Peabody and certainly Bulkeley Wells, the adjutant general of Colorado during the Cripple Creek troubles, and who dug up the Goddard bomb. Captain MeParland. of the Pinker ton detective agency, may also b a witness In rebuttal. It ha not yet been decided when Haywood, the defendant, will go on the stand to make his statement aa to the affairs of the Western Federation. Counsel for the defenae are as to the placing of Moyer, the president of the Western Federation, a a witness. It waa quits evident from the statements uiade by Mr. Darrow that the defense proposes to admit the connection between Or chard and Haywon.1 and the admit that Orchard was at tne time employ, ed by Moyer. Bui it is stated that all these connections were perfectly legitimate and had nothing to do with a conspiracy; that Orchard was a traitor and that be sought employ mem in ut the connection with the Western Federation tinder the guise of unlua workman and a member of tile Masonic fraternity, all the time being a detective employed by mine owners and their detectives. Wit nesses are here to testify that Orchard waa all hia life a gambler and a man who llvea easily, ready to do any crime for pay. Witnesses will he here to say that he did not poison WHICH WILL BE SEEN AT THE the milk at the Bradley home ana EVENING. that there wsa no bomb explosion there. Bradley, while he will not be aom oae to connect the malter here, has made depositions that tha with. expkmion was not caused by dyuanilte Judge Wood allowed the witness to but by gas. To offset this, the state give hia experience. Redd aaid he waa has expert testimony oa the possible arrested by several deputies on June effect of both gas and bomb explos4, 1903, and taken aboard a train to ions who will be oa the stand la Cripple Creek where he waa put In the bull pen and held four days The one great crime that the dewithout trial anil without any charge fenae admit that Orchard committed being laid against him. la the murder of Bteunenberg and by Mr. llawlry. through the whole of the tesRedd said he was a member of the running will be the motive Orchard timony Western Federation and had been a had- in revenge on the man, seeking member since the organisation waa who aa be thought, rubbed him of haJ, formed. It waa the day after the hla rlchea In the Hercules mine. depot explosion that he was The claim that the defense will rest taken to the bull pen. within eight days la looked upon aa officers were in at Military control aa the the bull pen where there were ISO quite speculative, many of their witnesses men confined, wheithe witness was probably will take considerable time. arrested. The aisle expects to take a week In Asked if he did not know that the rebuttal and the end of the case la not military were merely Investigating looked forward to with any degree of the matter and that as soon aa they until the last week in July. learned a man had nothing to do wifi cerjainty It he waa allowed to go. Read said he knew nothing about it at all. The witness was st Clyde, Colo., What a Mans Beard Telia. when arrested. He aaid he never had Tou can tell some of a mans habits seen Steve Adama until he came to read seme of bis traits of characBoise. Redd waa released by the and ter his beard, aakl the old bar from colonel commanding the bull pen If a msa spends his days at r who told him In leaving that if he her. waa molested to let him know and desk beside a window hla hair auT he would see that he waa released. beard will grow faster on the aide ta The witness said the colonel also ward the window. Plants and lieanl advised him that it might be a good both flourish under 'the Influence of plan to leave Cripple Creek while ex- sunlight Why, sue ef my customer, iling conditions prevailed. He left found the effects of the side light s two days later and has not been back pronounced that he changed hia office since. desk to face tho window. Another inCfiarles A. Sullivan, watchman at teresting fact is that, when a man U the Brown hotel, Denver, and a former miner in the Cripple Creek dis- up late or works long