Show DR GIVINS CALLED Hypothetical Question Propounded to Insanity Expert Dr John W Glvins who Is in charge I of the Idaho State Insane asylum was then placed on the stand Ho hal practiced his profession as a doctor for t wen t foU years and has had fifteen years experience with insane patients eaIf experence during which time ho bus treated about I JOOO of them He suld that the Insane are often controlled by the same feelIngs nre feel-Ings oren and pasnlons that control the sane lhat to some extent they have a knowledge of right and wrong that they ate often possessed of cunning cun-ning that they are often Insane without with-out delusions or hallucinatlone and that In a certain state of mental disease dis-ease morbid Impulses may drive a min against his will to do a desperate desper-ate act The attack of typhoid fever suffered I by Mr Mills was then described to the wllness and ho pronounced It a very severe one Then a hypothetical question coverIng cover-Ing sOle sixteen pages of typewritten manuscript was propounded to Dr Givins The question contained an abridgment of alt the evidence which has thus far been given for the defense from the time of the birth of the accused ac-cused until the day of the opening of unt the case In court or nearly HO winding up with the direct question Assuming now all of the facts that I have stated to be true what do you Bay is your opinion as to whether at the time that Mills fred the fatal shots which killed OMelveney he was sane 01 Insane But it was now fifteen minutes past the regular time of adjourning so the court interrupted and said that Dr Givins might defer his answer until 10 oclock this morning |