OCR Text |
Show THIS UTAH STATESMAN, FERBUAKY 7, 1929. CHARLES REDD AND A. E DEBATE ADVISABILITY OF CALLING UTAH CONSTITUTIONAL Representative Defends H it Resolution by Offering Weak Points of Document; Bowen Declares Accompanying Political Upheaval Would be Bad For State. Th, advlablllty of having a Just one or two counties or school convention was argued districts get tha benefit of it. than Redd Representative pro and con in a public hearing pafore the houae Judiciary commit touched upon tha system of taxataea Tueaday morning, with tion but did not go Into detail. Ila Charlea It. Redd of San called attention to tha fact that Juan county upholding hia resolu- the conatltutlon provides that all tion which providea for the call- property shall bo taxed at a uniing of the convention and with Ur, form nta and declared himself In A. E. Bowen, a Balt Lake lawyer, favop of a system wnich would speaxing againat the convention. lessen tha levy on homes and It on producing property, Ur. Bowen waa aaked to apeak by Ur. O. W Adame of the Utah Bute He declared he did not seek more revenue but only wanted a readNational bank, Ur. Adama repre aantlng hlmaelf aa a member of the justment. Mr. Redd also called attention Tax pa ye ra' aaaodatlon. to tha fact that tho corporation tax law of the state had been Redd's Reason. ) unconstitutional and that many lawyers had told blm that Ur. Redd baaed hia appeal for a tho state could not enact a cornew conatltutiona convention on poration tax law and have It conthe following itema: stitutional. First, inequalitlea in the educaConcerning elected officiate Ur. tional ayatem, which can not bo Redd called attention to tha fart corrected under the p recent that certain atate ofrtciaiia could ba paid only every three months Second, Inequalitlea in tha taxa- and that a proposal waa now betion ayatem which can not ba rec- fore tho aenato to correct thla. He tified without a change In the con- called attention to the fact Inal stitution. there was agitation to have the Third, certain Inequalitlea In the county attorney elected for four election and payment of atate yeura instead of for two years. He and othera whleh cannot he called attention to the power of rectified except by changing tha the asyisor in his own county and conatltutlon. lo the fart that tha county assessor , ' Fourth, certain Irrrgularlllea in was supremo in hia own sphere, a the matter of aaaeaaing which place also that. If thera were too mut$ authority in the handa which were obviously too cf aaaeaaora who may be Inex- high or too low tha state board perienced or Incompetent and tie of equalisation could do nothing the handa of the atate board of except make blanket changes. in rectifying theao m laoqualixation T nOWKX REPLIES ta kea.- Fifth, that tha makera of the Mr. Mr. Bowen questioned Vuh conatltutlon were working under a handicap becauae tha fight Redd's contention that a constitutional convention would call nut between tha Mormona and tha waa atlll in progreaa at the beat minds of tha state. Ur. tha tima of tha conatltutiona I con- Howen declared there waa no to bellave that anyone would vention In IMS, and that tha reauit convention of tha dietruat of each faction led bo In the conatltutlnnal to tha writing Into the conatltutlon other than thorn who had tha poastuteness to litical there. )le get many thlnga which ahould have also said that a eonatltutlonal conbeen placed on tha aUtuteai In vention had never been held any Mate until after a lot of pubBowen Dlaamta.' been aover.tl had and licity given proponed , drafts, mada by exports Mr. Bowen countered with the In aeonomy had been ofpolitical propoaltlon that if thera were any fered unofficially to tho thinking thlnga which ahould ba corrected people of the atate. tha people had the right to do ao Ur. Bowen declared that ' tha by eonatltutlonal amendment; that eonMitutlon. if framed, would have a eonatltutlonal convention waa to run tho gauntlet of public opln-- j nneceaaary and that the political on and that there was no reason unreal eauaed by calling a consti- to believe that tho people would ac-- 1 tutional convention would work cept principle In a new ronMI- grant hardahlp on the buaineaa of tullon that they would condemn in tha dtixena of tha aUte. Ur. to tha old. Mr. Bowen Bowen alto gave a general review of tho contenU of tho constitution but did not go into tho details. Ho declared that In hta opinion the only thing whirfi eaemed at all aarlous waa tha matter of changing tha Ux ayaum and that a amendment would certainly auffiea than In capo tha people cf tha auto wanted to changa thla MUCH WEALTH CONVENTION "Thirty Days Should be Reasonable Time Specified . in Statute. Regarding Financial Statement George P. Parker Declare Redd about tha apparent distrust In tho constitutional convention in 1196, adding howevar, that ha had not recently read tha proceedings of that