Show I PORTO RICANS STILL ALIENS I SAYS JUDGE NEW YORK Oct S. S A A decision was wa 1 handed down in ln the United States court b by Judge Lacombe today in which he holds that thai a citizen of Porto Rico I Is not nota a citizen of the tho United States and as such entitled to land without Interference I ence nce from tram th the Immigration laws but Is I Ithe the Insular decision notwithstanding an alien within the meaning of the law The matter came before Judge Lacombe Lacombe La La- combe on the application for tor fora a u. writ of habeas corpus sW sworn s rn out on behalf of oC Isabella Gonzales a native Porto Rican Rican l woman who arrived In New Ne'- York August August August Au Au- gust last She was as detained b by the immigration authorities on nry the tle ground that being an unmarried woman woman hor her condition was such that that she she was an undesirable undesirable un un- un- un desirable ble alien She was sas ordered de deported do- do ported portell but a well-to-do well aunt and uncle living on Staten Island secured attorneys attorneys to get her release through habeas corpus The rhe only question for tor discussion reads the opinion is whether petitioner petition petition- er el Is an alien The fourteenth amendment amendment amend amend- ment moot ot the Constitution of the U United States provides that all aU persons persona horn hOln or 01 naturalized In the United States State and subject to the jurisdiction n thereof are arc citizens of ot the tho United States The pe- pe waa b by birth an alien allen and une unless un un- less e s she has since In some appropriate way vay been lisen een naturalized she Is still an alien There is no suggestion that she sheI was J ever er naturalized under the general I l laws ws re regulating the admission of ot alien citizens s. s The treat treaty of Paris unlike i earll earlier r treaties which dealt with Louisiana Loui- Loui I slana siana Florida California and Alaska dl did no not undertake to make native born I citizens citizen of ot Porto Rico JUco citizens of the I I United States It expressly provides pro I that the civil rights and political status of ot the native Inhabitants of the TerI TotI Ter- Ter I coming coming- to the United States should be determined by Congress |