Show 1 A GRIFFIN REPLIES TO DAILY NEWS EDITORIAL ON FREIGHT RATE ADVANCES aroln chicago Il leago dally daily evs mr griff griffn n replies I 1 desire to call attention to tin n edito rial printed in th dally daily newa news may 21 hooded hack back alre oil the shipper shippers in which oil make the follow following inn itata ineneo first that ii in representation of the enote to not candid that what I 1 did 11 hav to may wan a based upon the action of the lite shipp Pra conference e and arid thrill th lill bat that I 1 had nu no rahl to dwite bg its a busi business mai inai having Ini erwin in common with the he still ehl fore porm the circulation fur for utes of a tat ement relating to f fn r ight tit rates was ae as for no I 1 wae was coner nl confined to fellow follow of he fie hallway o 0 built dieso lieso as oblation s oc lation anil and no reference wall wat made t to the shippers c I 1 pem nally attended thi this conference con frence ant an I 1 have no criticism to ninke on adiv thing hat that am done there and nd wae was made or u intended b bi inglut inc I 1 tit what I 1 cepi was in lit nn nit ir tr fent pent out by th illinois association dated may 7 and as u member of that I 1 u nilly wrote ft a lestr tu to ench each of 0 ith ii intern daled lil ci may lay 17 in this I 1 referred reft to the and unfair Bt alLin tits ro rot talked in the circular of may alay 7 mentioned above lind and in ili doing 11 so I 1 nag ag candll I 1 sald that tits hit railroad railroads are rapidly their net earning earnings waa was not true trite und and ha to the corr etrest of my ernt nt I 1 beg to reft refer r to tho the following I 1 ahe lie Intro introvice vite c manere co con n mission reports show that during the month ot it wirch elf ell ven hyatt ms ins depre otery north and on a line drawn through Chic livo bud and st louls show an art in earnings for the month of march of nearly compared with till march 1909 whilo hilo the bet e for the saino to loida ids in lit tho hu ahod alow ito a dec of and he the inter later state co minert figures for the he ten tan mon mont thi liv july to alarca it 11 in tit as n compared ich wilh 1901 how show nn tin Inci caso in lit gloss of over white while the tut nt earnings of these anie sanie systems in the same period of compi compall tirl hon ion how show a falling oft off of over 3 and anti no little of the tile increase ln In crean creasm in hu its I 1 iven ven gone into elleck during march the must pro ilde omo some means to a revenue ruvon iio that Is 1 already alre nily on oil nn nil of business and there Is g no wa for to provide lile incept by ralo rates anti surel thero there ili rt tion for tho need of it ita in the third on oil the see ond inie of title hi Illi noli ae po ellon circular of mav 7 0 it la is d that 7 99 iio lie cin was as carnol on oil lie the dividend paying stock 1 no allo Hl lowance iunce for the it pat pail cent of stock on which no were paid vald I 1 might w m hh ith equal eav anake tho the statement eta chrt there wak was nu no biffi dividend idena paid on oil the non divi bend pa ing block stock for a clearer den the average earning earnings abdull be bused based upon the entire stock and not upon the bt paying portion of it un less a there Is 1 some why the 2 BOO the 14 per cint should not leave reLt received Ived any ill ditl I 1 dende at ell all in the final paragraph ut the edito ahil it ie Is elated stated that I 1 should not be allowed to pose a as a business man having no interest Inter cut in with tit the shippers Inasi nuch aft my con cei it shipped an fill average of ton tons of finished product during and and we were obliged to recelle mere then tons on of iron to furnish this plus enort quantities of ikc coal und and other supplies I 1 can kaffl claim to have ts chipped hipped fit n and out tons ton it n ear and as its there arc tire no railroad railroads who can afford to haul thie this mit material erial or any part of it without impink a revenue bioni join it nn an increase of 10 vents a ton on on my hauling charmi bould amount to and here there foret for 1 hav in corn nion mon with it it other shippers the tone tons of finished product shipped spilled in lit the of 10 1 hopi W r pi most ly lalor or with the Vicc exception