OCR Text |
Show SUFFRAGE LOSES IK house ey . 204T0174 Partisans of Votes for Women Meet Second 4 Crushing Defeat in His- tory of Cause in Washington; Wash-ington; Republican Leader Is Champion of Defeated Side; State Rights Urged. Iparty lines are lost in struggle Debate Is Bitter and Speaker Clark Is Com-' Com-' pelled to Use Gavel to k Keep Order; Under-wood Under-wood Heads Winners; r Enthusiasm Reigns JiWhen Vote Is Known. jf TTASHIMTrON Jan 1 The bouse ef repreentat tm tonight, by a vote of N to 174 refused to submit to the (Utitea la amendment to the federal fctf rotation to enfranchise women t2je vote the second in the. biikxy Sre eonrresa on the woman suffrage is-Vgetame is-Vgetame at the close of a day of long (Brf pared for oraton" dnnng which the jjcuy speakers were listened to with li&rHTient evidences of approval or dia RppoTal by packed galleries. The ques Iron was before the honse on the Mon AeH resolution to snbm t a constitn Gonal amendment that tha r gbt of (oftage should sot be abridged be ana of sex. A two-thirds affirmative vote was necessary to pass the resolution t was defeated by a majority of thirty Party lines were not etnetly drawn ' a the fight though Democratic Leader t Underwood, vo eang the attitude of his Jirty that suffrage is a state issue strongly opposed the resolution while Sepabhcan Leader Mann was one of the chief speakers of the suffragists Enthusiasm Reigns Enthusiasm mingled wttl dejection en Speaker Clark announced the re ult, and Into the orrldors from oppo fits gantries filed the hundreds of uf ingleta, with their purple and yellow aubes, and the red ose-bedecked anil mffraglats. t This was the ee ond defeat for the suffrage cause In tie national leglla toe within a year March 19 last an equal auff age const utlonal amendment, fcroposed by Senator chamberlain of Ore ton, received a ote of 35 to 34 tn the senate, securing a bare majority but a faffing of the ne -ftseary two-thirds. However suffragist eaders tonight were not d smayed. As hey left the gal lerles. led bj Dr Anna Howard Shaw Mrs. Carrie Chapman Catt and other cbamplons of the cause, they declared rthat the fight was by no means over and that the suffrage propaganda would he pressed forward and onward unt 1 ev 7 woman in America would have the f right to cast a ballot. V The result was what we expected f said Mrs. Arthur M. Dodgo president of I the National Assoc at on Opposed to ) woman Suffrage. It means tl at the suffrage movement funtered by hysterical women. Is on the wane Party Lines Lost Often during the earnest and at times hitter debate preceding the vote. Speak ' r Clark was forced to tnte rupt the I speakers on the floo nil the chamber vtth the deafening battering of his savel, and warn both members and spec tators that order m st be preserved bev era! times he threatened to have the gal tries cleared unless the disturbance subsided. But the m rmurs of approval and d sappro al pers sted as each npeaker voiced h a support for or oppoatt on to the t cause of votea for women f The turmoil culminated in a storm of h ss ng that greeted a speech n ade bj Representative Bowdle of Ohio opposing I tee amendment He had trea ed the sub Jeot humoro sly and remarked that the women of Wash ngton are beau If 1 but they have no Merest n affa ra of state. I Opponents of the resolution based thelf I yppos Hon la gely on the argument that I, for the federal go erament o prescribe II qualification for s ffrage would be an un u Warranted Invas on of the right of Indl K vldual states to control thetr elections II and further upon the content on that U there was no adequate pub c demand ) 'or this amendment showing It to be necessary Advocates of the a nendment contended that the widesp ea 1 demand fo woman suff age Its su ess n the sta es whe e It has been ed u id the principle of allowing: the people to ru e justified j the submission o the propossl to the states for rat lija Ion. r Preceding the general debate t ere was (Continued on Page Nine ) 1 SUFFRAGISTS ' LOSE BY VOTE 1 204 T0 174 J party Lines Are Lost as friends and Foes of Measure Mea-sure Engage in