convention. He declared that the people of the elate had been wanting statehood for years and that the only way by which they could get atatehood waa by getting to gather and framing a constitution of high standlpg. Ha declared that thera waa aa incantiva to gat together In HIM and that thera waa no particular incantiva in this day, v THU CONSTITUTION also disagreed with 'Many Discrepancies Seen Attorney General Gives In Statements Bled Under. Opinion on Meaning of School Publication Law Utah Corrupt Practices Act in. BOWEN Mr- - On tbs public domain, aayu the Geological Burvay, there arc aeras ef coal land which tons of contain 00,000,000,000 fuel for the future. This alngla Item glvaa aa Men of tha latest values thpt Mill remain In government-owne- d land. "While tha area of land atlll remaining In publlo ownership," aald President Coolldge In hie reoant message to Congress, "la small compared with tha vast area In private ownership, At tha request of Clyde Eppar-ao- n, praMdant of th Utah preae association Attorney General George F. Farker, suggested that SO days after the date of cloMng of hooka ahould be reasonable time to prepare a school financial statement. He also declared that tha ax pens nicnay mentioned In tha Matuta waa there as a maximum, and hot aa a a pacified amount to be drawn by the official whMher he used Auto licenses Republicans Leave $5,000 Hanging in Air With No Place to Light. AvaihUeAt plete the preparation ef the autamant aa required by the section. Tha term "reasonable time la a relative on and lta manning depends entirely upcircumon tha attendant stances. jt baa bean held In on ease, "a soon aa convenient;" in another, the least passible time after an event'' . and In many others It we held that "reasonable tima" was to bo hold according to tha circumstances of the ease and with particular reference to the means and ability of tha parson who is to perform. Othar eases have used the following language: "What la reasonable time depends upon tha nature of the act and of tho circumstances relating to Many Places ' Democrati Have $2,15Q Unsatisfactorily Sped fied on Account Slip, Milton H. Trolling, Secretary of State, announces that automobile licenses era now being distributed over tha state and that to ovoid (Continued From Pago On) tho general rush th last faw waaka Mato chairman ta plainly evident ha advises ths purchase of theao os soon aa possible. In that much or not. resources of those Many do not twice one showing a donation of tha natural Mr. Bowen stated briefly with public ownership are of Immense 104 which may have been hta al know Just how theao may ha seTha raquaMa and the opinion what each article of tha constitu- present contribution and another cured and to than hs gives tha and futura value. This la follows was tion dealt concerned. Bjace where ho turned In 604, aptnia aa to minerals and following Instructions: For tha benefit of those who may particularly "All automobile license must b parently collections, but merely water power. THE REQUEST. want to get a blrdaeya view of tho Lola of Phosphate. before March I. Pleas had hta name attached without the rsnawsd constltutom wo will give hia resource MM from which aa Thera are half a million acres of ha received th obtain licana your Balt Lake City. Utah, plates sume very briefly. soon aa possible. Neither did ha add th money. phoaphata land aeys a statement Jan. 18, MM. InArticle One Tha declaration from the department of tho "In almost every community word coltaetiona after tha nemo of lion, George P. Farker, Attorney of tho common rights of man. soma garage or local agent will Dan Shields who to credited with terior. that can supply 1,000.000,-00- 0 General, Salt Lake City. Two Boundaries of tho state. 609 donation. tons of thla essential fertillier Mr. Shields wax have on hand application blanks Dear Blr Ths Utah State Proas Thraa Duty of tho state to the as Its need on American farm la association la desirous of having ara of tho B sura to fill out tb application on th coltaetiona committee, but ws stated Aa above, nation, giving U. 8. tltla to public better realised. Thera la an unde- your Intepratailon aa to th mean- opinion that tha clerk would ba an card completely buff card for of course it ta possible that Dan land etc. termined acreage of potash depos- ing of section 4114 Compiled Lawa tied to sufficient tima to close hta passenger cars, blua for trucks and ! tossed that big donation Into th Four Concerning the right of its. tha best of which yet discover- of Utah, M17, In regard to of books and complete th prepara- trailers. Hava th card properly pot out of hta own poekot. ed ara on publlo lands. Thera art publication of tho financialdata suffrage. tho otatemont before giv- notarized and attach It to either state- tion Only $5,040 Off. gaa fields ment required In thla section. Sev- ing Itefto the newspaper where It