hours, lie needs trict, followed Redd on the witness a shave oftruer than' If ha look the stand. Sullivan aaid he knew Or- usual amount of sleep. Tliata becaime a chard at Cripple Creek, in 1902. He In being awake be keeps tiie vital then detailed the statement Orchard of Ms body in greater activity la alleged to have made to him and than when asleep. The growth of tiie which Orchard denied this morning. hair depends largely on the circulation Sullivan said Orchard declared that it of the blood, and the heart slows down had not been for Bteunenberg, he wbeu we sleep. Kansas jtwould City star. be rich, that Btennenberg ought to be killed, would be killed and If he Fog and Ssund. waa not UlleJ, he (Orchard), would In a fog at aea the toll of a hell kill him. Sullivan was by buoy la singularly grave and solemn, Senator Borah, He said he had well matched by the weird note of a known Haywood since 1903 end was whistling buoy, . Unfortunately the also acquainted with Moyer, though he value of both la lessened in foggy had never met Pettlbone. He Joined weather from there being but little the Western Federation of Miners In motion ef the see. Nothing, too. is 1902 and was acquainted with more difficult tbnn to distinguish In n a-- . fog the direction from which a Bound SURPRISES TO COME. comet. This lx In part due doubtless P rote cut ion in Haywood Casa Claim to to the interference offered to the straight rearer of the waves carrying Hava Evidence In Reserve. Boise, Idaho, June 25. Beginning the sound, tint also probably to tbs with the appearance of the first wit- absence of the normal, although unness for the defense on the stand to- suspected, of eye and day, the story of Harry Orchard's life ear in locating the origin of Bound. will be traced by a succession of wit- The assistance of the eye on tea and nesses Called, not to enataln, but to land Is instinctively given to the ear contradict all the material facts in different ways. In a fog to by the chief witness against the many ear has only Itself to trust ta Wm. D. Haywood. Orchard himself London Spectator. will be in court again today and counsel for the defense will lay the foundaDaseribing a Railroad. tion for hisr Impeachment. The Fall Mall Gasette in 1M0 asked The presentation' by Clarence Darrow, the attorney who la conducting its readers to name the worst railway the defenae, has cleared the stags in England. And ona English kicker for the new Interpretation of motive answered thus: Bir The Southeastern on the part iit the chief actor or, as railway is the very worst railway in the defense claims, the puppet who the world. The engines are asthmatic. played1 the principal part in the many Its lamps are trimmed by foolish virtragedies and stirring events, between the year 1899, when the trou- gins. Its fares are excessive. Its car bles In the Coeur dAlmes reached rlages let in the snow In winter and re furnaces In summer. Its motto b their height, and the close of 1905, when former Governor Bteunenberg nnpunctuallty. Its principal station i" was assassinated, followed by the ar- approached through the neck of a hot rest and confession of Orchard and tie. It rains the temper, destroys thr the arrest of Haywood, Moyer and digestion and enables one to realise tb Pettlbone, early in 1905. Harrow's horror of DaniCa Inferno. I am development of the motive the de- sir. yours obediently, the Worm Whi fense attributes to Orchard and bis Tnrns. explanation of the circumstances on which the state of Idaho baaee its Noncommittal. claim that he la guilty In common not guilty?" or "Gnllty bone conPetti with and Moyer of n Yes. the man at the tar. responded spiracy to murder the leaders In the Whats that? queried the court fight against the methods of the Western Federation, opens a field for con- sharply. Yon asked whether I was guilty or jecture. by which the defense claim they will, through their witnesses, be not guilty, and of rants I am. Of the able to completely convince the jury two conditions I could not well escape and the public that for years a conboth. spiracy existed among