| Show DINGLEY BILL IS DEAD republican leaders give up the contest HERMAN SAYS ITS HOPELESS an animated animated debate in fit tile the swats senate which covered A wido wide range taking in the tariff nud and r financial questions vest PAYS lays a to bryan and denounces the method of carrying elections with avith money teller sure that bryan was not elected he says I 1 washington dec IG the session ot of hc senate developed the most cent eventful ful and exciting debate that fiber cither branch ut of congress liaa has heard beard for a long time it brought forward for Nard tile lie reorganized organized re loaders leaders of 0 the arlous parties and tle lie merits including auch conspicuous figures as af a f means bles shrimati Shei mati prye l teller Gorni ill vest aldrich pla plait it liale hale mitchell ot of oregon chandler und and allen alien in notable on tile hie leading questions which have engaged the attention of oc gress and the country of late not only yes vas tile the line file laid down on tarin and finance but the debate partook lar took of nil ail the pent tip ill feeling re stil tant it from rom the hie national contest it was dramatic in its ita intensity and at ull all times absorbingly interesting Inte g to the crowd in the gallera gal lerl 8 anil intent body ot of senators political differences cattle caino in an for a fair share of attention and tile tho names ot of air 2611 and mr bryan often were heard president cleveland clevelan d also canio in for a share of at attention if n mr air allen alien declared that tho the president 91 e it t was waa a republican aho who vho rejo rejoiced c with vf h republicans over lite recent mutual 11 L a I 1 victory the debate came unexpectedly ahen lien mr vest called up tho the allen alien resolution resol ullon lor for of the dingley bill lit in broer to make sonne some remarks on it mr vest was in mf ill usual caustic vein and ills his speech teemed with those graceful and catchy phrases phia for which c e la Is noted it severely arraigned the Joc doctrine trine of protection and derided the promises ot of prosperity held out outi lie ike says tv by air mckinley which chic h could not be fulfilled by levying more taxes on the people there were frequent sharp and nd amusing cross fires be between teen mr vest and Aldric ti chandler and frye tile the debate advanced to a more acute state when nhen mr allen alien with ills his usual bluntness began to question mr chandler as to the hie FUTURE or OF THE DINGLEY BILL ile he asserted that thai the republicans had no reason to fear car opposition from th the L president who had I 1 gone over body and soul to the republican party th this Is brought forward sir air sherman Sher nian and sir mr teller the ohio senator spoke M valli till deep earnestness declaring that it was a crime for or congress Cons reig not to lo give the government ample revenue tor for needful expenditures lie he characterized the silver substitute to the dingle y bill as a monstrosity designed to cripple legislation mr Clev elands course in issuing bonds to maintain the gold reserve he approved mr teller P pointed a anted out the fu utility ot of urging the dingley bill As t to 0 future tariff legislation he reserved ats lit judgment on it until the measure v was vas presented and its merits considered sir mr gorman german also alao pointed out the he t u of 0 urging the L y bill conceding ho however weer that march next the republican senators would w bo be in sufficient strength to pass pasa a bill As to the course on an the democratic side elde lie he said he anticipated no obstruction to such a measure beyond insistence bosl alence on rea reasonable debate throughout the debate the sentiment had prevailed that the dingley hill was dead and to give this final and apparently official sanction I 1 mr platt ot of the finance committee con announced that no effort would be made to urge that bill to e mr air shep man promptly arose and alid ald lit in view ot at what had been sall sald he acquiesced quiet ced wed in tile the general benti sentiment ment that no further effort should be made on the dingley bill tills this was regarded as the linal final disposition or oc the bill vast ON WE TIIE FLOOR floon tile tho bitter debate came on in an ail apparently patently ly innocent way when mr air vest veal I 1 cat called up tile Dill gley bill upu upon to lo submit IL few kb there vas as ile ll 11 warning of oc tho the storm to come cattle oa cs specially ally v m hen lie ile stated hl its appreciation tit of the hie fact that lie he vas mas about to on a dond issue the alie hill bill lift regarded as a remarkable piece ot of legislation leBl born of 0 the dentral warning to that eliat alm it countr count rys yi finances were in such a ilan dall berous condition LIMA tile the usual holiday recess might well bo abandoned al lIdon ed the lull bill had bail riot not come from the wool grow brew ers or from iron iran interests tile the production ot of tin LIT plate said bald air vest had increased notwithstanding the dee cate of 0 I 1 cent per pound on oil tin see secured ared by the present law and ret that reduction had been secured only at the point of the he legislative this brought on lt a spirited paa p saze between mr me alarich and mr fr vest the former