your last year's certificate of regFive Distribution of the powers ft developed oil and Turning now to tb Republican of of the atate Into three departments with an annual production eral clarke of boards of education Is to be published- - Giving tha istration or certificate of owner- state committee final statement we barrels of oil. Thera nra have contended with publishers clerk th benefit of tho doubt wo ship, and tha proper fee as par find a dlacraptaney ef M.OUO In Judicial, legislative and axecu acres of oil shale from that there adtlvs. la no specified tima for are quits sura that thirty days' ochadul on tho back of applies- - their totals. This la very probably Bix Tha make up of the atate which possibly 00.000.000,000 barpublication set forth in tha sec- ditional time would b ample and tlon card. Don't send cash by mail, a clerical error but clerical errors ba extracted when tion, to time and reasonable that tha give ua legislature, time, length of term and rels of oil can clerks for your own protection send of thla sort havo no place In a may extremely high prices arrive to warrant the their own discretion aa to time of th clerk In which to dose hta eligibility. order or personal check. I rupt practices act statement. coat. even though they pom- hooka, complete tha preparation of Th Mub of tha application Seven the Hat of executives of higher Thar ara two itema at th head card ta The general policy of tho federal publication, the it Inti the suto governor, secretary of and pon publication months and even tha statement' get used in mailing out plates. Sea 'of th last statement, on reading: reflected In recent years for of pubbands tha end newspaper tho fiscal atate, attorney general, treasurer, governmentIs as beyond of tho that th correct name and the adContribution from th Republicto retain tha ownerperiod for which tho publication of lication. auditor and superintendent of pub- legislation dress where th plates ara to ba an National committee, 6,000. ship of the principal natural re- the notice la required by th statlic I mu ruction. Very truly yountx ta Tha other oua reads: or mailed, plainly written printsources of Ila public ute. Th queMion which arises now GEOGE P. PARKER. Eight Relating to the election of lands, permittingremaining ed." Contribution from th Republican the development between th General, clarke of Attorney tha boards of tha Judiciary. "If you are unabl to send your National committee, to be given to these resources only under lease education and th Niue Congressional and legisla- of publishers la oI M2 certificate of registration or Salt Lake county, and to b reor permit. In order to carry out 'What eonMItutes THE REQUEST. ) a reasonable tive apportionment. ) excertificate of ownership. Include 1 ported by aald county, M.OUO. thla pollry It la necessary to of time.'' W would ap Ten Concerning education. extra with your remittance, and ba Then follows a long list of small and classify all the public length Salt Lako City, Utah. predate receiving tha benefit of Eleven Powera relating to cities, amine aura to give this office lata year's donations which total MOO. In lands with reference to their high- your 1121. In thla 26, matter. opinion January towns and counties. of license This will est use or value. Thla work number. avoid carrying over their totala tha ReYours Very truly, Hon. Georg P. Parker, Twelve Tha lawa concerning classifying all tha publlo lands and delay in checking up and issuing publican state committee did not Utah Slats Press Association. General. Attorney no been that " specorporations, providing you a duplicate certificate. leasing the mineral lands haa carry over the flrat 6.009 mentionCLYDE EPPERSON. Salt Lake City, Utah. cial law can ba passed to benefit assigned to the Geological Purvey. "All transfers of ownership ed above, but only added tha 604 President. Dear Sir: of th any special corporation. Efficient beneficial use be must In this to their list of receipts Tha ques- properly recorded Considerable Interest haa been offlcs befora THE OPINION. Thirteen Relating to revenue lands la the purpose of classifies 1121 plates can b tlon now la: all from manifested by publishers and taxation. tlon. Issued. If th January 31. M2. What Doe It Mean? transfer accomUtah State Press Association, Fourteen Concerning tha public part of th atate aa to tho mean- panies tha application for plates, Water Power. Did the Republican national com4601 Compiled Laws aactlon of debt. ing to City. extent b aura to include tho An Indication of th mute ship n 10,000 for tha last Attention Clyde A. Epperson, of Utah, 1917, In regard to that transfer fee of 1 In yourrequired Fifteen Providing for the atate which use Is now being mada of remit- push and was tha stats committee's Militia. portion of tho section which haa tance." our mineral and water power re- President. 