Show WILL NOT TAX INCOMES house democrats oppose a party principle ONLY TEN GAVE IT SUPPORT zenner konner the author of the th lar laix Mea measure suie vainly warned his brethren that their party would not approve the defeat ot of the bill three other measures including tho free school book bill killed echo ot of the reunion of the ita w has pull two bills introduced ten democrats of 0 the thirty nine in fit the house voted tor for konners income gincomo tax bill chich mits killed hy by tho the hostility of 0 the party pledged to 0 o taxation t tit of incomes this action iv iraa a 9 not to t taken without n r reminder of 0 I 1 pirty party platforms for kenner kellner in ill con cl lils ills ha 00 for the measure mea auro his hla fellow minivera that they about to vote voie on a bill embodying the lh of the domo cracy ot of the nation anil and ot of the suito state ills his barning was waa in van and the bill bil I 1 was waa defeated doCe aled tho the opposing members tile the income tax in feature ot of tile the bill and maintained that while tile tho SUP supreme rem cour court t or of the united states had pronounced such a tax unconstitutional there was waa nothing to prevent fluch a state law ile he argued v velh ill com inching logic in fa favor v or of the tax provided lommori objected to A tax on so small email mi an inheritance as 1100 1000 ON BOTH SIDES shepard made an argument at thi same time for and against the bill in theory ile ho waa v for an income tax but ho hellevi d its results would bo be aa the burdens of tins tile jai law tall ta would all only upon those with the iho s after inc incomes mes he maintained that AT tance an icher inheritance tax would simp if y punish un I 1 the ail widow dow and orphan an and be in c effect double taxat taxation ton sl sloan a n asserted that A nans mans apparent antol income n c ome does doe pot not properly represent lila hill income ile he might have an income of 0 float property on r which fe th it fet interest terest charf harg tea f a are more than that amount for this ronson reason lie he faired the limitation of the tax lax to not net incomes ets as suggested by Mi epard hh Sh epards amendment limiting tho the action ot of the th act to net inca free was then cart can led murdock offered an amended schedule for income taxes which was accepted by kenner as aa follows on 2000 to 1 per cent to 10 2 I 1 per rent to 3 per cei cent or more 4 per cent mangan Min cran offered a new schedule eche dulo ot of taxes as ai follows follow from htwa lt wa to 2 per cent 2000 to 3 per cent to 0 4 pier cent SAM to i 5 per cant cent s i to 6 tier per cent to filo 7 per cent to f per cint ci nt to 9 per cent 1 or more 10 irr cent cicer followed with A motion to out the entile the section relating to inheritance taxation CHURCH AND STATE sloan said maid that kenner had firs his dictionary mixed up tip with his doctrine and covenants Coven ams tho the latter says a man cur in tho the house amendments to mrs cannons Can nonn bill for the compulsory education cat ion of deaf mutes ond and blind and as asking king the appointment of a conference committee speaker pc perkins rolna named mrs irs la karlh mangan manean and benn ion sw al the conferees conf eroca and adjournment dolther journ Jorn ment followed 4 offering ott ering as an excuse for killing the tha measure their hostility to a provision I 1 ac t contained tor for the lie taxation 0 of inheritances the day opened with a spat pat s over the journal of wednesday Wednes dy J in which la is set bet forth the incident of 0 the missing members and the lost sergeant at arms the members mho ho had insisted on the journals showing the facts of the at fajr fair hold had been able to outvote the absentees on thursday and by a clever parliamentary trick hd had pre anted ted any further action so that ashen shepard moved yesterday to reconsider the vote refusing to expunge the minutes ot of wednesday evening he was ruled out of order by the adoption of 0 hostile committee reports eho bills were killed shepards Sh epards no 24 relating to ra railroad 11 companies no cl 61 lor for the purchase and distribution oi ot textbooks text books among district schoot pupils the house concurrent resolution reso lutio it appropriating pr at 1 ng 2500 lor for an exhibit at tile the T tennessee centennial also was waa killed in this way NEW MEASURES bills were introduced and upon second reading referred as follows tol lowi by brennion to prevent the adulteration of binegar it Is made unlawful to manufacture or bell any vinegar containing any preparation of lead copper sulphuric acid or other ingredients injurious to health manufacturers of vinegar and dealers are required to have stenciled on ahr e end ot f each barrel arrel lit irv lett letters c ra or one e inch in length the stand standard ard strength of ohp i negar violation of 0 the act Is made a misdemeanor punishable by fine of to 50 and forfeiture fel turo of the vinegar not in accordance with the act referred to the public health com mitlee by price Validating water certificates certificates for the use of 0 water issued by county Select selectmen mon under the revisions provisions of section 2725 compiled lawa lamm of IMS are validated and the tha holders of the certificates certin cuto confirmed in the right to use such water as Is mentioned in the certificates a referred to the committee on agriculture and irrigation THE IDAHO VISITORS chairman sloan of the select committee appointed to arrange arrance tor for the reception of the idaho legislature reported that hla his committee had wired asking the Ida idahoans Idaho homins ans to defer their examine coming until sunday find stating that the uth legislature was to meet in joint session jie silon on monday next with the lawmakers ot of idaho we received this reply last