belal df blared e I 1 that it avab va f well known that thai tho the iton iron schedule ot of tile the wilson bill was waa prot protective etIve in char a z ter and that it if iron iran and tin had I 1 awn e e it treated as other oilier n tides had been they too would mould have bave been struck doun domn this prodoc production ciori N as 03 duo due farsi arst to the original protective duties on tin and to that thai pat atiat remnant ot of duty maintained in the present law the senator from rhode island with the prest doer not bec baem rn to agree dent elect mr air mckinley on oil this tin responded air ir vest the question senator sald said lie ha h had ad read a recent interview with sir mckiniry at canton in which lie ho said that the increased ot of tin was due to tile the use production oils ot of indiana la in tile the natural at 0 the manufacture ot of tin plates but mr mckinley must be mistaken raid paid mr vent tor for he found indiana had only live tin alks out ot of seventy seven in ou operation no ratton said mr air ve vest veit it th this can bo be answered only by an ail absolute surrender of fit the senator benator frown from ithone island inland of the contention that tile the denorn enormous IOUs gitles ot of the mckinley law are slite domestic industries ot of nary hary to the united ted mates the senator asserted that the opium habit had no more deadly hold on oil its A than this advocacy of protection lie analyzed the results of 0 tile wool schedule ot or till tb present law shoil shoeing ng that many factories fac torlea hud had been established the year A return to tile tho old id hystek KM its proposed prop sd by tile the nii icley bill meant disaster to thu the ers of 0 woolens why Is in it 11 a tilted asked the senator that with tho ball balance ance ot of trado trade in our favor arld with ill the a gold eold standard Blan dard in n force the iho country ix its in A STATE OF DISTRESS wo avo were told said nield lie that with the election of 0 mckenley prosperity would hood flood the tat land I 1 d like sunshine MeNt mckenley nicy was waa acted caid ct id but fill him prosperity come will increased prosperity e orrin como with our bill adding more tr taxes to tile the burden ot of tile tho people and heaping up rn more re money in the treasury while I 1 may be subjected to the charge ot of helner being a lunatic an abt aud repudiator declared mr vest 1 I assert that the only relief for or the people la is to give them moie make money it wo we are lunatics and anarchists because wo we fask bk tor for the opening ol of tile the mints to treo free C coinage or of alli er then over six million american amerlee 1 I freemen who voted tor for wll anvil J bryan are arc lunatics alit ally anav hod oil hot licup p tile Ite public hut it I 1 la S it 11 vile slander blander tile the men mell ahr I 1 q so supported rt d that great croat leader william if 3 illyan are aa loyal und ind UA as in tell igent a i body nr at men as ail tiny in III this coll alry T the ic gold standard at tile die loot of tills this evil Is 11 the lite viles ever coit coin aved c in tie the 1 mind reind of mortal tile the senator mile of oc t tin 1 I recent election ice as a parody on oil ripe five ate N MIS ag anxious to ace what became or oc the plo posed hy by lite avna tor froni from Nebra tik L allen allani lie he was inclined it bellel 0 the senator f froin roin new I 1 a till p chandlor chandler was ahn hn io ILL lared that tin tilt st conven L 1 llon I was with fraud and 1111 that the delegates there tail hail be awn n bat galoch joor jar and bought to it a question by mr ile ut us liy in why it 11 was that hiat it the a woin and till all alit otylior v I 1 industries nere mere aihini ask iiii for protection mr debt answered that of oc course they wanted more protection alive I allt im a lul lot of co coyotes aej lt 1 famished they wanted more bounty ty they would conic come with the lie plead pica 1 I 1 I 1 voted lor for I 1 want inore protection lr frye bald he be bould present just juat two pin twin in answer to the urt senator arst Ti rat never before in nil big experience per peri lence ence had bad lio lie known it a time when tho the wool industry was so BO dead ua tie it was today second lending leading wool authorities thorit ties lel had declared lillutt kiil halt ot of tho the woolen mlis were closed the vuot N oat schedule was m As tile very worst one olle or of all ail in the present tariff law it had resulted lit in an inundation of oc the country with will cheap shoddy roods goods mr all vest asked u hy by it W was s that sixty flin woolen nolon mills were st snarled ailed in wil and only rot edity ty five one lear ear of the mckinley bill to which I ilch mr air crye with a tit as ta to why fly a magnificent mill at ill his home of great value hall recently sold at the sacrifice price of tl 1000 mr frye fryc went on to 0 o kay bay that it if the dingley bill was not passed lie pie pic dietes dieted an enormous OF JAIrOn IMPORTS TS within the hie next tour four inantha in anticipation of tho the greater duties thereafter alii reatter there was a burst ot of laughter lauch tor at one po point 1 int 1 aulien mr air ich deferred to the lite position po atlon ot of mr icat and lna ills great ereal leader mr my former lealer lc aler