eption of 0 the coet cost of or th tit ore und and roni coal in the mines all the balance was tria analo le up tip of mag vari i nit and profit on tho the different conditions of the raw rn nitter lal until it ana iia nn fin lisha product mv illinois pilots product d CO 0 per cent of this amount or i 1 ami r I 1 lor or three years our chicago pl ints hue not run diore than hilf capacity therefore there m vaa as 1000 1 a year less in of a torri shrinkage in kales rates ali moat most of our iron rind coil roll comes from front illinois this 3 a f ar ah not distributed in Cli li leago ag as would hate hae been the case had we worked on fin the sumo output hat that we me did in DUG 1106 and anti 1007 1907 and n great deal of th hit thit it whick was not laid aid atia is out of th the business firms altu abed in or near chicago by ill he non burch aises from front their girled business on oil till pirt of the community that hae hap received tho tile a beor ear that ie Is the ret son on why I 1 hive a right ne as a b mines inan man to deprecate any unfair or un called for obstacles that are re placed in the ika a of my lily business and the nun hun art drad 1 I other aarli ties of I 1 lutiness in lit thit I country that are affected by lie the money put into circulation by the railroads it it ll 11 Is to f further I 1 that lily business constitutes but 10 pel pei cent of the rot cost of n car tar and that chete anio io will othar unit units similarly affect pd ed mot of which ft bild hae acen tributary it to chicago can see bee hoi important it Is lit to hia his individual interests thit that the nill roid ld tom should have ample timple funda to make these improvements and purchases pur chaves and will how compa athrell disy it will bt to bani ia a advance on oil iho the freight for any he will i decd if he U receiving ardeis T A grimn advertisement food alar 0 d u are re best for your table because they are made of the choicest materials and guaranteed to be absolutely pure libbs veal loaf makes a delightful dish for lunch eon and you will find libb 40 vienna I 1 corned beef pork and bean beans evaporated milk equally qually tempting for any meal have a supply of libb in the house and you will always be prepared for an extra guest you can buy libbis at all grocers libby mcneill libby lib by chicago it t ia I 1 no wonder hen to da they see JS 11 silver we ci C present presents may be b halo y L 14 or dollar collars M I 1 liver silver up u 0 I 1 4 dollars al 0 I 1 solid bi unequalled guarantee guaran tet tn t 1 HI IQ f SALT EA very I 1 11 N 8 r L te ia fir 1 faeh I 1 I 1 a if 1 4 an IN A n r u ff ff k ask tor for it QUI Cali califor forr excy TIL ti 1 3 led edi art I 1 t rn ditc t ig ft t H at forr orr I 1 sai 1 0 1 r ata ai at I 1 t to oooo 00 t C I 1 lah nit T I 1 Y n iii M I 1 at 4 ti ait tits 1 IF t I 1 FT drw H itt IL a I 1 ku lor for I 1 i at 11 I 1 1 sin IM oft atit d ali I 1 11 I 1 k RUBBER line kup 1 I 1 p i i 1 limit il d SALT LAKE STAMP mk TAKE A FOOT FOOTBATH BATH TONIGHT after adlis alf ml nit x or two mien ilena foot T tat ach ll 11 antiseptic tablet for ahr ill toot bath 1 n the e batir it ill take out all more T r at 1 1 ing and rind toot fot 1 re an 1 fregi 1 I 1 n tic the fe fei t allen x foot instants rolfka and sa or feet an binl I 1 bt lint ner of 0 tip fiet a niehl night then for houi the lay day bli sh kp ke alien allen e I 1 rot cot 1 mi the he antl itic pad r into your F chob h 1 hold me avoid hub mil 1411 ie to gambles toot T TAba fihs ihs nail I 1 J ail TU I 1 or our rel cular ilar size ilze pent b by t pill for ailian Ai liln alien allen li if bitoy bitoy N I 1 lad 1 burnk eak enry antery nry erets er Pied ily Alli millin tIne I 1 ye luridly try at iram I 1 r loir ajr I 1 e lle ro x you 1 arr I I 1 I 1 ilk lk murla it b h oth 5 bit L at your vr I 1 U allf rit I 1 r I 1 it v 1 it I 1 ok k aree ree irin I 1 f it 11 i 1 hit ayi it lk th iiri omi to epe ile ho hoft the space floars a roan man of and id 1 ailin find afif edoin if I 1 in in fonti rif I 1 I 1 P allta reul wat url rit tf ind ant llev li alz binl hor bugar cat I 1 liny M 4 candy kiil ill t webs an angel bo callol she it e fly fl it guar it DEAF HEAR a THE AURIS alicel irr bul leads ri iti 1 idt to dij day AURIS COMPANY i i |