Bitter Debate "-"(Continued from Pima One) -T for an hour "nd ha.lt on a spe , , nrovld ns for cons derat on or "Teuton whlcl was adopted by a "SoU or '09 to SI "pi WW tolos 4ote"ies Jr..inc (or the resolutlo SSuentat es Adair. Alexander n , ?',V AD hens, Aus in A Baker Vtot I Bathrick. Bel of I. a Iron a Xrs Borland Britten Bro n of -ink B san Buchanan of I o s J T C-ampbe Ca Casey Chand er e vim Church Cam) Ulne Con I ,;y Kansas Coplev Cramton r Curr Davenport Decker Delt WDersham Dlcklnso D 1 on Doo . Jl DrulAer Eagan, Edmonds Eans Fon,usson Ferr Fess Fits JZrv Fordney roster to ler Fran Frear French Gal aghe Gal 1 an irzeG on Good Gorman o -aham fpennsy vania. Green of Iowa. Grlest, Jma Hamll Ham on ot M chigan I ffln!5Hart Haugen Halej Hajde 1 He gesen Hel enng Her is S, Hobson Howe I Hughes of West tdn a, Hu ng Hun phrej of Wash S Jo nson of Washington Kahn 'Song Kelster Kel e of M chUan, i r. o.r.r.:ivMi9 Is.ent. Xettner 1 Ti JsJnkail of Nebraska Klnkead of Viersey Kirkpatrick Know and. Laf J La Fo et e Lang ev L ndbergl tad Logue, McAndrews McGutre of kkhoma, McKe ar McKenz e lie S? MacDona d Madden Maher fiapes, Martin Met Mltche 1 Sen Morgan ot Oklahoma Moss of . Sana, Mott, Murdock eeley of Kan ss. Neey of Wet Mrginia Ne son. ikn I.orton O Hal O bhaunessj jSar Patton of Penn vlvan a Pfter ST Van Porter ProuU Ralney Se Re ly of Connect cut, Roberts of STchusetts Roger' Rubey Ruker opey Russel abath Scu y eldom Z. Se s. Shack eford Sherwood ims, Stt. "? emp Sm th of Idaho Smith of jSrSid J M. l Smith of Mch gan Se! W m th of Mich gan smith of unie ota. th of New York Steener STsepnens of Cal forn a Ste ens of w Hampshire Stone Stout "tringer softer and Taggart, Tavenner Taylor of dorado Taylor of New York Temple, Thompson Ul umouuh a, - s. Towner Treadwa are. o stead Walef W lliams Woods Young of orth Dakota. Total, 1 4 04 Vote INo Voting against the resolution Pen esentat ves Abercromble Adamson illeo, Ashbrook iswel Bai ey BalU Barchfe d Bark e Bartho dt, Ba t ett Btakes Beau of Texas Backmon Broiler Bowdle Brockson BroussaM Brown of West 'V rglnla, Browne of Wis eoisin Browning Brumbaugh Buchanan 0 Texas Bulkle Burgees Burke or Pennsyvanla Burke of South Dakota Bu ke of W scons n Burnet Bjrnes or sou h Carol na, Bj "ns of Tenne see, Calder Callaway Candler Cantor Can MIL Carawav Carew Carl n Carter Car? Clark of F orida, Coady Co ier Cojiolly of Iowa Conrv Cooper C"vc Crisp Cul op Danforth Dav s Den. D es, Difenderfer Dixon Donohoe, Dono WuDoolng Doremus Doughton Drs tel Dupre. Eage Edwa ds Esch Es opnl,Fa child Fie ds F n ey F; zge aid Flood Floyd Gard Gardner Garner Garre t of Tenne see Garrett of Texas Gerry G U G llett G tt ns. Glass Cod in Goeke Goodw n Gordon Goulden Graham of 111 no s Gray Greene of Massachuset s G eene of erpion Gregs Griff n Guder tiami ton of Nep Tori Hardy Harr s Harr son Hay Hef Hi Heln Henrv Hinds Ho and Hous on, Howard Hughes of Georg a H Humphreys of M ss ss pp Jacowa Johnson of Kentucky Johnson of South Caro Ina Kennedy of Connecticut Key Klnde Kltchin I onop Korblj Lang ham Lazaro Lee of Georgia Lee of Pennsy vania Lenroot Lesher Le er Lewis of Man and Lieb Linthicum, Lobec Lonergan McG 1 cudds Magu re of Nebraska Mahan M er Montague Moon Moore Morgan of Lou lana, Mor 1son Mulkey Mu ray O dfle d Page of North Caro na Paige of Massachusetts Park Parker of New Jersev Parker of New York Patten of New York Patt, Plum ev Post Pou Price Qu n Rags dale Rauc Rasburn Reed Rel y of Wlscon In Riordan Rouse She e Sis son S as den S oan all "ml h of Texas Sparkman Stafford "Hedman Stephens of M ss ppi S ephens of re braska, Stephens of Texas Stevens of M nnesota Summers Sn tzer Talbott Ta cott Ta or of Alabama, Ta. or of Arkansas Thacher Thomas Tribb e Tuttle Underhil Lndernood aughan t n on ollmer Walker Wal n a sh Watk ns Watson Wea er Webb Wl a ev Wh tacre White W ngo W ns low Witherspoon Youn of Texas To tal 01 otng for the resolut on were e ghty s x Demo rats seventv wo Repub cans twel e Prore slves t ree Progre s ve Repub cans and one ndependent Tota 1 4 oti aga nst t we e 71 Democrats and th rt three Repub cans Tota 204 |