Show I 1 independent journalism the herald refuses to discuss the question with hampden who gets aftel the independent it herald men with a sharp stick and uses the independent men up EDS Tn HiTOE on tile lath ielli I 1 I 1 wrote a lottor to the llie salt lake borau iu in criticism of 0 their course as independent and pointing I 1 conceio Q t be their dut duty T if they mi wished thed to malio make good th their cir claim to lo that desirae 10 tite they bola my communication until tho ilia dinst anat when they published it tg thelber eLber with a lengthy editorial com libent thereon crat journalism ta that abat clitoris cli clit tori orial i it at isue ill lit mot lilo anti WAS really no answer tt at all al to roy my letter on oa tho the amli int I 1 vir wrote a fe Io conil ond communication to till the herald in ia I 1 call eallie al its iti cili editors tors batel to antler dicu azon anti and otis I 1 harka handed oil to theal alis h kame lay day they informed me that it if I 1 wont would call cal tho the next evening they would woula lot let io ilia know whether they coald publish it I 1 called choloa on tho the evening or of tho the balk is ich when they bogged begged further time aal and appointed appoint ool this thia evening the 27 th tor for an answer their answer is that they cannot publish puLli sli it as they have hato doelbor time nor seico to discuss tho the questions eions involved with chii explanation for my rca ions would it bo be ashing too loo much ile editors Editor sto to request 30 01 ol t publish it land and this note in your you r columns colu uina ivyon it yon bill ill do so BO I 1 shall bo be under lasting obligations ligat ions As aia tho the letter to to the herald explains plains cj itself your readers will bo be able to draw araw ons ona us as to the refusal to paU ish without anything further farther from ilasa P dev r SALT like LAKE cirri rell 27 1874 HERALD you yon heil in the hernia herald of the my loiter letter of t the iol and an editor editorial ital headed Journal journalism isra conini commenting ent on tint production you would woula havo bavo been justified in relt re fasing ming 6 til publish it because it takes arotin 14 that hint could cisily lead ton to a lengthy di cassion entirely foreign to tho the a of 30 ar paper which ift ia non etc but bat tho the other jou nals dais moro than a neu paper it has as ai it abbuhl have nie virus ins on tho the leading topics of tile the lay day part cul karly 7 on those of local iDler cst t As a 0 pr of caf of I 1 ai hii I 1 I 1 quote quota your own words wo propose to aunt continue dinue battling ter lor tho the b best st of ilia people cattle 11 for tho the I 1 n ight anil nil claim to 17 bi the judges for 0 u nhat hot hat right i ii anil uil u kahnt hat those interests nr ar ag in you say a a k ins tico lico and right fertall lor for all tall irrespective of pa paty ty politics or creed this is goob nonh but you ton lime no er up to it no at ar anti tile falth fal pors mini 0 it t ciuch a course bould lift alio I baboo th character jf a moro new paper and flakk biao c it tile chat cha upion of 4 c LO th causo cause of hamin liberty ion of evoy kind nor nn your re serL ion to bo be you arsel judges of eliat is right etc aar that liitt let your platform as above billed is to tio broad aa t admit of an aca c cepl z arini this t tl the public public it was tho the striking sri Ling con content trait between betge ell your former claims to bo be independent anil your con stout stant courso course in the opposite op direction induced mo to birite nto to you on tile the a lath thero waa nothing in my letter th at dally Dk lly lead to any odiseus 7 blo hion ouaida tho the hue of your duty V whether hether you yoa giago it by your former claims or by tile above quOta quotations tills from your ia of the filst jit bat YOU yon nw fiew off at a tangent on a silo issue in aich isaich you yon may br be but chich I 1 certainly bm am not nor do I 1 think the public tro ora interested who cares whether you tie do or tie do not pitch into inte any ol of tho the clergymen whose names you drag into your article click cibit including the mormon president ident I 1 ami am suri furj I 1 tie ilo not nor ncr cati caa it bo fairly inferred from my letter that I 1 nn thing of the lind I 1 atae l in my lay letter that it laoj been luray manifest niini fes that at t cvar r pont 1 began legal or bothem othen tse your en led la in that that I 1 had haa no reference nha tover to church authority chii confined to its legitimate ci naj tho the whole tenor of my I 1 letter a I 1 ter will mill tallow that I 1 condemned it only ashon it to cont control A civil auy any chaich that does docs chilt becomes by that act a political institution and as aa such subject to censure and atack from the public I 1 asked you why you dil not carry year independence into all that concerned you as newspaper men whether it affected the iho president of the united I 1 astle the governor or of utah its ex governor Brig brisbain bain young its delegate 0 lo 10 O congre its or any