Show I 1 BOWEN IS tap IN JL RA 0 I 1 t DI driven iven from franr his teachers quorum n for supporting critchlow at the school election I 1 HIS BIS BRETHREN BITTER oen denounce ounce him for opposing I 1 the right ticket I 1 I 1 1 ACCUSE HIM OF DECEPTION I 1 F it at the monthly mooting meeting of 0 the nor MOT oman mon block teachers ot of the first f ecclesiastical ward his case was as V taken up the burden of 0 the tha coni dem deni natlan was that he had given people the critchlow mid and wilson ticket with the assurance that it birss the e bight h ticket when from th the mormon point of view it was i th the wrong one without allowing 1 I 1 him to speak summary action was ana ill taken liken Bishop warburton Wn makes a I 1 statement admitting the cause of 0 4 the action taken bowen tells the tha astory story in an affidavit the affair 4 it 11 sensation t V P james charles charlea bowen ot of 67 sixth L east ia street a block teacher in the ho first ward has been dl nilsen am the quorum ot of teach rit of 0 that nini ird 1 7 he supported 11 JS 13 B lit chlOw tor for member of the th board I 1 FAu education cation us as against chatlen W V inloes the dismissal occurred d at lie i regular tular monthly meeting of 0 tit the e chire hold on in thursday evenin 6 nd the motion to that effect A no r warburton War hurton bishop ot of tile the iril aid preliminary to ti this summary action n M had bad bil b il genelar charges mad bondt t calust bewen of 0 decel tion in pre oiling ing Critel critchlow liow tickets to voters no ko W nag offered in substantiation of 0 he atoll n ile charp charge a or to de tilt at his patt part in tilt th clcil atlon on was not ciller honest and ho was not peri to say ay iy a word in his hl own on dole twice lie in says he h 4 0 alk avid and on both occasions lie aa used by P bishop on in 10 lo he presided over th tile meeting inet ms boscn was waa a conspicuous figure in ali it beriy burly of 0 the 6 chloi 1 anly I I 1 i the day attention was attracted attl acted ty to 0 ym at by this the that vere heaped apon 11 hlin him by tit th aupp of ct simona r thet nas as to ti ille lle to be applied fa hint him and cap man inan eu 1 inada I de a hircan at ot of phi physical steal violent gioie k e A full to ac funt fit it bobolis burden of abuse that y waa as published lit in th tribune on inday lit H as I 1 in n the th musts rill that nominated bp be 18 9 then a support r of afler 0 con ent lea lit mim its for or its lt nominees ga 44 dax ho he critchloe ilan tickets tick Is from born morning unell aeilt though efforts vre more made to yc le mm him stop alop delim so ro and threats faai ade of lit barlous ports in fasal oal ment ot of ills hh ATTACK ASTO astonished HIM boan wen had no expectation that he aull lit bv b to 90 harshly ing treated fr P i cpr fr the right of 0 citizenship uv ill mtr iter ended the hc leachel a m ting as B a of course roun always having mado 11 1 practice to be b faithful and pulli in his hl duties when hop top War bumon opened tile attack n ahn lin he b wa is antona abil and in though rOv roverud erod his at M nava fitly to nept e it to defend bunal hU nal if the bhole hole lr iv wa arr beloro re jv i realized cd full ully V the 1 ivaa aa A curil ilig ng I 1 ground of tho the deiml liim lal A q ab UK ill people at tile the pit poleg V warburton do claring that it m I 1 hout b oil 11 gritchlow 1150 inon n ilk 11 but laub ln iusa t n dc vil I 1 1 1 a I 1 I 1 I 1 should the he people at the that roven should be NS N S SWORN ACCOUNT dowell yesterday made affidavit be foro fore W G young tov hat occurred at the teachers ton chers meeting ills deposition anns a as foil tol loAs 31 I 1 state stat or of utah city and county of oc salt lake ln 0 ke sq 8 james charlie 9 bowen being first duly sworn on his oath pays gays that he Is 19 a ilk aber of oc the mormon church that ho he li t ia a resident resi dont ot 0 tho the first blah his h aps ops p vard A rd 0 S salt lake cl alt I 1 and up lip t to 0 q thursday v e n t tig 2 ar 1197 it of the teachers ia chera quorum quork III of n said first n ward ard in glod I 1 land ing that on said evening evenin ff th the regular re zular monthly meeting of nr said paid teachers quorum wits wag held in tho the gllnn ward illert ing linuse in paid mid salt sail loko lake city and hat the fol loIng named per bons anione others siliwa N aers ere present they being also alao bombero of said paid quorum riuo jn aph warburton john T thorup first counselor nell ra mua cn second counselor M t J F kakl 1 Kt akle kl hoph thonia jl it F F thorp tharp lip arnold sa arnold 11 1 I theFts james 1 P stilling jolla john peter morten morann Mort nn on andrew Morlen fountain S johnson thomis johnson johnon scholl Sr Fel holL loles I dehol Pc liol john Vet teril brother barr muser mus lu sor er fred musser 2 alpo rl go hatt hankins kins creigh 1 I ulm king kin john squires chat charles lea tor and henry that ot at said after the regular business had been ed of dishop joseph warburton stated to tile the meeting in substance