OCR Text |
Show MALPnACTICE CASE. Cuse of If tss EMnrflVs Dei:b Sill Bern?, Iiveiiij;ttJ. TIA?II JkU. 4AM.t lilM IUKU.II. Uchrlf Mik'H a Motion lo lhat If-fir If-fir l (.b lelerinind to Hold Hrr. 1 Tha It nmtt malprc'lremurdrr oe, of which ao much been wrlttan am sild tba laa. twuwoeka, cnnlinued to b IbVetlignie j and araiud be ore Jul tow Harvey today, ar il la atlll on at pros- Wnon the Nrwi reprir otat yn-leruny yn-leruny ftfleru nui llivt.i J, ll n oe'.t, of I'rovo, br ..tuer o tno uea I girl, wu un he aland. Oo tbi Haturuny lffor , Eveline'- ilcilh CitU-r tt It- ln.i-1 him irumtitla city t c -tne ui. i i h m lkenu the nxi train. W itn-a -au, "I told bliu 1 bad uo m uey to c -.ne up on, ami he I 'l. me lu uu lo Mr. Ouugi i lur it e itijuey. I did ao and tie loiolid, "My (Joil, that hoy hat ruined tne . ready." 1 ut tilueJ luo money fiom Miiotncr -urco pnl than want bank to lug4lua, who Itxj'iirtd parncuiaity ia to tna ritur ul iu ni a. U a 1 tin rereivod (rum L'arlrr. Ar. rlvii g In tbia chy, 1 w in-1 by t ru r, wno iat ttiai i.e . line waa v-r ill. Jual tol(iro reaoiiirg tho I laoo, he laid, 'at.k'a lo a I'M y h -id pl-ooaud 1 want y ii to look i.vor It.' H lf au h ur alter arrivln at Ibe hou.e I met Dr. M Coy aua I r. N -v.., wli .haJ bee.i talieJ In. lr. MrC aaid ll wa wiahvd we ml.ht inh tn uttier phyainian, but lie, N y a ad-vud ad-vud mo tint tuy eiater wa- uyiu, nd il wuul.1 be cf nu ute. KaturulnV toltiauiutel bad Borne ciuvraan.u with hat, when the d. utor Interiuptrti to give her en lnciin nl murpuii.o. Cnrii-r auU) myaelf laa the beuao aud 1 -aid we Ini bolter flu I her luutiier place. iMcauie iba dldu'leveo bave a IMUpvt'l bad. lueilii'Mime Dr. McCoy and my- eli wnui to teloMhona lu my wile, lu adviaeharu tloo mu. Alct;yMd i nit teiephunlng, an I I'd i iuv wife net lo come up bocauiH Eveltao waa di-aJ, When, an milter Of tact, the Uld Uol die fui turo- -Aj jar ten of on n-ur. Voung lioui an lautid a ui ma il anu in a In muloua VoIl-o tatu: "1 bad audi conflui nca In thai boy that 1 b-iiovod b-iiovod htm.'' VII AT IIIB SIHTKIl TOLD II1H. Io reipuiua tu ft queation by Judva HKuderaon aa lu at bat the litter tola bm at Mra. M (tea't Ito'oro dying, he replied toai ina aeid: "1 bavo unit wrong, Dave. Aak Hi bar tu forgiv BJI." Kvellne wu vary waik, and It was d 111. uu t buld bir atieutiob. 1 i.i n slu aaid, "I Loiiare I era goiu lodu;" ibe Witneai told ber but lo bo Uowu-btar.ed, Uowu-btar.ed, and, aba laid, "If I d i die, promiio to lake me lo your plec.'' aiiKHtyr hkowm TKvnviK& Hberifl Umwo, of Utah county, taa-tlfle.i taa-tlfle.i ibai eiur tha diatbuf Evoilue lioiiuotlaud befma the poll tniroui, be bau ft talk wltn Mr. Duggiu, whu aala ba wauted to Xtlalo tuo matter. Ito aaid ba waa lu H It Lake ou Maiob 