other min now gentlemen I 1 ak a k you candidly by aliat rul of f you Cock stroe thal into a wili wib wi li b to ime ur brig g bam young attacked tacked tt as tho head of a religious boby 1 W by you creot I 1 scarecrow gailli away at your own creati creation cati and nd imagine you are arc an the tha iiama or of brinham young was mentioned montio nod incidentally with many others to i your duty as lode inde j an ul d reference to it hlavas bibla Is there nothing lothing in his bis cour cauree 0 a as gov orner and eident of indian air lira i that calla fur i he fie criticism or ol to lan jour journal joi imil nil list lat the hi aisi lory ory 0 ot I 1 utah farm 1850 to 1858 answer it tan can jo do BO act uluth better belter than I 1 on can pit hut you affat to thick him bill beyond crit icieg icham because baic iu io be DO no longer holds boldi a ai ili you hive have become tery sell eidde it it at once this dew princia in 10 as 88 purt purl of your journ erod cot quito quite deceu ly lor for I 1 have tided filled to ice fco its ita application in bour columns coli imoe the schuyler colfax no DO longer holds a political 01 ol ft fial yet you low 1040 no 00 with or vi hoit cause ause to la aci revile I 1 to him in the coal coarsest sest mariner niao ncr ll it barms to malo a vs differ difference enco to jou ou ox is goaded but it would not be be il if you were ai i you claim to lo be journ liu r JOU so touch for tho the dacre iou ioa f sion om tile lle at isiac which your avo dvo led me into but nuit to the iho on which I 1 fiatt wrote you bakal shiell you yoa totally evaded in your reply thero there were three prominent points in my former letter may bo be br thus farat arst that tho the iral in ter fire vi nith ith and nd controls tile lle civil potter in utah second I 1 hat the people are becoming eircil of if this thia control coot rol 1113 their to throw it off at the lato ate municipal elec elepticia ticia th rj that it is ia j our duty seeing you profess to la 10 l a I 1 indea independent ideran journalist to conour and to some direct go promote te or of liberty and inde alic prosing toa ing spirit rion pon decco dence among tho the cailan peck people le which failed t to borm duty duly 3 iou on brave so fur far pei thu tender sig ny 7 our claim ta U ent col journals im a tham thain all these important lucati oni you dodged completely tod kind went off into a chaps ody on oa others foreign thereto I 1 people do 00 not of thought poss cli sas that no osis siry to ft a prof or of tiny given but con tiff off to others having but little if ciny 10 lation thereto I 1 am orr T to fin 1 you ere or gas so for it ii il to any annoy iniz in this ikie case I 1 beg to newspaper will allow too mo to recall your wonder you and 10 log they ORR ia renal ramble 10 I 1 would stag HIR gest gei t us IL 4 an aid to memory that boil oil im retail tho the first and met hately tily third propositions ni as above stated it t will put you suit to ID the ti point bohuta TO TIIE THE it would woula teem seem unnecessary for we ui offer aily talling ling thing in proof ot of three tarco tho the first fint and aad second are ri pr avite evident ona nicias to any unbind un biad man loan who bon ha leco been long elough io utah to look below the of society and ana the tahiti can frequently bo be kinstad it d by reading one ona number dumber of the sterald at any titue time by reading a few number bat to place them beyond the iho noss fines ability of or I 1 will rill produce a little evidence i briefly be 69 I 1 an am in proof prof of it my loy fircht apropo it on I 1 will otate that on oil san esy evening jut t lafora la fora the iho I 1 li do lociy city election tile the cali teichi 0 cn rat vi hose duties in the chuch ora ard tj ta church members at their hort homcha ici pray iry with anil and exhort them admi olAer to lo tile acl eto went from hou hodio 0 to house housa in their respective district an ami 11 kit with each cadi family a number ol of tab erl aclo tickets lickett lic keti astric strictly allu exhorting like iho people to vote vota that tic ticket and no other to bhoj bow it worked I 1 offer this one bouc old lady ol of my acquaintance after ticket she had voting tolido was asked what vote voted d she replied 11 ll lii I 1 11 I 1 don dont t know it was the iho ticket alic teachers ga caloric lORIC inc I 1 suppose it was tile right ole o le it if more proof of int intal crenco wit wiil our oar civil affairs be estry any amount cla cia be furnished and some ot of it of ortt a grave character at that CUT AND DRIED the second proposition tan can also b bi sustainer inel by the c 11 f toor oar late municipal I 1 akki cont contat con tbt bt when lite mass meet log was waa convened in the iho tabernacle mayor wells acted as temporary chairman A respectable table mornion nion critien amov moved col that the lion HOD W 11 hooper bo be chairman of the meeting tho the motion was duty duly seconded but it dil not suit the plant plans of our wio daniel for reasons that will mill hereafter appear tic so ho be did not put the motion