the mine ownBut which are you? ers and employers of labor In the Aw. go on. Judge! Whats the Jury states of Idaho and Colorado to wipe for? Philadelphia ledger. union labor from the mining fields. After Orchard la examined, the w A Bier on a Great It to. tdenre for the defense will begin with It Is toM of the Bight Rev. Daniel B. Colorado and Cripple Creek. Witnesses are hire to swear that Or- Tuttle, D. D., LL. I)., who had been chard waa the confidant of the mine attending an Important conference at owners and their detectives; that they Lambeth palace. Ixmdon, that during planned and he was selected to exe- a very formal function be and bis wife cute a number of Crimea. The de- were loudly announced as the bishop fense positively states that It la not of Misery and Mrs. Tnttier-rllarpetheir Intention to convict the Mine Owners of murder at the Vindicator Weekly. mine and tha Independence depot, How W Os Chang. where sixteen men were killed, bq exclaimed Mr. Jellua. Aha! Been show to that the death they propose were accidental. They even go so far treasuring another man's picture all aa to assert that Orchard draw on these years, eh? Not exaetly, answered bis better his imagination in his relation of bis connection with the Vindicator mine half. Thats a picture of you, dear, and the Independence depot and that taken when you had halr. Louisville . be was not there at all. On the oilier hand, counsel for the oAU-er- I called Sterling up and told him the doga were on a goad, sate .trail. He said: Call the doga off; we know who did it. I called the doga off. Some days later I saw Sterling and he told me the reason he called the dogs off was that he knew who caused the explosion; that it was Adams. ' Bllxard aaid On ha did not know either Orchard or Adams, that Sterling told him nothing about Adama, other than ,iy;L jje was the man who blew np thetiPpot. Bllxard declared that the Independence depot was used aa a stopping place, but there was no ticlfet agent there. Biliard was followed on the stand by Dr. A. I McGee, formerly a physician and surgeon in the Coeur d'Alene and bow a mining broker. No, on a boat, replied the witness, amid laughter. He aaid he had known Orchard since 1897. Orchard delivered milk to hla house. The day of tha Bunker Hill and Sullivan mill explosion at Wardner, Dr. McGee aaid, ha thought he aaw Orchard at Mullen 1 am not eighteen miles distant sure of it , but if I am not mistaken, I saw Orchard playing poker that day la a saloon or cigar store, aaid the witness. Dr. McGee also related a conversatlo with Orchard, in the Coeur d'Alene, in 1904. Orchard, according to the witness, said he was spoting for a detective agency. On the witness aaid be saw Orchard at the depot one day at Wallace, Idaho, talking to a claims he gave the Peabody bomb to a man named Cunningham, who aaid he wanted to blow up a scab The witness posiboarding house. tively fixed the time of his conversation with Orchard as the latter part of July, 1904. D. C. Scott, who came to Boise In behalf of the state, was called to the aland to establish the Identity of K. C. Sterling, who, it waa claimed) was a secret service man In the employ of the Mine Owners association in 1903, and several years thereafter. Next came F. R. Redd, a miner now living at Goldfield, Nevada, but formerly of Cripple Creek. Redd said be had known Harry Orchard a long while. ' In union hall No. 40, at Cripple Creek, In 1903, he said he had a conversation with a Orchard. In which in the latter calletl GovernorSteunen-ber- g hard names, and said he was responsible for hi (Orchard's) poverty, and that he would get even with the governor. a Mr. Darrow here precipitated heated and lengthy discussion by asking the witness to detail his personal experiences la the Cripple Creek labor troubles. Mr. Hawley voiced for the prosecution a strenuous objection, declaring the labor war In Colorado had nothing to do with the inquiry into the murder of Governor Bteunenberg. He declared the question was asked for the purpose of possibly arousing sympathy by showing the Colorado