| Show THE CALTON CASE THE tar KILLING OV OF MIKE CUI Lr it was like droum dro atil tile term finished rafn basl isi ive mr williams Will ianis was wag recalled aud and to testified stifled I 1 saw marl mark 8 of discoloration 0 on n cullens throat when I 1 saw him dead inaina cooled liko ahk the man had had a struggle looked like they might have been anade by the thumb nod alid finger first them thein after lid ha I 1 waa washed and shaved 1 i upon agon re cross lie he said didlot did rot notice 10 0 atly any marks on oil calton Cul tona s atice 1 neck redirect saw mr calbot before and after tile tho shooting that day defense wished to hold their testimony y till monday morning request granted tile caso ot of jos coe UC notion motion for den demerer demurer de jurer under tile the statute of limitations on oil tile thu ground that the indictment lid did not I 1 ot charge ft a public of fence was ed court elated that he case could be 30 referred back to the coe grand jury case of tye vs tye was taken up ill atty ally marshal representing mr lr winters stated that tile clime case wua bueing for alimony and lawyers fees mado a 1110 motion tion that they hay bo be granted grain ted john NV W christian atty brown in ili tile the action took up tho the cause of tile the plaint iH court ordered that tho plaintiff jessa tye pay the i b e 8 1 of but a spoof 1 expel I 1 0 0 ln 1 1 i s wife V 1 fe thought thal the aita ailet 0 fecs lee berv too 11 eiph lotin or orddrell derell 11 thal 11 tor tim lawers lauy rs aind 05 00 for au flirt 81 lit be 1 I paid bald by thu the ph by till I 1 t kirbt r atlay duy of noveme r 1881 1 inu auts that the ho caso borl fir eliy next terni of if court A lc ed court adjourned till ill monday Alb liday 10 a in Cl 01 clairl I 1 tirl q adrai ened on oil ti charge of k open a saloon on oil sunday entered it a plea a of guilty gui I 1 ty find was fill litick A und cost 8 of pro su ution joseph hague was recalled in the calton case and testified 1 I noticed tile the wounds in ili tholena gs particularly ticul arly and nd one of tho holes was W 15 about un lit inch highee than lian abo othor other they were not on a direct line liuis and gave in addition mj vy attention ly auf 10 lo called to it by buc others present ii resent dan william Willi alls mid ot outliers liers istre tile cution rested tile the ee caie cai e and d the 1 agn it by ca cal ling ani I 1 held the position of justice of tile the pence peace I 1 also if acted na as coroner over tile the body of mike cullen jerry Tib berty wits waa there and testified before me md additional Addition nl points brought out in tile the cross examination I 1 held tile examination on oil the V 16 i of july in i 1887 I 1 do not recollect all 0 of tho to Sti mony I 1 took down what mr Tib herty berty said all that lie aavo ns evidence evide tice had never acen see ii andr andrew e IV calton till I 1 went down to milford to hold tile the inquest RL redirect direct I 1 took tho the teotimo testimony ny down rind and then copied it into my locket docket and cent bent tile the original to the clerk orthe district court tile tho deft defense iise offered 5 lines of tile the ony that Tib berty berti gave before the corners jury as evidence Protte cution objected ol to it unless the llie choln t testimony wont lit in court sustained it tile whole paper of ortho tile testimony given by jurry jerry Tib berty jeffire tile the co oner was alien allow rd pd by mutual consent to go in filis as testimony mr BJ B J lewis sworn and testified I 1 got acquainted with andrew calton in ili 1882 I 1 worked with him in tile tho mi anine cabinet cabined ith mill his bit character OB as to ilia his being a good citizen was good I 1 have known peculiarities oabie of his mind at dillni di luni his 1118 among tile was vm that luois ilka crazy cray moved tot to strike 1 rike that out motion 61 sustained s t 1111 cd lie known lafin to havo have fits 1010 known ian them to liipa list for three days