Show 11 ANDIS 1 li ill r t on the ilan I 1 in I 1 Bus washington at three documents in fix tilt nature of rep ali i will ba pro pio to tile hie houa hou flou a by I 1 Is pall electric telephone committee bu but I 1 i as neither will be signed by the he ma inn of film 11 s Q a k ing there will 1 lio no r report e r t III forn ilia for 11 action e apoi 1 tin thi K port drewn ur up by ilia chair inan ill 11 will ill be sigfid by and aftin atessis Atess rs ottes aliben 01 null demo cro crati N kinny lias has secured eureil ae file als I 1 catle 4 0 r ilessie iles sim millard and 11 Moffit tt hll all Republic aus to tits lila report whilo lialo hala his has preson lel his leiws in an individual report aport chairman Cli irman belote report will out not Us brt ellade public before I 1 lo 10 u tile report signed by the he llepun linin lican bers tile test I 1 mony la Is cited to allow how tile alio Pan Elect corn com pany was organized arii HIKI and I 1 brae arde und ami ii a half of its ita stock block given to tile iho gentlemen for tho the use of the their to r naine and mation tic tho opinion of senator Bori alor garland deceli Lir lilL unit that the he fingers anten intents do not infiel dge on oil the hull patent Is 0 tell with tho the statement that it 1 lidid I I 1 byon because the lie pun pan electric could not sell the rights which it had and it wai vai intended Intend eI to bean Induce inducement arant which leil fell large numbers im babers cabers of persons persona to lo pay in money a part of which was divided among arll ni and his at the time the van pan electric knew kne w that their instruments did luf floge on tho the bell patent the report then ali eo refers to the belog r h bill na all explaining the motives onuiel of thel pan electric organizer and states stated that hat two millions of acock WAS heitl by me tubers of congress when it was expected that tho the bill would ile be subjected to legislation it ils 18 charged that the pan people I 1 iner garland tried to ret got endorsement forit fors belr their sc schemes homei and evidence evl dunce la Is cited tiara it touches uvon upon the effort to se secure C ure t the he a ap p ointment C or of young rogers IRS HB the be muse boune electrician it la alleged that the senators garland find and harris and general johnstad Jolin John stoa had busied themselves personally to accomplish this the report then re remarked markell the sale of state rights to sub companies compa olea andears and ande says ays the bell Company ahod I 1 he sub companies toe the pan ateo t trie rie company declined to befeld on I 1 the around that it had no money mguey 1 r re epou they 11 16 11 a cure cura ilia he name of the united uniel to suit against tho iBell company to it 1 find and to buy peace ho 80 they bey obtained per mission when they wanted it lod he they wanted it without any opre pre lical inary examination worthy vt of the name without tho the usual Iti investigation t and in ia defiance or of all rulo rules sod and alifi all practices of the department 61 and in indirect direct disregard of the dec docman lilon made within a month by its head hud had all facts developed I 1 before the c 0 w been known at that time time briya y the report tho the department of justice would have driven these thesa petitioners petition ers from I 1 ita Is doors for public sentiment would havo have constrained cons traille I 1 it t to do so the report in commenting upon goodas shore share in the transaction de dares clares that if ho he had bad made the la in qui quires res he ought to have made lie he could not hot have granted the application within twenty four it hours re Is al ledged that so far from making a careful ex atilina tion don of 0 the subject lie he never even read the he petition taking all these theo things together says the report lt it does not admit ofa of a doubt that tile the solicitor general acting as the attorney general was by home borne means lead to prank grant this application with out tho the usual reference refe or inquiry without any pretense of compe competent teut examination with unexampled speed and in violation allon of the tire of tho department inan ordin sty dry case such action would be held belli to be positive proof of fraud at least negligence which in a person of his position Is id equivalent to iran irjud upon these thesa filets facts no ono one of which can call be ba dl no jury would hesitate it I 1 s enough however to say that it cannot be ed thil tile the business busl neua of the ilia govern merit ment oin nail be so conducted it e cannot an escape observation tint that senator tor harrion Jarr lion and mr air cabey young acted just as men would ut at if already assured of what was aa being asked and that the conduct of 0 the he solicitor general Is ia easily accounted lor for on the assumption that he understood heo the mutter matter in tita vance and n 1 I h bad a d fredete predetermined upon the co lourio u rao of of batio 1 l tho the report then alien recurs to the subject of the opinion furnished by the attorney general it charges that it wits written with a view to dot de ceide tile people in the southwest and says enya that it wai wag h a view that that the people so sa believed but bat that holbo s at attorney t orn eycie general n eral did not th the report goes on the best that ean can tit be said of him la Is that he lout laut himself to a scheme because he be gut got his sio lt tor for nothing ile he had not the iho strength to deny dany what hid associates asked nor to return the stock an and cease to he an ile he hall had not the boldoc ti todo to do personally what they thought was waa a fair servi service c 0 for the stock he kept but it W waa 0 a lone dona fly by his department as aue such 11 a athinis thine never was waft dope before the plea la that the parties concerned did not think they were doing wrong but a government which ex pacts to bo be respected can not permit such it thins than to be ba done such ioelu once enco to bu be sought for or such personal interests to exist and fand avail it Is enough that those personally interested e ted who ought to havo prevented Wd it say that they did nothing and meant to do nothing tho rho report wates the expense orthe suit if a trial bo be had on ili id merit 4 nt at not less than |