Show EXPERTS DECLARE KAIGHN SAS W AS INSANE ii r g WHEN HE KILLED FILLED WILLARD HAYNES I Local Physicians Under Oath Testify That the Youthful Prisoner Was Vas Mentally Un- Un J 1 balanced Day of Tragedy f JURORS WHO WILL DETERMINE I f THE FA OF HAYNESS HAYNES'S SLAYER f 4 r i ff The Tho Jurors who ho will determine the thet fate t of or Ro Roy charged with jf 4 the murder of or Willard S. S Haynes Harnes In ln the order in ln which they were acH ac- ac H- H f are 4 H- H ROBERT nOBERT N. N HOLT Mill MII Creek I 1 H- H EDWARD WHITE farmer Mill bull Creek 4 If tt THOMAS W. W PARTRIDGE real TN estate Salt Lake Laker g. g 0 y yI 4 I 4 JESSE JJ GOODFELLOW wool buyer Salt Lake t M f H- H CHARLES SHARP farmer West cst Jordan 4 f t ALFRED AIFRED J. J GRANT GRANI farmer Grancer Cranger 4 t I H- H ALONZO YOUNG employee Z 2 C. C M. M I. I shoe f factory etor Salt Salt Lake 4 K t 1 f A. A E. E CADDY smelter employee Murray S 4 t H f HEBER HEllER B B. B ALDOUS contractor Salt Lake J. I t t ff EDWARD grocer S Salt lt Lak Lake t 1 H- H HHENRY HEr HENRY E. E RA RAWLINGS LINGS barber Salt Lake 4 f JAMES JA RE KEMP HEMP IP farmer Cle Crescent cent 4 I if 44 9 i Attired in ln a n new nc spring sprung suit Bult and oc- oc shedding a tear Roy fiat at in ln the criminal courtroom this morning and listened to two experts on In Insanity and his stepmother tell of at his I queer actions Just after the fatal shoot shoot- I ing I INot Not in His Right Bight Mind Dr BaIrd and Dr Benedict declared positively to the jury that the they visited In n the city Jail after he had shot Haynes and that he was not In his right mind In cross 8 questioning Dr Baird the thc DI District Attorney brought out a n. statement from him which apparently apparently appa appa- had the desired effect upon the ju Jury r When does temporary Insanity end Dr Baird 1 It ends with the thc commission of or a Do crime Dr BaIrd replied Dr Benedicts Benedict's Opinion Dr Benedict testified to having seen young oung Kaighn In the city Jail shortly after aeter the thc shooting occurred He Hc said that from all appearances was mentally unbalanced at the time He Henl nl also o testified l as to the thc effects the various vari vari- various ous narcotics had on the thc mind of at the user Adrian Pembroke testified to having seen Roy noy Just before 1 o'clock on the afternoon of November and that at the time appeared to be bc under the Influence of or liquor Mrs the stepmother of the defendant was then sworn but before I Continued on pa page o C. C Says Kaighn Was Insane Continued from Pago 1 she had testified the court ordered that thata a recess be te taken until 2 o'clock Expert on the tho Stand Dr W. W F. F Baird practicing physician was the first witness winess called caled to the stand this morning moring Dr Baird te to having known young 1 from the time of o his birth hirth He stated that in company with Dr Chauncey Benedict he had visited young oun Kaighn in the Jail Jai after his arrest for the purpose of making an examination of ot young mental condition He declared de tie- le- le dared that at the time Kaighn eared wn was apparently under the Influence of liquor li liquor li- li quor or some drug He said Mid that the pupils of the prisoners prisoner's eyes eye were dilated di dilated di- di and that his answers were Incoherent Incoherent Incoherent Inco Inco- herent From all 01 appearances appearance was not In his right mind at the tte time trl District Attorney who cross- cross examined the witness winess asked Doctor Is Cross Cross- Cross a ined Doctor had you ever before treated or examined a man inside of or two hours and blood a 0 half hal after he had shed human No Then you do fo not know knoW doctor whether the boys boy's condition was caused b by liquor or 01 n narcotics or 01 whether his condition was caused by the great reat ex- ex which would naturally f result after a man had killed