dayo additional points brought t out by the iho cross examination I 1 was interested interfiled inter filed with andrew calton in a mino that gallon calton hit had td leased lie ho and I 1 were ile he get sullen eullen and would it co t speak the boys would teare tea ili him m and ho lie would get angry have heard beard of one 1101 culty that lio had sot got in I 1 to I 1 heard hear eliat at tile tho terni term of court when calton was tried before j I 1 heard hear of him having 11 little difficulty lini culty beffre tho the cage I 1 let rd it at the time tillie spoken of 1 iii I 1 have thought over ever bince I 1 iliev I liev nini n I 1 eliat lio was weak 1 ill I it ii tied led I 1 did not think lio lie was era ernys 3 1 I never saw in ill hini to rae me thinie lie dill did not know aln right lit froll wrong lie ite direct tile Thoin anost I 1 over lioard hear ab about out this having a pistol in ill niu arrel with antin was ith want it I 1 lioard heard right lit in court I 1 have heard a n good matiy pt koplo 10 lo say bay that his reputation was that lio lie was a gcoy citizen I 1 hive heard thoin say buy lie hu was i harm lety me ifie third pae page j ahti m r na i THE til THIAL CanIn tied front from first pavo mr carver testified touti fled I 1 knew andrew calton lio wan always con a quiet anic l citizen lio lie had spells or sullenness did riot not aucin apin to want avant to take or do anything any thrig I 1 cabined cabinet liim him somo soine time these spoils spells seemed to bo be slin simply ay front froni his igind had known jerry jerr Tib berty ty for eight or nino nine years jis his rt for truth and voracity vara city y was bail bad additional points on oil cross examination ami antioni it is mainly when mon Tib berty is under the of liquor I 1 have iward bear the paiboon keepers and sp speak e ak of him its as riot not hoing hoe ing very truthful calton fortin choco would inal 0 o e no answers to tile alio questions wo put to likai solve times timea lio lie answer not to tile the point at aballi all I 1 did riot lease liim I 1 have aicard juniors of liis ills getting into difficulty lini culty mr hall te testified stifled I 1 am acquainted with etli tho defendant bavo known him ainoo 1870 tit at bingham anil at frisco liis his reputation wax as good a an to liis 1118 1 being 01 aig a peaceful I 1 arid and quiet Illi ct citi zall upon cross to stifled I 1 do not noi know enuch aln simply it a dabbing acquaint acquaintance anco lr dr AVin ceslaw slaw was called aud and testified I 1 know tile dof CRI cilton tOll havo known liim hint for about toll ten years his ili reputation for being a good und and quiet citizen was vary goad I 1 know nothing wrong 0 a grinst leini tot on oil s I 1 have board ito avid IL a quarrel hancl it ill frisco bafo heard lie ird that hu ppul tuli a beard tilt icat heaver tit lit lie hie willi tobin of court ii lion wi calton was waa tried I 1 L aw part of the dul Y 1 1 lit in tile culty I 1 maw HW lit lie I 1 wua vas tho illie t party that that par t of 0 tile ali bu be tit ricken out bus bua talked jenso baldwin te stIfled I 1 nm am elf 0 county wrt in july 1837 1887 aai was at milford lil licci lell tile boily body of ullen cullen wilf HUB brought brou glit lit in there I 1 arrested androw andrew calton nt at that allne I 1 noticed somo bruises on an lila ids hody body one on oil his lil r anil and ong on his neek there wai MH blood 0 on it him neck nack arid chook I 1 I 1 1 did I not lot no lice any bruises on oil tile tho body of cullen do riot not recollect liow how ciany bru nos teore were on oil tile tho defenda tits nock neck tib berty tit lit that flino lie ho was waa in ili a drunken condition I 1 arr esteil Tib lorty sti th vaine aino i and had litin him lit in my charge part ol of the night I 1 think lie ho WIH was iiii lo ito 10 nna antil bota ata taa liko wo ili oy wel aeto I 1 I 1 siut lut dar dan smithson ili charge of rhems testified on oil cross exam anat 1 jr I 1 biad