Show ON A washington 21 after the prose poso cution cation lad bad rested lifted thou their case ciuti guiteau lui was to in tile tho opening of the defence retaining I 1 tinning his seat be it liu bigan began your honor I 1 was vas not abaro that I 1 ws was expected to this morning scoville bc here leaned over find whispered to him when guiteau retorted bliar ply anti with i in 1 I wont stand up ill im lot afraid to however but I 1 havo 01 anlyn ay a moment to L aud I 1 will vil 1 loop my beat T do not caro caio tu to say s ly moro moio illan wai last mou lily a my ItI Iress to the public I 1 aresu me tho ilia jary amy till saw it I 1 have but speech to diaho I 1 as M my Y own on counsel and nir my idea is id to I 1 malo 11 a he corrections collections its vo go along just fig aa we vo have done tile tho past three or tour four dyb days I 1 dont don t mean inpan nuy any dis courtesy courtoy to any oro ore I 1 only ant to gi if any one I 1 mo hil him a twenty dollars nail and I 1 dont I 1 will deny it on tho the spot my idol idea la is to talo take things they nio are and not let them got get cold and tin I 1 huffor arom misrepresentations of courso 1 go on tho the stand tit at the proper time and ba examined und nad cross 01 ain ined my idea how bovi oci over is is to meet a misstatement bholi it is 13 hot before it is is digested I 1 think the true way is to interpret ray illy state ments us as tho the caso case proceeds dg I 1 haie ha 0 no c set et speech to wake nuke but I 1 am much obliged to your om honor anil and to council for foi tho the courtey of this thia invitation guitian Guite aus s manner seeing to have nn lill a marked cli chaise ainge sinco sinco tho the early dis days of tile tho trial ti al find and during duing tho the delivery of his short b speech eoal this was particularly noticeable tit at tho the conclusion ile ho settled hack back in in his chair with an air air ot of oah aubdon and rusted his big head upon his hind hand weini ly while a careworn care caro worn expression up ap feared on oil his faco face scoville Sc then addressed the jury at considerable length the only question for tho the jury to consider consul cr was atai vie prisoner killed tho president ric aident and whether at the abu timo time lie was M in in such condition mentally as to render him responsible for tho the action the speaker ikei with no attempt at oraton cal presented in in a plain matter of fact manater uio the points which he p to make and upon which the defence would rely icly without concluding lus his opening address see villo requested request cd tho the court to allow him to finish to morrow this was granted gi anted adjourned now york 19 the tribunes washington special says a police of fleer says guiteau was terribly ten ably alarm od to day when shot at ho jumped about lih lile a conloy what is 13 tho the matter iio cued cried out ont I oh who shot thit it pi pistol yo you u know edin did fire at the iho man ns as he be rode roda oft off I 1 could not make guiteau belies 6 the officer fired he thought both shots wore were fired tit him somebody is 13 shooting at wo me ho be screamed he did not know that ho he was hit then you toll and williams ta unit t I 1 want thim them to put on more moie force foice washington 22 guiteau was ft as bi ought brought into tho the courtroom shortly after 10 and scoville re burned his argument ile ho called the attention of the jury to tho the plea pica set up lip by the defense ot of insanity and discussed rt at great length tho the growth opinion upon the subject of insanity ins anity anil and its treat mont daout by the courts chuita whon when set bet up as defense in in criminal easel casas ill he cited numerous in onos ones ile ho claimed tho the plea of insanity having baying hron been hr on set bet up tip by burden of proof rests with tho the prosecution there was waa just as much ground to indicate insanity E uvon von president garfield garfi old said why did this man do it ile ho must b bo 0 insane i 11 dinino must havo believed guilt guinean an insano insane col Cork lidl bore arose anil and with emphasis said if you ou will ollow in mo 0 mi ir scoville villy ille tho the president never said ho he thought he hb was insane ho he thought hm him sano bano all the tha timo time maine blaino never thought hini him insane lie ho said andar oath ho he thought hira him sailo scoville St oville eipl explained ho spoke from information derive I 1 fiam newspapers and a ua would not tako take issue on tho the bateni nt he thea toute up ill tho the history of ch tha a gaithan ianuly who wore of lin huguenot guenot extrac extraction ti on and aad who had retained tain ot I 1 to the present day ns as a marked lop the sturdy all ad lerenia to rol gi jus convictions which conseil tho tha expatriation of tho lie ile assorted asserted inaam insanity ity was wa s hereditary in the family at one point ichi in his argument ville in in detailing the tho moro moio on lighon pd ell of tho higano in m vogue at the asylums said 1 Ir I rv inird ard choso 1 in in chairo of tile tho asyl unis with alt it little muio reabon than I 1 do tho this sally hally soothed to G Guit ciui minions ely and it broad biond smile canic came ON OMI or kisi his find tw two I 1 or three thieo turn times a as if i his mind inin