6,000 omitted from th tabulation, to do with traveling expenses of Dear Mr. Eppenon: Beventeen Regarding the water sources under permit or lease may "Cara whleh war registered In or did tha national committee Juat Is which board school members, am I in of your letter rights receipt be gleaned from the following Ma of Utah In 192 do not Inspec- send in 5,009 and th clerk mad January 6th wherein you state set at a maximum of 100 each tion, but tha affidavitrequire Eighteen Forestry and protec- t lattes: of regtatered a mistake in listing tha 9,000 to tion of watersheds .Out of a total of nearly 11,000,-00- 0 your association Is deslroua of hav- per annum. custom In ahould ba filled out be- ths Mat committee. many school ownership It ta the Nineteen Publlo buildings ing our Interpretation of aactlon and horsepower now develbped in 4614 fore a notary. In othar words there ta apparentachool state for Lawa of this districts of more than Compiled tho United Mates, Institutions Utah, 1117, Tou can expedite delivery of ly a clerical error In th RepublicIn to to on members date board of la of appropriate regard publication developed Twenty Regarding Mata lands horsepower license for yourself as wall an ate temsnt whlcu ahould have rtreams. th financial statement required In unto themselves tha maximum ex- aa otheraplates Twenty-tw- o Concerning home- publlo lands or navigabla by seeing to it that tha bean called to their attention long stead exemptions pense allowance In a lump aum above requirements under authorisation of tho federal this section. nra complied ago, and would have baan called without any itemised vouchers with." Twenty-fou- r The Court Says; Amendments government to thalr attention had thera bean Tha section referred to, haa showing how tho expanse was InFrom tha passage of the mineral After Mr. Bowen's talk, Mr. "If your application ta regular, anybody in tho atata capital comAdams made s word of explanation leasing law In 1120 to Jiina 10, bean, at least, partially Interpreted curred. The association which I your plates can b sent out tha pelled to look after the stale- 1121, 117.000,000 barrels of oil haa In tha case of Crockett v Board represent ta deMroua of having am regarding calling Mr. Bowen to up- been 1a re day the before tho committee. There produced from publlo landa of Education of Carbon (County your opinion as to th legality of calved; otherwiseapplication must 'manta, Two More Loophole. per- School District, a Utah case, reth practice of expending these be delayed until application were no other persona who wanted under government lease or Thor ta yet another loophole or auch time aa ta to ha heard and Chairman Holther mit of which about 1,000,000 tons ported In 191 Pacific at page 1M. publlo funds without itemized needed two which should ba checked. to perfect aamo." In waa fiscal th year JuMIce Corfman vouchers. produced declared tha committee meeting writing this opindar th present ayatem thera ta no ended Juna SO, 1121. ion uses thla language: Very truly yours, Journed. mottd two hors team, each team provision for checking the "We think tha statute la manUTAH STATE PRESS ASSN. During a similar period nearly at 100, meat and trad iy expanse accounts tigalnst those 11.000.000 tons of coal haa been datory In its requirement in that Clyde Epperson, President. a horse, on to ths other, and each 'of If tho tha state committee. mined from leased publlo lands, of it plain and piorttive provisions team ta now worth 160 because' eta la committee ewsara It gave waa manifests lta purpose so clearly I which about 1,000,000 torn now ta matched.1 team each wall aum Lafca of a ended money gajt county that tha contention made by the produced In tho fiscal year value and tax value of there ta no officer who haa taken June 0. 1S2S. defendants that they have subM. 1929. 104 January MCh wera aame. and tha juat. Years Buaineaa. jt upon himself lo ac if th eoun-Bstantially compiled with It, must Utah Stato Preae Aaaodatlon. after they had traded tha val- - ty committee admits to receiving Last year the oil and gaa rights tall" City. tb It. Th asm ta true with a V' In a tract of 110 acres of publae Quoting farther from tho opin- Attention: Mr. Clyde E Epperson, A Si wlttao and the candidate. land were disposed of for 420,000, ion, Just lea Corfman says: PraMdant. Of course in th absence of a Dear Mr. Epperson: SSSedMhlSsauvaUi? V l Epical example I ahown In Sen--r in addition to which the governayatem. IBS assessed valuation of I'tali B721, 000.000. tor King's at element. Senator Ur. Redd'a dlecuralon of tho Inment will probably recelva a royal- fixed time by atatuta th publicaAnswering your communication IUn ,warB which Krtimatcd revenue for btemilnm July 1. 