never calton berv bf 1 l f gaw ilin him thoro there joy iny attend A ggs birst called to tile alio dead inn i in nn illy attention was 1 by somo or of tile tho inon Baying sayIng I 1 ln ili note bory they til that lio lie ar arroa rosted ted too I 1 judged froix t boiu Tib general actions tit that at as drunk I 1 arrested liim bini in iwick hague I 1 a saloon I 1 lid did not seo see inn n drink in tho thop aloon saloon Cal gallons tons actions action und sund talk mado wo pio think flunk that ito ho was wah drunk hall had never been another dinati after liia his having committed a burdor do riot not knoy how bow ho would acal act I 1 asko cul cideon tott when I 1 hint him ato where hia pistol wai honald said it was in ill tho the front 1 ol 01 f abo I 1 toll told mcl afla to hot got it I 1 halkol to ti dalcon some I 1 docot do not know any of I 1 the ho wo hail I 1 was called by tile tho last la altime time I 1 think aiko mike quillon Qt Illon wa at tile dirae it 11 Y J pime united collad nna and lo ili july 1887 1 hold the liosi position tim cf a deputy Shor shorlie lil I 1 know mr calton at that buol erht nty iw win when lie he was brought brou clit tn beaver liv bv sir mr bild win will it was in july 1887 1 hat had ilioiu of calton baldwin recalls d I 1 brought brou glit defend arit to deaver on oil tile the loth 1887 1 I turned hini him over to mr gillies choti I 1 brought leini up to deaver ik avar I 1 mr ct gillis i lis r when de defendant dependant was vas turned kotur otur to lo I 1 buo I 1 ill by mr baldwin lie ha hall a un oil liis his left cheek check wid on oil ho alo left bitle ortho thront angell d I 1 li livo liu vo diw essl 1831 lia ro iw for bahig arid iii ela as tt fat av ail I 1 k know now tf of 0 havo of 0 bill libin to TI crass lio ito i I 1 k enow nothing L nn lill v difficulty t what 1 11 leiv ity lion lional I 1 iii u tho cogut coo i t ruoni I 1 no 0 o Mol lallan linn ried I 1 libow miko miho chelleu was tit lit salt JAL jalek ek tile OM cullous Cul lrus buds eliud v waa inide it was mada by ur dr pink mon dr 1 fowler lowlor v ns away irbon 8 tent botes I 1 baw tile ho leolly y mr ir Will williams ianis wn wa capin called arif anil testified nebout us its mr am 1 l valian li hi id veiled ii lloil tind nud fied ie JInni rain taio defendi int fit tic i it 11 voa URS in in ou tho luo ruing of MY july 1 1 1887 i wils n nt 11 tile stir star I 1 thill h a t morning luo ruing Tibb eity mani bent to milford with UKI ine I 1 tuot miko mika cullon on oil cli was na not will its iia we wp drabik nt at doek dock lieford 1 I ore lie io drank with us I 1 saw 0 01 t T at Will iguls sa won mio 0 nil all took too k a drink cherip 0 we o too nok drink at dick I 1 drank boor und anil vIllis liep nye yo were lvere nt at Ws Vs about A 1 u i r that day tow about 5 cack 1 I ld el I 1 did not taj I 1 ily hiskey ibid two bott bottlers leri of wo first a drink afo r wo left town I 1 abat it q tearte rofa milo from OWL rout about it 11 quarter of 0 it milo beyond ha 1 in irful traca cullen sat in iii 14 t willi nae cullun cullen had tile botill iu in his p elect inid would not lot civo ivo tin rit boltl bakoy mv iny whip lasof ew air lye guari ral n ig igl 11 gt oliell onlin would not lo 10 lot him drink ho paid I 1 wit will riot not ride with you oil chillen struck nio me or on I 1 tile tb onice and ami said yiu 13 0 of f it 11 b h ill I 1 kill you voia ito hu botino got itie down over lie tik s t I 1 bearl when T came back miko abaid 5 ili bo kulild not dot atop bo walk wai go houi to kill tae lue I 1 vaa gOing civili wi li cullen Julle ii iphon I 1 picked up tip my lily tho abo firt two ivere voly arwid I 1 atley tap beut into lna bi I 1 wai laveryl very evi ted ehll he bo hall bud bacu ino 1110 1101 the lidid head my iny pistol was not tied jap I 1 oid alid iver ovar tile cheol awl hi if 01 th bt ground on city iy rot fot I 1 it bid id the leslei pst the ibo dav ire T bull bud been homei borie 1 that is liow how it cimo came to