a 94 follows thit that he it harl had been uptown darlng lh the day and had visited holics hall and other places hrc anch tell things boucht not to have been talked about and was aked rone ernine nt other bowen n on election el action day at tile the polls that such mich action was vas the talk ot of th the town and that it hall had boon been asserted that row annen en had been gulling slid and deceiving tile the pen pl that he would like to hear further concern I 1 11 I 1 I 1 1 I 1 I 1 k I 1 J I 1 11 I 1 I 1 n I 1 I 1 f I 1 II 11 q rr al I 1 3 I 1 1 I 1 J s I 1 I 1 ak N 3 4 ak 11 p I 1 1 ak 11 k 3 N I 1 I 1 N i 11 IN na t I 1 r M W W y I 1 I 1 I 1 A 1 I 1 1 I 1 I 1 I 1 r I 1 t 1 I 1 i r I 1 I 1 ai I 1 Q 1 1 I 1 1 1 1 i 1 I I 1 I 1 1 I 14 I 1 W q 1 4 1 1 I 1 I 1 V I 1 21 at i 11 I 1 I 1 I 1 1 0 1 I 1 1 Z I 1 I 1 I 1 I 1 I 1 I 1 11 I 1 Y i I 1 I 1 1 I 1 I 1 james charles bowen ing ng the matter front from brother jolla john T thorup that thereupon tin brodber th thor orup ip stated to tile the ine cLing in ice as ollow fl that lie he went to tile the polls polla nit in elec tinn day and III wits was told by brother M J makle that flint drother brother bu HUH cri en wa peddling pc lor for mrs Alep rs wilson an and and dec the h peolia thereby that he vent ent to la brother bowen and red him lint he be WAS duing khat tickets lie had ilal drainer bowen ansu erod in on an indirect and evasive way uni that he ar had the or words to that of ft feet that h he immediately sorn alother to drive him 1 in the lebrat ward hrc here he h notified tho the people thereof that rather bowen had bad turned traitor that during the day he threatened to have drotser arrested or ling the voters rot cra that tl IL lady had conte dillong and dowen look her into a room and ana that v hen file came camo out nut he brought her to the polla the asp of vati tir that orson I 1 to it heard the lady say ay that she had not bee bran n alven e n tile the tight ticket by 13 dow llowen es that brother F W eakle then stated to n tile the in ance n ni anllo eliat hat drother jansen had her ats d ihrl by a ticket to him by brother bouen that lerother chariot at mated in Flub tInCe to ill that ho had pono rone to tile thi polls polle will b his s na ilac ife abat brather dou coven en h 1 I 1 lil 0 ire ife a ticket when slit had a I 1 nl ill ready and alid that boothr powell llowen ought bt to he be arrested i brother in kub stalled that brother broiler driven niia ails ilke a L t that andrew 1 stated fit g nt that erotha Erot hr bova BA ii ought to in be throan out of tile th meeting that brother choice stated in inc that brother eow bow rn on ai as a st a judas that fountain S johnson johnron stated in pub manco that brother nowen flowen ought to lip lie skinned that flishie joseph lV Va arburton therell thereupon pon stated in substance that they could not nol have IL a in tho the tol rbra u ubo h awl deceive uio the people pe and in moved that hoen bv as aa a teat teather teacher her slot not lot or p peddling linc wamon abid critchlow I 1 tic eta but fat ft elving the people kople pol 1 r clr boilon wan vas I 1 pu and upon by uplifted hand I 1 I 1 7 on rago I 1 BOWEN IS EXPELLED continued from rago pace 1 and declared carried by bishop war var burton that when said motion ians as put I 1 brother dowen asked afkend the privilege of I 1 making HII tx explanation in rel reply ly to the chaires an it alch tell had teen been made against him by the brethren present that thai such privilege mas alas refused by bishop war burlon uon mho lie stated in substance sut stance na as follows no it il will cause a and you cannot talk that atter alter paid earld motion had been put rand and declared ca car ri heal brother hi oilier rouen again I 1 the he pr lilio it go of making art i explanation t lo 10 0 t tho I 1 to mi ting alch bach uns aa again denied ilni till by hasho laai but ion ho he said in substance you cannot lalk here on oil that subject that thereupon brother cloen said 1 all that you have heard tonight Is it not a t true Bio bitthien Bi ethien thren I 1 t you goodnight good night land and thereupon left tho the nn ni etting that said douan on oil ills oath says that the th made against him of develling dec dacel elling inc and anal intimidating voters on election duly day aro are absolutely falser that I 1 went to the polls on election lay day and corked tor for the regular nominees nece masars wilson and critchlow chlow or of the inas convention had loon been held in the birst municipal ward openly fan and I 1 above board ANIt hout intent of do de calving any person penton and that I 1 did not let in any instance In stancu decele dec lc any person by an anything which I 1 did on that day that I 1 was approached on sev elial al different occasions duijn the day by in bembera orn bers of my day teachers tonch tra quorum lie ho me lira arrest and to 0 otate throw tile me through it a window arid staled 1 to me that if I 1 in peddling laigon bihon ond and critchlow crutchlow tickets that I 1 naas aa never to