interposed mr air vest vert till such vigor on oil the lite former tori wr as ad to make Senit senators tors anti and g a roar mr vest remarked ked that lie mall ana surprised to hear senators on tho the other side talk of mills being closed now how could that lie be since mcaninley was elected circled wo we are arc living under democratic laws interjected mr fryt frye yes hut bui everybody assumes that the election 0 mckenley AICKin ley means tile the return to at e 11 n ley tariff rates the ihl dingley bill 1111 Is dead it reposes in the tomb oc at tile the Capul capilets ets and in its place abill a hill all tho the old rates la Is being matured mr mella oem dem ter sala said he looked to a radical tarin tariff measure in tile the next Con congress Co nereM grebs for the republicans had the presidency and in his judgment both branen branches es of coave Conf fres beyond much doubt lie he spoke of the shoddy and hair which was in general use its as wool as a result of wool M election sir fr chandler carrid came forward at this point to urse urge that the immigration bill had tile the i leht ight or of way but ho he was soon seen involved in a lively and colloquy I 1 squy with mr allen alien mr chandler said said that as the dingley bill was according accordine to mr air vest in the tombs of the hie Cap capul ta why N by was it brought forward knori now there was no serious purpose by the senators from nebraska or missouri Mis mearl allen alien and vest to urge the bill to a final vote did tho the tomb of 0 the Capul capilets ets apply to tile senate hamber chamber or the finance committee asked mr air chandler amid laughter I 1 mr air chandler pointed out that the opposition or oc the president must be considered in connection with the prospects of the dingley bill jie ile Is not my president although alt houch lie he helped to elect my Pros president Ident added mr air chandler mr air gallinger pressed a question as 03 to whether the president would a bill with a tree free silver amendment 1 11 I do riot not stand bland near his excellency answered mr ali allen alien and I 1 cannot say what he will do lie ile has no party lie ile had a bare remnant of 0 a few thousand votes ill him last lail fall I 1 assume he liaa has rone gone over body and soul to the republican party I 1 SHERMAN HAS till FLOOR air sherman and mr air teller anere cro both on their feet as a 3 mr allen alien closed seeking recognition and there was intense interest on the floor and in the galleries sir mr shei man was ural first recognized ire ile spoke nv walli ith ai cical cat it was ivas a crime sir mr sherman declared that congress remained idle falling to 10 lo do lla its paramount pol lamount duty duly ot of providing sufficient sulli clent revenue for the expella A 1 ot I f tile die government biorn on the civil war down donn to aw congress ConK ivna had rimer failed to provide the gov virn ment with necessary revenue after ill the ping passim of tile tho wilann anvil aon bill tile hie rev enios fell off 01 the deficit di llull result WILS the iha direct result n of f the lie wll sol law with this hla dic denall elicit exi it was va tho the plain duty of congress tu to pro alv nie revenue we jve ought to do it exclaimed the senator 1 it l la 19 it a shame A degrace to the congress of the hulled states to compel the issue at 0 brids lit in the time 0 of f peace to meet the Govern governments ex cx that bill or ilder to tile tho dinsley bill 1111 la Is a mero mere cowardly or of legislation declared mr air sherman Sh trman pas idaa hil lately 1 I say it niall emphasis it MIS mas there to prevent action in a measure framed to aid the operations of 0 tile hie government the fault fakult ot of the bond issues was on Cong congress Tess the president hadl had lone done what lie was waa forced joao etien he sold gold tile the bonds said all mr TELLER IN THE DEBATE there was its an addel added interest when I 1 tie mr teller rep colo coin contributed ills ilia share to the debate mr bellve sald tile the question was could tilt the dunkley bill 1111 be passed lie had it noi hesitation in declaring as an ail answer to lo that question that there was waa III no earthly leason for supposing it cougil pasq pasi it was mas the basest pretense to pretend that the hill bill could become a law without desiring to violate any confidence lie would tay bay that there was an obstruction in the banate which would not net permit it to become a law without a silver attachment tile the republican party parly lie c continued afi tin Is 14 about to come into biow power er it if it was not so late I 1 might express an ophelon as 03 0 to o the agen clea chich ell cn abbed it to do so I 1 may discuss that subject nt at another time the can call party I 1 ifert Is IM A about bout to come into power promised and pledged to dissipate lite condition now prevailing in all j i country we were told during the lite that the era cra of prosperity would begin as a soon as a the elke tion as aa over it if the alio predicted prosperity has cpr appeared eared on oil the lim hal I 1 xon ficon I 1 lave failed to bee it 11 you toil must pa hiis si A republican bill flamed from a standpoint I 1 it 1111 riot not lie ill mckenley bill I 1 lii 14 c I 1 lit in tile the st louls pla biform that tile the |