1DM living th ltamo- S1I.BM.I91.10. equalities of tho educational ayaty ef 11,000,000 or more on tha oil tion should bo made within a rea- of Jan. 2i, with reference to tb anTnf craUo Shirt?1 committee 6.000. Th Tho general fund overdraft k Increasing. tem may ba aummed about aa foland gu when they ere produced. sonable tima after th year ends" moaning of section 4109 of tha In dmsfnvsMer Democr-- .o committee ad- Mat It will ha observed, therefore, Compiled Laws of Utah, 1917, In that Income value and sale proves lower Tim legislatnrra persist In appropriating nil of tho anticipated Before knowledge ef their mineral price tracts othar that avallabla was mils Is 1,000 from Senator tha clear content i revenue. foregoing opinion secgetting of tha to taxation are that not. for synonymous portion of even greater value have been upon th queMion os to the duty regard King. Thera ta a discrepancy of Total general fond deficits now $149,770. Textbook Law. I' landa of th clerk of th Board of Edu- tion that has to do with traveling or anything alas. 2,01)0 which can probably be exMain deficits aliened during tho year "W board 88.000 to pay certain dlapoeed of ae agricultural achool members of Court expenses Again. Supreme Wrong falls cation to cause to be published in for a nominal tiling fee that plained but which should not havo ta act at a maximum ef val A portion of county officers' salary as required by law and not fully to lot to a which la tha flrat place Ur. Redd call- taken city contiguous administraof coat cira the newspaper having general rare of In budget; IU.0WI allowed coda commission; M0.000 for tion pay 104 each per annum, will say my uabla business block baa no In- to bo explained. ed attention to tho fact that by the Tho gain to the United States culation, Matemant aa provided in Kara Records Lik This? conatltutlon tha leglalatun waa in state land board when supreme court refused to allow atate to use from Interpretation of this section ta that come but it may have a good sale Why on a this section Information Senator King took a sum of adequate 100 aside no way allowed to say what kind certain other money for llwt purpose. ta value ahowa each whleh tha not set for tha supreme would A Reasonable Time. proaent to him by Uia Senatorialngla tract of thla kind f textbooks tha schools of tha Bute pays $10$ to etliirau n Muilcnt at the lT. A. C. particular member In a lump sum court waa wrong again. If you 2,000 Tha only queMion left In vide an appropriation sufficient to committee at Washington and stato shall use. In this connection Mate pays $1M to educate a student at U. of C. of but merely represents a maximum fore a man to build without a al of large area doubt la what would be a reavalue ascertain turned it over, to tha Democratic let us call attention to tha fact that Advises against Junior col lego plan. budget to b paid to him when tha demand for a building ha becomes sonable time for th clerk to th public land In advene of discommittee. The Democratic tha Utah legislature, by law had expenses are legitimately Incurred. a competitor which tends to re- stato Urges classification of property to give more revenue to answer posal. aa a means of Intelligent nd tile th Matemant and comply stats committee ahowa tb receipt created some yean ago tho text- state's needs. I taka it that th proper mtthod duce the sale value of all other of 2,000 with the provisions of th statministration and insurance agalnM Senatorial comfrom tha book commission and that right of making ua of thla fund would near property because It violates Calls attention to ITMMI1 asked Iy Institutions aa bn tiding ute. It will be noted that so but does not show that th b to require of each board mem- tha cardinal rule of supply and mittee, cam gpw than is a but before the leg- budget. far aa thla statement le conAt th end of tha fiscal year MM through Senator King lalatun to change tho personnel of ber. voucher showing that th demand xhlch, if obeyed prevents money permits cerned. It should be complied Offers n pay aa you go policy. nearly 22,000 mineral or that Senator King had any right thla commission. Tat than are with up to th money had bean legitimately ex- tha conrtructlon of a building on to list year ending Isaacs, and license were under Suggests admission tax aa means of raising revenue. It with hta expenditures- - Tha Juna 10. I am of tha opinion many lawyers who declare that the pended whlla engaged In tha work that lot. but that vacant lot has a by tba Geological survey. bond Issue for building program. Urges M.INMMIOO twenty-yeconno Income value at question whleh naturally cornea up and valua In sals work member. aa school board a clerk tha that Certain supervisory therefore, leglalatun can not do Indirectly ' Point out that tills will rail for $150,000 sinking fund and alL But th auprema court haa In tha m.nds of those who ara not ta forbidden to do directly. Tour very truly. should have a reasonable tima nection with tho naval petroleum 120,000 taterrat'. said that whatever property 1a already cognizant of th facta ta