7, and altouood tbe theatre, re erring t lumbal llligbaui on J olliar preamuoil fit Brui Wuuui be met to curruburaU It. Iloaalitiial he woe ae t la Hod lhat II Hie body wai liken up u wtuhi be found au abortion bad Iwen commuted. DuKKh-a did ut l roiiib tun teaiiuiouy at all aud ih'Kk bis l-aaJ rtpoaleuly a ibougb ib witoeta ware oot Uhiug H e limb, KVKM.NU MKIfluN llgl.U. Dei uly Hherltl Thomaa itrowa c r-r r-r b rated Hbrift lirowu lu regird to iba tiatetnaut mauo by Dug ulna, to the ellrcl III ai If the bo' y woieoxbuiued, it would bo found thai an abortion bad I'vau commuted. Mr, fowler u-iiied up..u I arior the day tolre the laitui'a arraal ana auggoetad thai be bo pro-pared pro-pared br boft'ia, a compialol bad iieeu fliodi Ou thai ouoaeiuj Carter aalo, "Iha faoi Ii, 1 would have married mar-ried tbe girt, but I knew 1 waa no mora lo blame than some otheti." HAD yoa buuoiMa. William O'Neil colored man who keepi a rtatautint nexi lo Dugnlua' alooQ In 1'rovo, tilled lual ebuinx 1 wekiao Dujgiua came lul'i hia place ai absiut 1 a.m. aud nrd-red two atip. pera, direoliug Hie wilneaa tu briug tne lolrapbuieuii lu liugli.i' door aud leave them. Ho ul i tbia bui alter-wirut alter-wirut looked through the wiuaow ud law DuKglm and Mlaa iWuueil, boib peril. y u umaeii. Dr. Kr.uk N yea ietlflrd Ihit he came to H'l Dike on .February i!, the day Lali-ro Mm kloiiuall'i ilrain, but did rut k'i"W int be'uia bo taw her ol Mia, Mattt't, wbeu be Ituuguikod hUi aa a 1'iuvo girl. f hia Sar.-Mouu'e llaarluv. D'pUty Hheritt KoWler recalle 1 by the proio utluti n il-1 waa pr. rant a' o j.Vi-r-loi) on huu ay laal iniwo a Dr. McCuy (and HbanU liruwu. Dr. MuOy aal.1 lno y'U.'ig laUy (Ml-I It.'UiiM i) h.d v.elleu b.a i fllu tuur tuneiluiM unedayiuau ttlorltote. Ute rlio alio ba l beu aiaking. Tbe c x.vt-r-ailou li.ok p it o ai ilia oouiu jail In Iblicliy. Htier fl llaidy waa r lent. t r. ai-examli eJ I tol l Dr. Mi-Coy It WoU.dtaba.llar Ut IHIM lo man. a I rli'iii trraat uf it. I aid lome un I waa neponaib.e for tba butciu ry ll.i i iour irr cf tne gill and annul I t penally 'or Ii. 1 b l i Dr. MoCi y il Ur ! wuulJ te 1 alt Iik kut w 1 w UIJ help j ii i iu lu i el out ol hli trouuir provid I ing of fun in- t. a' bo wai itinbt-eni. Did not tell h I in 1 would give tne narlatarice uf (he Oud Ktliow- or I Mita nr. 1 Uou'l k oa iMVIbloti about ; tiit-n ; -ioi.'i know w m H ir ir Ur wu I e'.il tu him, If anyiblng, nu lh.i ioinl; 'tbel .tltr held a wuiat wred 0 iLVi ft. 1 lion wiui Dr. Mr('o., Ouut noiiul Atiormy W.iLili ill of j Mr. Wlei'e leiiluiMiiy Wa alinkuu Tn rui John taw Carter, Duglni nil I Mlaa It i eti nI I I'l v., ,tll tioiiau uu Hie Ii Ik lit ol l-'t bruary 17. Clemen I llouiia.t, biot Iter ul Iba I'eceaieii, nu eila-r J t liuii" on Kchiiiuiy 