bo be i in tl the wai i 1 I do 10 not know ali nt after elvit tl I 1 biad acon over tho head after the tbt first all slid it war wit fired T 1 I mid leold ori on I 1 taid aid it will wi too loo lato late to hold bold on now I 1 gunsol it mas all over I 1 do not know bal at milford lr it culler culle would not RO go home till he bo rot whiskey mr catlin would riot not let bill havo tiny liny abil ley hey arld aind heJI be billed lq lier ber I 1 dill bol know oil iu wa win wai i or riot not 1 w haq bain ill failand to the in in 1808 1869 tit at the timo I 1 re idled r id ia pistol I 1 1 I toll 1 til ought that cullen would L aill ill tile if I 1 did not cot defend iny solf self Tib berty to tuo TOO as afi thou g I 1 be bowab was drunk he bo did no ijo know what bal 1111 1 ohlon 11 till I 1 0 ailo wo I 1 hita him pack bick tile as full te T alia it ln t in addition to direct my lily xa hii riot not wrapped up tip lit in my illy coat T lid did riot not got abot of from cullen cullen must have buve had it in liis his pocket wilen whon lie ho got to Mil mildord bord I 1 wits part way in and part way out of tho the V lou 1 1 I shot bot cullon I 1 wwii with cullen willi illy loft hand I 1 am right li landed ndel cullen lid did not speak utter after I 1 nibot cliot him tile first time not that I 1 beard after the first two shots I 1 irod fired nil all to in nv liko like a di dran pain the pistol I 1 wed carried t kix ix halls T spoke arter f after fter the stith sni tf were fired r T wai wad at tile horres lienda beads do riot not know that I 1 drone to ml 1 I rill am certain I 1 be quilico Jui lico tile liquor awl tile cullan haruck till nn madonia madon iq till tile tho next I 1 amne befit 0 tile dur I 1 air fair only lis as I 1 a dream a W to tile lue aft I 1 A dirak i yi pot to alio H I 1 0 i 10 riner trial knowli arly for fo i out el clip I 1 air axt r on oil tho mor dds of july they cania cimo to illy aagoot and fook it 11 drink with mr cullen thi was vaa just juat tiller after they had arriet arri d at SI ilford I 1 calton chivi riot not drunk anything att t roy ray place before lie 10 branle ira with llullen ullen cullon cullen was vas lit in my lily saloon when leonc U aid ai d T catao no in ili i whon cullin lift 0 afia r onu one on each side liBl pini alk ow one wednesday morning tile divorce tse case of latown vs 8 nan cal callair leir atrial told ind taken about IB 18 follow fol w if birj iJ irown I 1 was aforge brown in ili 1884 do not know ab re my iny I 1 boband id lio ito lot loft aliver reef fi I 1 uio the tit liday of april two tw years tig nol 9 n L it 11 liwe a not heard from froin cilip tor for I time i I 1 linn only received fa from it aneo L li loft lio wan to nic ilie CIT MV i ivil civil alisher tu lu lily in itte would abato tile by lind licking kicking tile supported myself by taking in work did lit riot nut say boy jong lon lio 0 would lo bo botio otie lio ito was a terrible drinker lio lie was never sober bobor while I 1 lived liim hini did nat adt pro vido for ino 1110 lio lie ly was a s living with tile ino ditl did lot say in ill iiii big whether lio lie was chini coining ng backor back or not 1 do 0 nol 1101 lz know lOV where lio went when lie ho loft left rd 1110 lie was in antho tile butcher business busi lio lie was wail discharged lly hy liis his B on oil account of drunk oness ones mr Wo odvard fortified I 1 all I 1 mr ir and mrs blown mr browns lit ill thu root was that lio lie iv wib is a drunkard I 1 know billat illat mrs irs brown works at working out fur her wv living I 1 heard that tliatha lie was discharged front from his hig employment 0 1 11 0 1 for being drunk I 1 I 1 do I 1 0 jl not t 11 knon Z 1 O 1 1 lily iny inis cond licit on oil lier ter part to tl allu aln W civo lier her MJ mr mi axer ml cr I 1 inn fill acquainted with geor george 0 brown io ho drank verylie very beav riv fl alv y t do 0 not inot know where lie is now lit 1113 bet hijii naval from tile reefie be tween two tv annd |