Survey on GEORGS P. PARKER, after Juna 0th to bring hia and that thenforp tho legislature Admissions tax should bring atate at least what la brought federal reserves Is dons by tha worth for income and aala. It la 'ta that 2,u00 which 8enator King Bureau of Engineeraccounts up to date and com tha haa ao right to delegate duties to of QeneraL behalf Attorney S4 75,000. worth for taxation, and yet that turned over to th Mat commitof th Navy, and tha textbook commission. The government Department ing, this would rare take ami fund Suggest and Interest of sinking lot haa no Income at all. and may tee the asms (2.000 which tha state similar work In connection with practicability of having textbooks a fund for the go policy. have a high sale value. Th court committee receipts to the senatorial soma Indian eraervatlona la don standardised to a certain extent la leaveCUrs connects Income and sale as on committee ?' figure on Mate's Indebtedness 10.500,000 maximum on on behalf of tha Office of Indian not questioned but the constitu- 1030 valuation In Justice to tho men who are from oU 000,000. Bonded debt now $0,000,000 minus Affairs. Th and th same thing. Joined by th royalties tionality of It la. Mr. Redd ex- $4,455,750 now ofIn $7,000 reconnecting word and," and both handling tha money of a political sinking fund. Net bonded indebtedness $5,204,130. produced on naval petroleum plained that thla provision In the th and for Mr. Colls attention to fair Heine on which I lie state board of examl- - serves and Indian lands Mr. Parsons and Paul, party such d.acreptanclee should not conatltutlon because 0, 1921, amounth had H the power Horsley dam. SSOAOfl, anybody ala ought to know that ba allowed to remain a part of th toaon-MormV- n Vearid" thatthe ' year ended June 9.000.000. Had there been ths two words have a different publlo record. I0" to general destruction of property. $10,000 ndvanc- - ed to over dominant church would bo able to re1 $4,000,004 Remain. anyone having delegated th meaning In taxation. exhibit at Nevada road espnd-booby c,,,rn" lo hllve uh BY It A. HOLLENBECK. have th legislature mak church sponsibility of looking over thee unappropriated 000 publlo The Disagrees With Persona. ,n I9S7, BW advanced by Cedar City and Iron county cillacna part of the regular course of tm acre 194.000 with statements to Mr. Parsona further agrees and having the authority lo add to fund appropriated for B.. A. C. gym; $7,7500 advanced by tonda amount study In the schools. omaller Edltor Utah Statasmaa: supreme court by Insisting on to run down the facta a telephone equal In area to 14toof thathemin-eiC. campus. idivlduality ta almost everything In tha private clt liens to get addition to 1'. this follows: as on call to 10. "anon addition Tha the In Democratic Mate chairwhat says, Statesman, January and property, but, Asked general audit of Mate land hoard. . stairs. M.000,000 published my criticism of A. H. making capital "Income ta th only universal man would have cleared th matCAPRICE OF NATURE rights on about under suppose that man dies in tha midst Flrd general audit In JKO, none since. th val patented ter up and tha written record Parsona Tax Classification articlea of a big schema. A ganlua ta suc- yardstick for tha meaaurd of Cell attention to fan that state land board handles 7,000,000 of acres g of land law have bern Mr. Redd then called attention to In which I denied iha soundness of I ceeded by a common Intellect, or a uca, either for th purpose of In- would be corrected. suto Th specific taxation. dicta or vestment fha fact that duo to the tricks of Mate money. hoard our court's faderal Rights supreme tT(n a gan'us in another Pmr, orand Ak tint of purchase and supidle he given right to make have been retained in II.IIMJD In Adama Express Co vs. O. St I schema, and fata aoma school districts had salarv tha bubble will burst preme court doesn't quits say that, bringing aacompllahmenta schedule. (This to prevent new employes from coming In and acres. Th potential power of Aud which court said: much better educational advanland will Immediately for It makes income tbs proper creating property ta merely an intha property tnsi at old left off who worked to point had starting water-powfor developmenW by the future, and I mad employes years get It ta a cardinal ruto which shrink In talus, and la aoma cases basis for Invertmant and taxation, cident tages that did other school diswould affect government lands! tricts and that th legislature woe advances In salary. - should never ba forgotten that will be a total loss. It waa th in- which If taken as trua by an In- no statement that Ideas should wtimatad at 18.000,000 . horeo- whatever property ta worth for th dividuality and not tho value that vertor. would Immediately break be used aa tha baala of th value unable to do anything to change him. for ha would be the eaay of property," for