17, O . lli- iiitfi.l . I tin IIli, Wltneaa talked Witt. Caner. M - w.. i, 'Will, y i ii t link ..i.i y .n"' li r I u . lout ba hill uuil -aid oi' UaJ li-Il l.vi.tllilt 111 MBit Eao Willi C-Iawai.i.1. j tul-a hii I lhat I w.in m ii up , in I-4 I-4 ew dya to bring bur n n a a id hat liny lutui-dt'd to yft m in td a 'in I . nir lb t in iiilt', 1 ak d bin iff., over kiu-w aiiylniii,- wron: au ut i u utt t be r-pHUi (Mat be did n-l. I 'rota ox uuiii' d Ci'ior i ltlvuly It b- I Ii 1-mJI o wl h C iwtoi.', f Ik-. Talked wuu Car tr a. a u in ine alttvi, but uotuulll allor lut Una Lb ra. Dtvbl llonnMt. ter-tn-law. of Mlaa Eveline, titnd lhat aluoe the l.tit'deetti aua bad omerpd with Carter, Ii waa the nbrhl nf er th 'uiia-ral. He uld ho had left Mi-Eveilua Mi-Eveilua Willi ft Mi- D.din In Hi t lkr. Ankati aa to her iMtnMi hn ..i . not reply dlr-cty. Ho appeared (VaalVo and iiorvour. r n eiaicKird Carter le t vrry haj y ovrr the aftur. lie Hmughi e great eal nf Evo lno ani aald It waa nl htteiiilnu in marrv ber enoriiy. Mre. C.lla K.emnrn, a el- r of l.atiiiiie, aald alio Had c nv- nation will) Cnr. it n riirred on We inef. ijny evi' ilnr, February 4 h, at lltt h me of tier br tn-r D-l i. He end ih-lhebel le'l Evlioe cim tne aire I ti Halt Lke i'tty au I that the tmte l lint abe waa goliu u ft M'M D di(i 'a t alot . I nked blm w.ieiher alio -ihi anjtUiiia alin.it ber fi ika nt.d ho r -ptiej thai alio aaid: l Wi n iiT wbi Ihrv Wot. Ul Uo fur TH" at Ii -Ilia II ttny knrw I wa no-.?" He a'. . luforrued l neettil It wia hla lnt niton t marry 1 i Evhoe tbia in iiiih, Jan et Hooot U,lti egMl tithrrorthe iinlurlui ait gtrl, we tin next wttnaa. Hh ail iht a e Ir I home no Kaiir.inr 17tr ; thai the we in ko.1 Mallli ai e time. Ilndenud Ihol be wia on un fh u lly term Willi ber nr Willi obe of bit a u.a. He "i.J.-rUl,l.ow-I'Ver, lu her keerig company Willi t." irooer lu IT. nl fiau c unty, t.all-lied t.all-lied at lo the burial, exiiutnailjii auu r-ltit rriuent of tin i. 'v n I rero-i. rero-i. t d It a- ttial or Mi-ll mnett. D.V.J llonnell, retailed by Ibe proaeullDi. Had a Cinvoraatloii with Mia. Mm. with refertMPO i t Eveline' v uililng. which am. prmiad tu tend ' ome. i, m oiothliiH,ueoVtr, hid li d yet ban aeoi. I b pfoKt-tutlnti hero la-U.l a-i I Attorney At-torney l-'ti'iiile m.vrj that the ca axiilu.l Alra. Maaa-. Im lttui-pd. Al-tUie Al-tUie (.iMti .hivniedli til tiying there .a n t one oilier ipieat te dei.red I aK .Mlaa ila-.o. All tllK-or Wai PniiMdlately UUp'K'hed lor the young kiiimu wli i .in bei'ia: br niKiii uiiu u uri wa. iaki if hr nnrner .id nui it una food Jit a ieuuritt, hotel, . r aomootl.ur I il-liiaeaovar Mr. 1 i . t( M.a'. -lo u. Wh.hm replied, '.Njt tl.at I know u(.' A t .rn -y llli-i ihe room over Mr. Dj .KlnV, aal'i. i t I Witue ((e uclaiiLyJ Vei, alf. Mr. U'.N.mI, the cn.ieu man, being retailed, luruitno I ten minutvi o autuoatciil lor c url, atlorn-ya and Wlliieaaea. Tne dfeu enit-ivorod to nnteioh blm but gave up the ) b ai a ltd oi o. W liiain Elliott, ft l'roe.i i.ht-wairliinao, i.ht-wairliinao, eaw Dogiii en i a aumtu who JiM'k 'i like Mia- llniiet', lu bit eoiot u uo the uikf i.t reiarrru t by tin-coloio tin-coloio i man. Tbo wwum Wa baiiiu i lie bar Wahliig htr baud-. Duugtoa waa par Inly unclad. Tbe Womau wore a hi .i k cepo. Mta. t'uggibi wai corr niandod In aiauu u,i iu iro t ul the wumia who waeaakett If the wrap alto wore w a- ibe oue aevu ou Iba womau lu tbe aah.on, ihodeeuNO hulliu ibal Mr. Dointiua Waa tbe lamala a-u behind tho h.r at thai time. Witneai emphaticall - declared de-clared ih't wrap worn by I n womau he taw wee nut the uut worn by Mra. lJujgnia, Thi litir wa-o blck clotu muc ibe one worn t.y the wouiau In ine aaloon waa at-iitkm ur btaver. Ha ba.Uvtd tha ttniia wai Miat Uou-belt. Uou-belt. Tha court bora took ft rectis until S p. in. At t o'clock title aforuoin tba beai. lug woo roaumed aud Attorney lo.-b no renewed b.a m illou to ducnirae .Mra. Maaaey. Ho ataled ibal lio evidence evi-dence produced by tba Htete bit leoded o ily to remove i.I tui iclou ui e.ii ui egeinet Ibe wcuiaii; and nut only dial, bui ll baa otiiitt raird any dcum wblcb may biveexiaiod ai to the lo-uuL-ente ot Mrt, Matoey ul even fcuuwl-edgo fcuuwl-edgo uf the i-rime cbnge ', Attorney Uni laid mat at flr-t tliriii ii wuulJ aeotu prha ibat Mra. Maeay wia nut bi itutlty aa Ibe other da eodanii, but upou tlior. ugh ex amlnatbtu uf tua evidence) the virw un.y Imi chauged. If the curl, alter CUi'tlderilig Bli tha C.tt'UllMiancrr, mould fliiU thai lue delanuiul .Mr. Maaiey Was acoettaory, aha ahtU'U ( UeU lo tba ftctlou uf the diiltlcl : court. Attormy ine .The only reatuii ad-vaiira ad-vaiira I by Mt. U ith I jr Die ho Id lug o' Mra. Mai ey waa that Mr. ( ailerlold oertalu people carlalu uunuib. A nd yet lu an umirimmaiu,il argumonl tue ..reeecutlDg atturuey rho had Juai g l IbrouMh talking pruoea lo hul l Mrt. Alaaeey tu Ine untrici court. It hn not been ahuwu that a criminal atx.riton bad bran performed, ll may bavo biau tbo i vault .1 a Ihuiaand different cauaea. The only f-ct that hae hreu brought out by the time la thai Ihe dtceeea-d eprul a tew de a I al Ihv houao of Mra. M , b loriuu. ai-iiialiitauno, aud ihrro It riot ibe leiel evideuce tu bold Mrt, Mar. Mr. tiiwh roao iu aritue what be on-aloored on-aloored to be new point r Ued by d-lidaud' d-lidaud' allnrueyt, Ibe 0 rpue delhMl pbati-, Bil l al-o to auawer the "a;i vaulc, tc Ul grniieroiu," n-fi-rrliu to Mr. Zne. Tne geut.oii.au Wat talking talk-ing wueu our repuit oiuaed. |