I 1 reverted to it hawillo hai illo alluded to the poeju dico which undoubtedly existed exi against tho the plea of inanity genera ly aid 11 ly i in 11 tile caso case of f ti the prisoner iio ho slid paid tho the n c vs papers ind a n at C d that ghitea Gnit rauh us was vas un 1 ly tho the of oc insanity and till I 1 mich bi to bo the gonegal theory ot of tho the public C laitman turned tamed un ia in his hib chair and with hith nerv articulation said 11 1 1 never feign I 1 I 1 act myself sino sano or ins insane ane 11 with out noticing the thu interruption scoville Sc alluded to the arrott of a man at the timo time of president lilies hayes a sont sent to tho the asylum this man ni in as ito ha said had its as careful ly mado made his hia arrango ute L is to kill president hayes as did guitrau to hill president garfield ind and but for his hii arrest might liao have succeeded and went amt on to give tho the story of Uni tellus lito life in m detail guiteau Gui tonit appeared satisfied till scoville plainly od that th it tho the lack of capacity on gui gin boans part pait had reduced id his practice to the collection of bad add debts gui gin tean winced find and broke out with I 1 brought a groat glint many suits and gonei orally ill gave ga 0 them all the they v v anted on the other sido 11 after a moment of quasi explanation to the tl 0 prisoner boner scoville was about proceeding vicca vho guinean ap paTently appeared led cd waved lua ids hand pleasantly to scoville and said 1100 go on mr ullo nille that a an interesting story find and is 13 correct in detail continuing scoville said in in effect Guit amteau mado made a good living and supported his family all this timo time and paid p iid his debts broke in with 1 I have hava first class i references as well atell ag a my personal appearance acance and so I 1 got business besides that I 1 had no BO bad habits of any lind kind to illus illustrate rate Gmt Guit caus freaks as nn an indica indication tiou of insanity scoville i related elated his big rambling attempt at a speech on a certain oc casion casion when he bo hid hall boon been assigned 1 I agne a in coutt cou t as counsel for a p prisoner prisoner boner on trial guiteau again in m nn an excited mannor manner sail said absolutely false I 1 never tried a caso case with charlie rood reed in in my life I 1 dont want nant to interfere with nh your our theory but your our fuels facts are aie false I 1 arant the jury to understand und cistand my pec peculiars ties till all highl there are aio a good many people who will swear I 1 nuit am insane insane after scoville bc oville conti continued aued up on tho the same line of fro fie using the elpio linen men tal cal incompetency gaineau fro fretted ted 1 at t I 1 L the slightest imputation of lack 0 of f brain biam power and his intense intonte egotism showed itself in in his fro frequent quent interruptions rup tiona at the tha ono one time lie he e claim cd taking exceptions to tho the bbate mont of scoville ai not N ot true find and cint bo be bbown I 1 always toll tell the troth and again ho be broko broke in in I 1 had bad brains enough but nry my mind waa vas devoted to theology chata why iran behind there bi no money in in the theology bui moss iness im out now scoville continuing to speak of his impecunious condition at ak that timo time as shown by his clothes cloth cs ft hen guiteau interrupt ld ed with a show of impatience patiences im 1 I was always well dressed dont put that in m scoville related an incident in in lire winch which his big ft lends friends thought at the time indicated ins insani am ty guitrau Guito au av with much war ilith said baid 1 Ivol I vo hoard icard that story before andeits absolutely talai false dont toll tel any such stuff as that again scoville then thea related Guite auls yari van od ell experience ospin enco during the tha moody and sankey bankey re lev iyola and his efforts etna and failures on religious subjects find and lack 1 ick of appreciation shown by his big an all deonce guiteau supplied tho the explanation Guito juite auts aus belief that ho he was waa eor solving V tho the lord and that aba t it was vas the lords business to pay p ay iy tho the debts in in cidred in in his service was mention mentions nl it oil ed by scoville when guiteau laugh angly supplied BUpp lioA another illustration saying baying I 1 doad dead leaded finin tola lo 10 to chicago on the tha impi ossion 1 my appe tho conductors conduct ois aranca mado made with got put off twice though scoville Sc continued his hia di of Guito ans religious experiences experienc a and was frequently interrupted by the prisoner with 1 11 I left a C law busi business nebs to do that work and you 80 boy bov I 1 in made ado out with it ill and again the same luna kind of bus ness apostle paul was engaged in 11 lie 0 got his s pay find nn 11 I 1 expect to lot efa ilmo bogotin 0 out of that bool book I 1 wrote roto A moment abor lift r with a show allow ot of ultimo itam and mining ing ili tin voice i ile ha exclaimed 1 I 1 used to go around the ts calling try ny lectures people thought I 1 anva ii it a book rt ant ent and I 1 wn nn happier lt pier v inn 1 I was bloing doing that work than ever bo fol flip 1 I 1 ans a worling welkins for tile lord not for or money Scovil lil