tha us of a tax this. Ha called attention to the of Income and sale. It ta mada th Income. PThto Is a great ertate worthy of purpose worth for taxation. fact that In Washington county the prey ef all the speculative crooks assessment. But, as a matter of InSelling Frkio Not Gnage. adminiscareful and vestments. Ideas with both tha aturty much Answers Ills Critics. Th tax was disproportionate not In tha country. people pay twice th scliuol t;ix In tha Hlales man of January 17. only to th value that tha people of tha Jordan disTha successful buaineaa world seller and the purchaser 1a of tration, In order that thb Interest to tha selling but served. Mr. Parsons and J. H. Paul, both of all ha people may trict do, but that Washington wh'ch sailing price was dis- does not follow ths supreme court greater Importance. Bur-veTha United State Geological tnoy com back and poke a Util fun at price, Nothing Perfect. oounty schools spent but 48.00 per to value based upon rule. Business man unconsciously, proportionate to aupply Is Let Mr. Paul remember that a attempting me for quertiontng auch disting- taxation, ao tha supreme court follow a trua rul that disagrees Student agalnM 1)0 apent in JorIntellicareful that which on I court statement rule. so, logical facts must b based uished and rightly, dan. This because nature had with tha auprema mada two errors instead of one. administration may b based I supposeauthority, for Sagebrush philosophy gent A selling price ta not a test of would not permit either Mr. Paul placed certain mineral deposits In A .000,000 ahould be act up now, which building program ahould not ord narily have tha value. It depends on who sells and or Mr. Parsons to Invest my money th Jordan dlMricts and the Jordan be financed by Issuing twent 4 per cent aerial bonds. This districts and tho Jordan people mlrht temerity to tackle ouch a cardinal who buys. If a shrewd tnan sails If they Instated In spending It ac12 would about .01)9 160.0u0 for require interest for annually and rule approvingly announced by th to a man lea shrewd, you may bet cording to that fallacious rule of were getting th benefit of tax to fund. ttnn furnished sinking According us. Iha proposed money imld by corporations. greatest court In the world. How- that tha selling price ta more than tha supreme court. As poor aa my H also cited that Grand County admissions tax would easily provide the revenue required for this pur-- o ever. I have never known of that lta value: but if a man of ordinary Judgment may be. It ta not poor received about and probably at the same tint build up a surplus In th build-ons7oooVyearfrom I court, or any member of It. that ability wants to sail, and does sail enough for that, and If Messrs. tha Denver and Klo Grande rail - itn fun1 out of which additional c ruction might ba undertaken on haa aver written a work on politi- to a shrewd man. you may Judge Paul and Parsona ara successful out of eending task annual rm road bacause the Denver end Klo The cal economy, or any essays on th that tha property ta worth more business man, aa 1 believe they of tha bond. If thla tax pro-erMX notice on Grande tracks went arrnas soma 48,000 personal the point in controversy, and tha coort than the selling price. It often hap- are. then unconsciously they art government in 1921. It seems au- - In law or to. without analyrta or otherwise, pens that when a smart man of violating and refuting that t yield lea than that amount now. aiftomobllea commenced Frida., county. Ban Juan county, which anything else that waa head C. Turner, furnishes more live freight end not and capital buya suburban prem court rule Instead ef eon-- : a shining auecaaa. A naw venture of sumo 2no,000 over and above according to M. adopting what aoma political econ-om'of division nevmore dead freight to iha Denver las said and aa I have tnents. nut of whleh a comprehen-v- n of th auto asaeeslng a host of others will buy forming to It and th every day in law la later mad workable by er heard of anybody having run a proparty and Rio Grande than dors Grand from h!m tha same property cut condurt of th business world ta a later amendments 'by patchworlr, need with reasonable speed. Such the county assessor's department. that Inla all the atlll shall on I margin that patchwork goes on forcorner gats Ten county nothing. d up into lots at enormous Inflated refutation of that auprema court and might therefore he will hadaygiven for payment thla sist that thought Ho also called attention to the ever. Which ta better, to patch an aald cardinal ruU ta values. Those values are not real dicta. in ing program most the cxpedlold law that ta fairly workable or Cutler dam. Aa originally placed One For Dr. Paul. values or taxation or anything else, year on these notices. announced wrong tha Cutler dam waa In Cache coun- Th department hs Let me suggest a word to Mr. to patch a naw law that