OCR Text |
Show MONDAY, NOVEMBER PAGE FIFTEEN INTERMOUNTAIN COMMERCIAL RECORD 11, 1974 In The Supreme Court of The State of Utah Wyoming divorce decree, whatever that means. While the , trial judge 1 HENRIOD, did not use the term "domesticate" he did order: Respectfully, I dissent. That the It appears that the hallmark of the main opinion considerably is based on the gratuity that if anybody, - just anybody, - pays a decreed amount for X, beneficiary of a judgment, - has some kind of an immutable right to collect from the judgment debtor. The main opinion says that if someone other than the judgment debtor takes care of the obligation, "That person then has the right to claim reimbursement, . . . the same as any other past debt." It is impossible to determine who "that person" is here unless it be Baggs, her new husband, - who has no contractual rights against the old husband. judgment of the District Court of Natrona County, State of Wyoming, rendered on June 24, 1970, by which defendant herein was awarded an absolute divorce from plaintiff herein and defendant was ordered to pay to plaintiff support in the sum of $200. 00 per month from the date of such judgment be, and the same hereby is, made the judg- ... ment and decree of this court. I do not think we can make the judgment of a sister state the judgment of the courts of this State. All we can do with a foreign judgment is to Such a concept allows an interloper, not particeps to a debt, and not a litigant in a legal proceeding, to muscle in on a contract or debt or judgment and collect on a voluntary payment of someone else's obligation, -when the latter may be subject to a legal defense on the part of the creditor, such as fraud upon the court, full payment made, bankruptcy and any of many other such defenses. If Karen is suing for what she has paid, is one thing, but if she is suing for what Baggs has furnished, is another, which seems to be the case here. It seems to me that the term is more appropriately applied to wild animals. recognize rights conferred on the parties by it and to enforce it insofar as it 1. purports to give a money judgment to a party. We cannot modify it in any particular. We would create great mischief if we undertake to make a foreign judgment our own and then try to modify it or to enforce it. , Tuckett, Justice, concurs in the views expressed in the concurring opinion of Mr. Justice Ellett. - Estella Mining Partners, Ltd. 4783 Idlewild Circle, Salt Lake City, Utah Randall C. Pedrotti, Probate of Will James H. Faust, atty Hearing II207I 61519 - Dea, Shelly Diane . compromise J. &egg, atty 61521 - Meyer, Arvilla E. Probate of Will Perris S. Jensen, atty H. Joel Gordon McDonald Gresham, K. Raybould and Sheets Uniform These are Uniform Commercial Code filings with the Secretary of State's office. It will indicate the security used on the loan. Example . . . "hhg" is household goods; "Of Eq" Is office equipment; "Cmpr" is a camper, etc. BelviewAve., SLC.UT 84107 to Avco FinServ; HHG, furn, appli, con gds. Garrett, attys Letters of Admr. Hanson and Garrett, atty S. 338 E. M. HHG, - Loveless, Sadie P. Probate of Will Clarence Williams, atty Hearing 112774 61537 - Kinsey, John David Settlement, of Claim Edward M. Garrett, atty 61538 - Martin, Jackie Settlement of claim Cook, atty Confirmation of Salt Probate Hearing, Wednesday, 9:00 - 972- FR0ST, Thelma K. Hintze and 550 E. , SLC, UT Liberty Thrft & co-E- te 982-REI- 273, Cottonwood Mall, Holladay, Utah 60637 - Kandace, May Hudson Moffet E. Falkner,Admr. Confirmation of sale of real property located 450 South 11th East, to George M. McMillan for $20,400; Earl Greenwood, 444 South Salt Lake Jr. atty State, Suite City, Utah 202 A., & LA W. Leasing Co! - OF JOHNNY LEE & UTAH, 153-- R U. Button ,84115 to;-- ; Ave., FMA Leasing Co; stand. SLC.UT St., Fid Ind - 172- CLAIR OPTICAL, 1255 E. 3900 S., SLC, UT 84117 to FMA Leasing Co; chairs, F. & ANITTA, Utopia, SLC.UT Cr Co; UT , 171- VREDENBURG DEVELOPMENT HHG. EVANS, MIKE to Fid Ind to SLC FMA dictaphone, Cr Co; 153 120 E. 3500 S., 84120 equip. HHG. CORP. , 440 7th E., SLC.UT 84102 to Centry Equip Co; excavator motor grader, crawler S. tractor. 