militia may have done things it ought not have done. . Mr. Darrow, in reply, asserted thst the prosecution could not pick out the history of the past few years the isolated Incidents it wanted to place before the Jury and then shut the defense off in Its purpose to present the other side of the case and show who was responsible for the acts complained At-- Mr. Darrow once more made the declartbm that if Orchard committed the crimes he has confessed to, he actej fir some one other tbnn the The Western Federation of Miner. whole history of the labor struggle! associated with the Western Federation of Miners could alone locate the responsibility, declared the attorney. Evor since this strife begun be' tween the Mine Owners and the Western Federation of Miners, the Mine Owners have been on the aggressive, They deterconcluded Mr. Darrow. mined to get rid of this organisation It The witness next told of putting and it is only by taking both sUes the bloodhounds on the trail of the that the truth can he arrived at. men who were supposed to have perSenator Borah ended the argument petrated the outrage. The prosecu- to suggest that the defense, to open tion objected n the ground that the up to the labor troubles in Colorado, dog had not been qualified, but Judge must have a specific theory in slew . 1907 2G, cute COUNSEL (Coniinued fioiu Page Que.) threats agaiuct JUNE cross-examinati- Cross-examine- d r BAUMEISTER 165 - DISTRIBUTERS! BROS Street, Ogden. Independent Phone 185. Twenty-Fourt- JOHN J. GREINER, 12S - h Twenty-Fift- h - Street,- Ogden. Independent Phono ADAM SNYDER, 275 Main, Salt Lake CHy. Ball Pnons 1061V, Ind. Phans 1061 252. ", . ' iror-eaae- cross-examine- d -- UTAH CANNING Courler-Jmvjkiii.- Salt Lake Valley Canning Company af Packers of High Grads Vegetables Pure Food Catsup. Pood Pork A Beans. Pierce' Pure Pure Food Hominy, Worcestershire Banco. Wa pack but one grade of go ad a THE BEST. Utah Fruits and Vegetables J. G. READ & BROS. CO. II JOHN HOXER Harness and tea-tifl- ra CO. OGDEN, UTAHl MANUFACTURERS - 314 te 940 Twraty-fourtOGDEN, UTAH. h 4 :: Wholeeele :: VINEGAR 1 4 Edward Bichaal, Proprietor. Factory 2454 Wall Avenue, OGDEN, UTAH. Phans 107P. Cache Valley Condensed Milk Company H 1 1 2261 :: Manufacturer ef Honeysuckle Evaporated Milk Won tha geld medal at tha State Pair, 1908. A trial can will can vinca you there la none JUST AS GOOD Ask your Qrwmr for It FACTORY AT .OQAN, UTAH. and Retail Manufacturer af awnings ;; Wash. Are. OGDEN. H W-H-H-- f 1 14 I H' ' GILLES Columbia Club Pcrfccto Cigars made by Columbia Club Cigar Co. Company d Blue Label Flavoring Extracts and Gold Cross Olive Oil Practical Horseshoeing We regulate Interference, gait and curs diseased feet, improve action of ibe horse. Horses called for and returned. 2360 Wash. Are. Bell 'Phone 1(81. Call ua up. Our Proposition Lymskey & Larsen WM, PEARCE PIONEER FOUNDRY & MACHINE WORKS WE LOAN YOU AN Electric Flat Iron ON 30 PLANING DLLS Manufacturers af Saah, Deere. Frames, Mantle, Moulding, Wood Turning, Band Sawing and Stair Office and Mill Corner Building. Twenty-seconStreet and Wash Ington Avenue, Opposite Takers nacle. Phones, Ind. 666; Ball 1309. ESTIMATES FURNISHED. ALL KINDS OP MILL WORK. Ogden Pharmacal ALWAYS THE BEST and PICKLES STRICTLY A HOME PRODUCT. TENTS and Street UNION MADE Manufacturers qf - FACTORY, FIVE POINTS. OGDEN, UTAH. Saddlery The beat and Largest Manufae-turer- s In tha West. UTAH VINEGAR AND PICKLE WORKS DAYS TRIAL At tbe end of (big trial period, if I lie iron not satisfactory, you may return it to uk, entirely without cost to .you. If you like it, pay us in FOUR DOLLARS AND TUB IRON IS YOURS. ORDER ONE TODAY UTAH LIGHT & RAILWAYCO. a Manufacturer Iren and Brea Cast- Inga, Shafting. Pulleys, Boiler and Tank Work, and all kinds ef Machine Work. 2651 Wash. Are. MITCHELL 'Phone 340 Bell BROS. FOR MONUMENTS. Juat arrived 2 carloads ot marble and granite to selaci from. Don't bay from agents a they get large cammleeloas and you have to pay them. rise yonr orders at once. YARD OPPOSITE CITY CEME- TERY. I B B H IH B B B H |