a fellow being No I do not Not Able to State Then doctor accor according to your testimony testimony tes tes- you ou are not able to state whether er young Kaighn's condition at the time you OU saw him by the theu u ue of cocaine morphine absinthe ab or other strong drink or drug 0 or whether to the fact that he had only a a short time before shot a to man manZ No o. o I 1 do not not Th The witness was excused Expert Had Forgotten The first witness examined at the afternoon afternoon af af- af- af session yesterday was F F L. L Bagby a reporter for he Herald Herl Ff Mr Mr Ir Bagby said he saw w young at ot th station staton f soon on after the tragedy tragedy trag trag- ed edy occurred and that he ho attempted to Interview the prisoner hut but but that Kaighn did not seem eel to notice him at all al He lie Ic declared that thal he believed cd Kaighn was temporarily unbalanced at the time In his examination Mr Bagby Informed the court that he had studied medicine and ane psychology fol fora foia a year and nd that he f felt 1 capable of or Judging a 0 p persons person's r ons on's mental mental mental men men- tal condition In hi hl hla examination cross Mr Ir asked Mr Ir Bagby to tell tel him the divisions divi l of the mind Mr r. r Bagby stated that he had forgotten and was excused Under Drugs Drug's Influence F. F D. D helm Halm an employee of oc the Salt Lake Hardware lIa-dware compa company testified that that he had seen ten Ro Roy Kaighn on th the street streeta a 1 short shott time before the tra tragedy iy and that he was apparently under the In- In of 01 some pome powerful dr drug r. r W. W A. A Wilson on and John both bartenders testified to having sold Mid young oun Kal hn a 0 short time before beof the shooting Both told how absinthe seemed ted to affect those who used use It It George A A. A White a a. reporter for the Tribune th the next witness said that ho he went to school chool with alghn and that he knew him to be addicted ted to the u use e of liquor and strong g dr drugs Frank Yo Young un a n companion of ot Kaighn's testified that the defendant was wa an Inveterate cigarette smoKer and nd used lse absinthe and other powerful drugs Roy Ry Was Crazy Miss 15 Anna Thomas Thom who ho nursed Haynes Hayes at th Hol Holy Cross hospital af- af er he was shot SUS SU'S she heard sa say to Col Col a day or so after the shooting Ro Roy was crazy Miss Coates called caled to see Haynes Hanes after aCter and the latter laler held her hand hanL as she stood b by his cot cot A. A S S. Martin a former school teacher of or young oung Kal KaIghn's hns hn's said that Kaighn smoked so s man many cigarettes that his mind became Impaired to such an nn ex extent extent ex- ex tent as to become noticeable In his school work vork Mrs Irs Kni Kaighn hn was recalled to the witness witness wit wit- ness nes stand when the court COUt re resumed umed Its Is Iste te session slon this afternoon She testified to young Kaighn s queer actions at various vat vari Otis ous times and said that often oten the boy had come home and told them that he had Just killed a man and that he was as being pursued which upon investigation tion ton proved pro cd to be false Hayness Haynes's Relations Mrs Kaighn testified that the fam fam- amily am- am ily Iy relations with wih Mr Ir Haynes had al alwa's always always al- al ways was been leen friendly and that during the year ear previous to the tragedy Haynes Hanes had been a a. frequent visitor to the Kaighn home Dr Shores the next witness winess said that he had known young oung for about live f c years During the early part of at that acquaintance Dr Shores testified tes tes- titled I Kaighn alghn often ofen visited his office and andas was as a most obliging boy boJ but for some sometime sometime re time before beCore the shooting Kaighn seemed Deemed changed chang d and was wag not encouraged to visit the office |