may not' Is it true then, that "whatever except speculation, and later cirnow th Mr. law work good at 117 I prater to keep nave and that payment would to "Consider Hs ty county says OGDEX MILLS. SENIOR pro party I worth for tha purpose cumstance must measure the real Paul. ucatlon In that Mata asd later that according ideas patching th old law. A new oad tax benefit of the revenue de- that la due upon th receipt of tho It ta worth for value of those properties, and not Hollenbeck's Income aala. of plea and came CALLED BY DEATH. to east his studies complete rlved from that tax had It not lie-- n bile professing ta reach people be used aa th basis of tho taxation T" I say it ta not trua. It ta present conditions. NEW YORK Ogden Mills fi- at rhllipp Exter academy and that tha engineers decided a site that are not now reached, will hit value of property." Not True Basis. Collectors will visit the auto wall known that tha Income from I of a a Uttle farther down the river nancier and patron of the arts Harvard. and that lot of fellows that have all they Mr. Paul ahould know do not reply at th But. suppose n man constructs property may ba greatly disproHe only recently began to relax ere who was a better one. This site hapon mad no auch plea. What I aald can bvir already. Thera is a treor value. Tha to ten actual otherwise, period. Its houses, cheap the day portionate died his at In homa Sixty-ninth from the responsibilities of an acEast pened to bo in Box Elder county ncoma and value might not ba hose lota and gets a large Income waa: "Value are measured large- mendous demand for more taxes However, there ara three alterstreet Thursday of pnea- - tive business Ilfs. Ha was an offi- natives end tho result l that Box Elder1 for th automobile owner. disproportionate to th owner him- from rant baaed upon Ihflated ly by Ideas On man develops hi for naw schemes, for higher fai cer In 11a was 72 monla. several taxoliL an source extra of year oounty has corporations and n lla can remit th eaah or ho can self. for two ra aeons: First, ho values that may or may not mak Idas with property and ha will, arlea for new created salaries, for At hia bedside were hia son, Og- - director In many others, hia contriatlon. you with hta accomplish-- ; thla and that; that ahould bo cut present bond: or. If ho ta a real .causa of self Interest ha would nat good. Certainly that Income ta not surprise while L. MIL), undersecretary of th butions to art Included donation ertate out Taxes ahould not bo Increased, another with owner, ha may serve notice Ural)y have an Inflated value of a true basis for taxation. In case manta, TAXATION SYSTEM "te Metropolitan muss uni of that ha wishes th auto tax at-- hta own wealth: and, second, ba- - of great shrinkage, which ta quit 'asms property will do nothing, and i Let a atate or a municipality live treasury, and his daughter, th f Countess 4 of Granard. His other f m rtron initiative, ability apt to happen, the taxes will take ths property ramalna worthies! or within lta means, and It must ao thi C.Vlln tached to hta property tax. Mr. Redd would have tha con- daughter. Mrs. Henry Carnegie live or It will destroy lta futoro ln.dLn te,nt,nl' ,nd and fertility ef resource h might I the property. In ear the value does nearly ao. Mr. Paul knows that Turner declared Friday that ; stitution ao changed that tha en- Phipps, is In Ialin Heach attend collection will uea every effort to b able to prolong a large Income not later ahr'nk, th tax waa Mill Ideas will ereato property or de- and th prosperity of lta people. g nothcrsaUon t. tire Mata would benefit to a th illness of her uwji daughas Hs had a keen Interest In fin . department That ia baaed a who a tax because Uplifting propagandists ara mors upon stroy from catch automobile tax dodgers disproportionate amall'unjurt, hter degree from these natural horaee and Crl da Gulrre of the use license ololea obtained 111 otto rapital: and Indeed, that 1a usually actual praaent values, and not ing to do with tha assessor until of a detriment than a benefit. after It happens and eould not bo They would ignorantly destroy tho futura speculation. surfs, end tha development of Korn In Baers mento, Calif., Mr. Mills stable last year won tha'er state, but use thalr machines th ease where a man makes hta tha natural resources, rather than Mills received hia elementary ed- - Grand Frix at Longcliamp, Francq, own fortune. Personality and to- - Two farasr each with aa ill- - coualdarad before. Aa Mas IS country if they had thalr way. tull Urns la this state. : aa par-son- - cor-mon- ey ' Hasjaa-ment- . . t 1 constl-tutlon- I pr .. coun-Bsaess- ed ut al : ar " pay-as-y- TAX ANALYSIS . ' A Reply to Critics. ' od-wl- ll ks al stock-raisin- m'"1 er $3,000,000 Building Plan (Dems Budgetary Message) County Mailing Auto Tax Notices inf-iri- a st al K no-tl(- 99 ould . th! rer-iln- re-(e- r. n |