anier his one or 0 tile members of my quamin aforesaid door again that alc 1 I were hurled harild iv nt at me and I 1 wag abused most shamefully I 1 that rt at said meeting the chaws charges above mentioned were made me without any warning whatever that such charges would be made that no op opportunity ity of any kind was given civen me to answer the same sam that no ito proof profit was made ia do to substantiate such charges cha nor was naas I 1 granted the privilege of defending myself in any way whatever but wis summarily in the mannor manner aforesaid as a teacher in the teachers re quorum of the first bishops bla hopa ward jamna BOWEN witness john jl 11 beers sub subscribed s anti and to before mo me tills 3 ai ad d day of 0 december A D aseal WILLIAM G YOUN youart notary public WAS AT FIRST FOR SYMONS sy IONS dom bow en ell states that he was in the first ward mass ec convention invention 1 I irk A d to bring about Sy Symon monas ss nomination there lie he said but we lie were beaten I 1 believe in standing by the choice of conventions w when 1 en the men nominated are competent and honest therefore I 1 decided to vote for critchlow and winon I 1 had no idea then of doing active work in their behalf the morning of election was mas cold arid and dionny st imy I 1 was unable to work nork and I 1 derided decided to holp help at the polls I 1 saw in the that john henry smith said the masa ma na sa poll on should be sustained and I 1 believed he understood the situation matlon al thai I 1 told loli symons thit that morning that I 1 C support him 1 I 1 said to lo him alla 1 hai gulped him all I 1 could in III the convention ven tinn and would be glad to support WILL him it he had been nominated but that I 1 had to stand by tho the convention nominees mr symon Is president of the sixteenth quorum of seventies to which I 1 belong lie ile called me aside and told me I 1 should consider the election cler llon carefully as it was mas a serious affair I 1 replied that I 1 knew it but I 1 help himi sall said also alno that lie could have pot got the nomination had we not item wanted ta the whole earth and lost every everything thin will you carry your dismissal up was ivan ahod 1 I dont know dochen bow en answered the th e whole av h 0 I 1 0 than thing was so sudden that 1 I 1 avent had time to decide on my course I 1 dont know what else dae may bo be in store for me but I 1 have been attacked publicly and I 1 cant believe it improper for me to reply in the same way A DEVOUT MOrt MORMON MON bowen Is st a very conscientious member of the church chuich of 0 jesus christ it if latter day saints dy by his plot assion of oc belief in the IN mormon formon faith he alienated ills his family but this opposition has only increased mcrea sed his religious for fervor r those who know him say he Is a vc devotee devoice 0 the mormon word of wisdom has gilded aided him aldays abw ays since lio embraced that faith lie he Is now 40 years of am alze for the last eighteen years vears of the two score he has lived bowen ban ha not tasted intoxicating drink in any form though philadelphia born tile his early life was nine spent in ki el gland bland since he came to ulab III thirteen lr years yeara ao ago lie he has tasted neither tera tea nor cottee coffee lie he has refrained I 1 from born the iwo hue or of tobacco also during th that it t entire period ills recent gh has 1 not I ot altered his views in any res respect peet he still remains the zealot he hay has been ever since ho he first embraced alo mormonism but lie he has very clear ideas of the dl iding line bein een church and slate it was because of the nature ot of sy me monab ss candidacy and support that dowen could not aid him dowan voted against the celebrated celebia I 1 ed thatcher manifesto being tile only man who he did so go whon when the document was vias submitted at the first ward asard conference by joseph E taylor immediately after the tha geria Lial conference at which thatchers i name was chopped from the list of apostles CAUSED A SE SENSATION the report of the quor urns action it 0 n I 1 which became known yesterday annii 11 I 1 0 12 ing about town created a genuine sell pen faction sac tion it wa ass discussed everywhere in varying varyl nit language by citizens some bome 0 if whom were disi disposed posed to gloomy to toro re bodinka because or of the occurrence the ox expulsion of bowen was con condemned denine 11 lull universally Iver sally by gentiles and the mons na who were heard speaking speak lne in defense fenste of 0 it were few bitter feeling is reported as existing in tile tho beighl neighborhood ot at bowens bowena home ria as a resta result t of 0 f tho thia controversy excited e cited by tile the election bowen Is 13 not chec the only one who I 1 Is s belne being ostracized another caso case lepor reported ted Is that of 0 ayoung a lir r non men woman a domestic who I 1 doted for critchlow and tor for so ao dolne doing was alln denied od admission to tile homo home of her family PY y her unforgiving father |