Show acHuRcH CHURCH WINS IN SUPREME COURT 1 Gets Real Estate After Third Hear Hearing wr 11 t a D ing Before the High Tn Tri Tribunal bunal t t i OTHER tHER DECISIONS JS GIVEN OPINIONS ARE RENDERED IN MINING CASES air S Coining Coming before boore the supreme court c rt for forthe forthe forS S the third time the ease case of the Church of Jesus C st of Saints against Watson was ivan decided decided SI ed yesterday in lU favor of the church In Inan inan inan an opinion written by Justice McCarty and concurred in by Chief Justice Bartch Bart h and Justice StrauD In each ac 1 trial a decree was rendered in favor of the church chur h as plaintiff The judgment was reversed twice by the supreme preme s court but coming up the third time on ona ona ona a different state of facts from those h that obtained in the former instances S the decision in favor of the plaintiff Is affirmed which establishes the title of S the church to the property Involved Claim of Contestant The property consists of the premises o at 21 South Fourth West street treet Salt 4 Lake The place was wa owned by George Chatfield who died Aug 4 Ij 1886 leaving I 5 his wife as his only or heir at law He bequeathed the property to the church with a life ute Interest In Jn the property to his widow Mrs Chatfield died in 1899 and the defendant in the present case Mrs Watson a daughter of Mrs Chat Chatfield Chatfield field by a former marriage sought to secure the property on the ground that 5 Mr AIr Chatfield was dying at the time he made the bequest to the church and was was in no condition to realize what he was doing Mrs Watson has retained possession of the property since her mothers death The court holds that while It was evi evident evident dent that Mr Chatfield was in great pain P the great preponderance of at the thet t i evidence Is that he was rational and realized fully what he was doing when I 4 he be e deeded the property to the church t 1 Other Decision by Court i 5 The supreme court reversed the de decision decision decision in favor of the defendant in the case of Mary Iary Helstrom against Isaac Hodes Rodes and orders a new trial The Thease case ase Involves title to the Lily lode at Tintic The lower court held that Mrs MrsS S 1 Helstrom held part of the claim in trust for Rodes Rodez although she had relocated S the claim as the Julia lode after the i assessment work for 1898 had not been 1 done The opinion is a unanimous one f written by Justice I 1 The court affirmed the judgment in inthe inthe L the case of the tle Red Wing Gold Mining company against William D Clays ap appealed appealed appealed pealed by the company The company sued Clays owner of the Julia Dean claim at BIngham for alleged trespass claiming that he took ore are from the Co Columbia Columbia lumbia and Silver Hill Clays set setup setup setS S up that the ore are In question was taken c from veins that had their apexes with within S in fl the lines of his claim The district court found for Clays and the supreme court holds likewise |