illon hon gillad 1 rj ed to Guit eans to ill tho of anti said it was lna ilia c ti ion in i eliat that lio lie would 11 ille to any woman so long ns as blo I 1 listen to him ThIl ts B not t truo shouted shou Uil Gu guinean itean 1 I put a i no tico on my illy Ruto autobiography biography that imy lady judy will why wn wanted atod to cori wit with mo me and who would mend bend esoila cpr er refer inus if sho hns till nil right would lo ito well and to this not co I 1 got rv from a lad lady worth woith that wagne MISH t bid bail MT it it scoville bc oville continued it is la true ila is lie ho pays B ays that tile the notice not co brought a I 1 10 ponso III v aich shows there thedois ii one wo MO 0 min man in in thu the united states tint that ably lib h has is lost lod lo d her ronson niso alao this remark elicited a good deal of latich ter but not from the tha prisoner who aho ang angrily y e me aimed 1 I cioto brot 0 her hi r two loiter letter a n d she wrote ine 1110 two you sun still promised pio isail tile tho rest I 1 ibao have boon been looking lookin in for a response hi ies to my illy list last letter for came t areu week i and I 1 am carthin you have board ol 01 it I 1 toll tell oil onro so 1 pub ili liely lid lio be continued raising his ani v 01 oice c 0 I 1 boti ou anu calit t fool tile rao I 1 am going cc to 0 f fol OI 01 1 low any 11 her r laughter Luu liler scoville bc oTille the iho loiters letters arota J not NO you dibut didn t send illon horn yon hud had lind about it not tho the first lie you have told eard tile the p prisoner riia emphasizing his hia word i with ditl blows upon the table 1 I know knew yon had been laid you told mo me you sent chobo lette letters and and now you say you havo bava not court sternly br quiet D i strict attorney servillo Se Sc knows that if there were wera any such lotters letters they nevor never can roach reach the jury anil and this attempt to got into public colloquy with thia th man is reprehensible aa this man play hla his part whon tho the time comes 1 11 1 I 1 urn atil not playing a part cried the prisoner bonor and gostien lating wildly 1 I know knew scoville was lying scoville I 1 understand this evi dence is coming that thai it is perfectly competent As a general thin thing testimony obtained from lying is sot 61 competent retorted the prisoner Sc ovilla 1 11 I will not reply to corkhill nt at present pr csont tor for lis ilia when time comes for argument ho he will get his answer the significant tono lono in which w aich this was said ought brought bi down a storm of applan sa from tho the spectators 1 I hall had considered consider cd continued scoville this evide aco was competent compo tont TI tle tie e prisoner you will not have any 11 n Y 11 success 11 ec 0 from tho the lord by lying you lie you lie ivo found yoi out ot JOA when a mail lies to mo me once I 1 nov never r believe him acra again iii you have lied to mo me once and flints aln ts played out the prisoner in in making the tha speech 5 seemed 1 hat to 0 be 0 convulsed with passion and a 11 a it was i in it vain hill hii brother and it d sister attempted to quiet him scoville all I 1 want in ili this case Is id unit that the lie truth shall prevail und and isyou if you believe I 1 produce it as evidence fur for theatrical airee without alic lie el rnest conviction of fis belli being juat list and proper to he be lone done I 1 want you not only to t repent it but bul charge charee it liguin at me with tenfold effect n act 1 in 1 your fl aal verdict ct 11 applause tito tho prisoner prison erMy imy lagal namo naino is la Cl carles Clim rles lea guiteau Gull Qui rau 11 scoville then propos proposed pd to read a bundle of lotters letters written by tho the oner dating d aln 1 ack to 1853 1833 na as show ing ln the bunt built of 1119 hl hand the district attorney objected tp to their ai not connected with the crime the prison erWe we v will III allow they urn tire authentic the judge admitted the tha letteri must most of them being addressed tu lo mrs imra scoville and sumo to himself those or of tile earliest date 1858 show allow nothing peculiar but gradually they drift into a turn qU kig 19 texts of scripture and appealing to ills sister to turn to god this feat ur bof thein W f marked lifter after lie has I 1 gone to the lib onelda community the he bril letter from froin which Is ii dated febi 15 1661 1861 in he h lays laya down and supports tup porta the doctrine ot of com coin Ill unity when this thin letter was lead tho the prisoner said 1 I forgot that th 1 1 iter it aia 13 a very good 1 lion of the influence fluency In under which I 1 lived for eight years I 1 not awill 8 it vias mils in e existence I 1 lence tito tho ilat letter front doneld a wai wa flat dated ed october 6 and stated staled hill views had changed that lie ho desired to leave I 1 lie coin lit u n I 1 ty and go to 0 o vv york 0 it o quality for I 1 a li illon in somo bank lind asil obling ilni be beeville oville to send genii idol 1 50 30 prisoner 1 I was rul rel C 0 y e 1 ax froin my illy insanity I 1 wm iett IVIL my illy pica P es open III it then from 11 those people I 1 hall had beef ix cai a alx I 1 I 1 Arti subject it their 11 o lia explain tid othet bof tile prig one onera als letters had been burned up uit in ills his office in the |