to the meeting A j motion WM alu made that judge smith preside and as bon to 10 its as M wai put to this the meeting anil carried at ii a later stage etarl of tha when nominate ong ona victo it ID order strick ano IL cr worthy mormon tooled that thai a com cittee on be e chosen h Os en ty by uio ile and this motion alo alio althou although g li duly f was never av er put to lo the meeting but alean when it t was moved and seconded thit that the conj cammi toabe toi be by the iho chmir it wits rushed through without it daliy tho the ahn chairman irman appointed the committee from froni aliat already prepared which iio he had in his pooLo it wis now 1 iliin I tin to bt why the muton to hare mr hooper preside pre pryl side do wal wai not noi rat to I 1 ile kao ho he did not have hare the prepare I 1 lift I 1 an ani I 1 to lo liao have all illo nol oOl the west ing D to the bouli have tile tho enaire gitro for the in mai no a el choca loCra would not nol have such reliable str tano of lite church as ai tin the pro pre deatina A committee had te licin n iraq ru atio I 1 to nit fil lovaca why the tha ludepen leat citizens re rc elating the bine baie iric trickery kery that lial ha I 1 been played upon thorn them tay by the church lazi lede lers rii and feeling leanly their native at being robbed of their rights right as american cit cal zens put a ticket ut alt the r own onn in the fild anil and rk though they hill but a short time t work chry cist such buch a vote as sent alarm to the bear is odthe beca crati who had trampled rj mild ulon u on their heir rights proof the tra veiling bis bibo bolk officiating at t the jane lenoral riall of bah 01 op proctor a lew jew days after lite cle tin said although the death of bishop proctor is a great loss lofs to the ch church 11 a much greater calzi mity befell us last monday election day if icilio tile foregoing be not sufficient proof that the people laret are getting tired of this thia priestly control yoa xoa can learn it every day by talking with them A dumn DOO AT TBS on tho the thira I 1 mast 1 say sa clial it not dot 1 equirk dequire any fg ar gumont ament to corideo coni con inco iDeo journal journalists ests that it is 13 their duty to enciu encourage arx e promote kina and to some ex cx tobit direct such duch an Ti amona tile tho agai against nuit their oppressors I 1 hope holle you yon sill bill do 10 ao 90 in ia tile alo future sly that aou liao hano not dono clono so BO in the rust prist I 1 will prove you bad a rc reporter porter at tho tober nacle miss mass meeting above aboto referred to v be I 1 have did dia you publish it as it occurred no gentlemen ou on did not you published a cooked coolid report excluding everything that would intimate a aay 1 0 all among 1310 people a and at then placed lit tho the licud head of your columns tho the Tabei tabernacle nacle ticket and op P to tho ilia list even after uio ilia lo people cople hod had placed their ticket in the field yo you U worked against them and advised your readers to vote veto tho the tabernacle imposition anil and further when tho ilia church organ opened its ita thunders on tho the independent among i your our brot brethren hrca n ho he d dared ared to run for botrico in opposition to tho abo church ticket colling calling them tag rag and Bob bobtail tair although in their niall number in nere ore some ot of our oldest and bt citizens citi zenn what did dia you do 10 la dilyou did you battle batilo for moriho the best interests of the people and for tho the right then did you thon then seek equal ims ticia and right for till all no gentlemen youdia nothing of tho the scar bor you allowed some of bour best fellow citizen cit izet 5 tha tic and co religionists to be rubbed robbed of their ir rights by a church clique anil and dhami tully fully abused by a finia church h joural 0 kurnal and you said not a stogie bingle u word ord i in n their defence Is sample of 0 your independent journalism journal mm tito P e ople have need to pray may iho t tho it 0 lord preserve us from our friends so far its my signing tho the memorial lor for le i for utah is con and bernd inid I 1 will simply SAV bay that I 1 did dia bo freely willingly gladly I 1 havo have behic tt me ioos copy of that t document and by tho the most careful r reading ending I 1 fall fail to fled find an untruth in it as a memorial it if you think it false why do 3 ou on not publish it and point out its ita errors if congress grant our request the lie priesthood of bath who bovo bavo been anti are an impediment to the pro giess gless of lit tin the Tom territory tory will ill bo be confined to til the their r proper duties and curt curtailed added some in their influence tor for evil anil ud the tha pomplo the people in cot con honi from the priests vi ill lie bo free to exercise erciso ei their ho ir rights as elt citizens zend of a free Ito public without priestly di dit maya may god haten baten ha ten aliat day ila in utah and Itil akia elory ciar its accomplishment amen trully youre bours S SAIT ALT LAKE daxe cm cirr reb 21 24 1873 |