evening said he vib febi 19 we ens are highly strait flod fled at aou our thoughtful conal brution und a ad 0 our ur 1 elements ana iland compliments G IT II NY MOORE pre ident A it Sp speaker Oaker twenty minutes afterward this dispatch caule came 0 wo o ft ill arrive sunday rooming morning mr sloan recommended that all the members of the not gol going n 9 to lugan be named a committee to entertain the visitors and this recommendation men mon dation was accepted alter after some discussion INCOME TAX BILL BIH Kc kennera Kenn erB bill for or an income and in 4 inheritance herl tax was the first on the calendar f tor or third reading before the reading began thomson arose and said bald I 1 would ilk like to ask mr mir shepard it till this bill Is 13 constitutional the tha reference to Sh epards proneness to urge ure against ob measures caused a ripple 0 of laughter nelch it job was increased when retorted 1 mr ir speaker it L L customary for or a man to lo eive a lawyer a retainer when ho asks hta his advice the bill provided for im an income tax as follows on 2000 to Z 2 per der cent amo to 3 per cent or more 4 per cent tho the inheritance tax lax was flord by the th bill us as follows on 1000 to I 1 2 per cent to 1500 3 per cent 1166 or more 4 pw per cent it in support 0 of the bill said that it would if enacted into law the iho Int eleRt on the bonded in n dotted neBs of f the th state and the in driess itself before ln fri tile passing raB lna of oi I 1 I 1 the tha plesent Sone ration ile hi shall pay 10 per cent on his increase not on his income lie he argued against at an i inheritance tax dotson boison wils opposed op poised to on an tance tax also murdock il followed tall owed in the pitr uma e vein ho he believed trio dead should be allowed to escape taxation and he argued that an estate always suffered lemly in depreciation by tho the death ot of lu its owner gomney believed that an inheritance should be taxed the wealth acau accumulated u in the state he argued should confer some benefit to tile state slate mr romney was proceeding proceed lne to state the justice of c f an inheritance tax when sloan interrupted suppose yup pose you had eight children childre nIMr mr romney ro niney and it wife ulso also and died aou would id you want II 11 a tax imposed on the estate you left I 1 them hem Rom answer c be heard in fit tho the laughter that followed toll owed tho the questioning ile he proceeded with his as a aring ills its hearers of the great bubli aa 0 of 0 a law that would not to tax x nn an inheritance loss less than this h ho 0 said did not rotor reter to tile the estate but to E tho lla 0 various bequests X bennt enn c r followed earnestly in opposition ito A to the t he creer citer motion to strike out which tailed failed 15 to 19 sloan offered a substitute top for tho the brangan cancan schedule providing tor for a uniform tax ot of I 1 per cent on all inheritances heri corning coining from an estate of or more ray hay presented a second substitute tor for tho the mangan manean schedule it wasl wai front from to 1 per cent to 2 per cent to 30 3 per amit nt to 4 1 I per ent and over 6 5 per cent tile ray kay amendment carried 20 1 to 12 22 airs ira anderson andersen ross rose to state her belief belet that tho the bill was most unjust for that reason sho she moved to out the enacting clause lost TO PUNISH WIDOWS before the bill Is put upon passage I 1 would like to have the title amended to read an act to punish widows tor for becoming g widows said ald sloan anu and 1 the motion lira its anderson followed ol lowd wanted to make another ame amendment rayment but was wa ruled out ot of order still tho the musical voiced member from cache could not be shut oft before he had stated hla his request for ar information as to tile tho fund to b bo 0 bene apted by the tax 1 I want avant it to po go to the be district school I 1 s he nose I 1 led and aaa at town down before tile roll c call a 11 was had a number of the bemb members cre explained it that lat they would mould have to vote to against the bill because of 0 the pravE provision sion to tax inheritances heri si the rhe bill was defeated 13 to 25 as fOlIO follows WB agyei drehrer kenner mrs la barthe mansan mangan murdock obrien len price ilay sorensen of son salt pete sorensen of grand thomson speaker Por klile 13 noes sirs mrs anderson bennion Denn lon callie cook of rich dolson dunin duffin gibson greenwood hansen bandoni blardy hopkin kin lommon Lo nimon lund maxfield mckay purry parry robinson ItoM romney homney shepard Sho panl art sloan taylor wheeler r wilson 35 25 absent cook of box rider nider creer forshee Forn hee kimball ot or carbon kimball kemball of cache martin roylance Royla VOTES SHORT OB bin bill no ko 03 93 permitting counties count lea cities towns school a boards and school districts to und fund floating indebtedness debt edness at the time utah was vas admitted as aa a state was next taken up and defeated by failure of the majority the vote vota being harln 19 13 to 9 gibson lemmon lund land maxfield party parry price artoe obi ten sorensen sorena cn ot of grand craod and glicck wheeler r voting in tile the alega negative obrien gave eave e ave notice of motion to reconsider speaker perkins announced as a com top to receive and entertain tho the haho Logia lature martin kimball of cache sloan and perkina on motion of it was wa clooj to meet on monday at 11 upon motion of 0 cook of box aider of 0 POtes bill provid lit g for or the inspection of horsey horses and cattle battla over any railroad of thi the artap was WAB re committed to the livestock live stock committee which will hear arguments for ald a alnut the lh bill 1111 ni at it 11 I 1 I 1 ti nil 1 tuesday mornine next A I 1 senate 1 I 1 communication was wa read fi tating that uial body refused to oon clon |