066-RW- CO. , S. & WILLIAM S. JR., & WEBB, BEN, 2126 Linden Ln., SLC, UT to Madaen Furn Co; carpet, L. , 1730 W. 440 S. 5, Bntfl, Ut 84010 to Fid Ind Cr Co; KERRY HHG. 103-PAG- minipr inter, accessories, JIM B. & VERNA, E, 4116 W. 4400 S., Krns, UT 84118 to Fid Ind Cr Co; HHG. JAMES R. & MORTIMER, ROGER R. DBA CYCLE VILLA HUSKY, 9554 S. RAE, State St., Sandy, UT 84070 to 1st Sec Bk of Ut; inventory. 111-ISBE- MANUAL, LL, 267 N. Redwood Rd., SLC.UT to Centry Fin; t.v. 117-KA- TZ, IS YOUR TYPEWRITER TIRED? OF POOR SERVICE? OR SLOW SERVICE CONSTRUCTION RADMALL, WILLIAM R 531 Treck Photographic Inc; processor. dictatingtranscribing equip. 168- - J01LNS0N, BRUCE R., 5410 HHG. UT Rd., Grngr, Ut FMA Leasing Co; to Corp; con gds. drapes. 3817 Sunnydale Dr., Grngr, Ut84119 to Mur IstThrft & Loan Co; HH furn, apli. & SON, 423 E. Broadway, SLC, UT 84111 to ic SLC, CO., 1054 S. Redwood GRANT M., 2155 S. Main, SLC.UT 84115 to FMA Leasing Co; lanler R, & RENEA, 1675 War nock Ave. , SLC.UT 84119 to Fid Ind Welby 84115 to & 167- - PRISBRY, LELAND Cr Co; D. VALY MACHINE, equip. St., ROBERT DBA WEST 84104 Forrest Hills Dr., UT to Assoc Fin Serv; ES, -TILLETT, DORIUS HHG. 151-AM- personalty., STEVE & MARCIA, Oil Co of CA; conditional sales contract. kre-mat- 166- 2614 S. 15th E. , SLC ,UT 84106 to Centry Acceptance L.., 604 SLC 84111 to ,UT S. State, Co dba Standud Chevron Oil 9 86 -- HART, RICHARD L. T0NI, 2776 , 006 -NELSON, RAY C. & DANIELLE, 1560 E. 3010 S., SLC, in to Centry Fin Co; furn, appli. RONALD D, SLC, CORP., 412, Kennectoot Bldg., SLC, UT 84111 to FMA Leasing Co; MAURICE & VELMA, 3736 & Room appli. Post St., SLC, UT 84104 to Avco FinServ; HHG, furn, appli, con gds. E. Cupples, for $29,500; ' v 84111 to Loan Corp; DEBBIE JOE & EXPLORATION. compensator. 135-WRIG- CORP., 3920 E., SLC.UT 84117 to Leasing Co; photocopying machine. 84111 to Eastman Kodak Co; data UT DPM A 165- - PAN AMERICAN ENERGY cable, ground clamp, electrode' holder, connectors Jackson lugs. 134- - REPLIC0L0R LABORATORIES, SIC, E,, S. 11' . FMA W. DPM & S. 9050 W., Magna, Ut HHG. real property located 4583 South 7th East, to Charles Hintze, to Centry PROFESSIONAL Air Inc; welder, beldon INC., 236 Edison MAX JONES, to ICM Rentals; & - BILLS, 4681 Krns, Ut 84119 Fin Co; furn, J. roller. 152- PRITCHETT, ALANA, 356 HHG. 004- - CHARLES D. W. 5015 S., HHG, furn, appli, personal property. cadillac. REPAIR, 3866 S. 4620 W. SLC, UT 84120 to Liquid 845 E., to Centry FinCo; furn, S. 53 ANN, UT SLC, & & STate St., SLC.UT to Avco Fin Serv; con gds, 6495 S. 133 --PERRY & LAR0SE to Admiral Ind Cr Co; appli. - furn, fixtures, appli, x. Bridge Confirmation of sale of Atty-Sui- furn, appli, 662 4th Ave., Sales forklift. J., NACHI0 005- VALDEZ, RICHARD D. & RON, LEO 003- YINGER, JOE & ELAINE t.v., SH, 6IO98 - Grace Eliz Korous Raymond A. JAMES W. & RENAE, ALICE, 4068 S. 4072 W., Grngr, Ut to Town Ind Fin Co; HHG, equip, boat, mtr, wedding rings. 973- - SCHMITTROTH, RICHARD L. & LESLIE, 221 E. 3570 S., Mur, Ut 84107 to Liberty Thrft & Loan Corp; furn, vacuum. appli, 974- - BARKER, RALPH W., 3405 S. 2nd E., Apt 5, SLC, UT 84115 to Zales 755; diamond cluster. 13, 1974 Jrdn, W. 8200 S. 1754 W. , W. Jrdn, Ut84084 to Centry FinCo; - 61536 LINDA, to Centry FinCo; furn, appli, t.v., washer, Ut 84084 appli. HHG, lawn mowers. "JOHN R. & JOY, 4154 S. 3700 W. 3, C. & KATHERN, 3717 S. 3375 W., Grngr, Ut 84119 to Town Ind Fin Co; HHG. & 1595 Denver St., SLC,UT 84115 to Centry Fin Co; furn, HHG, jewelry. 971- 0GAARD, MuCHAEL . G. S., 999 --ORTEGA, 4541 W. 5055 S., Krns, UT 84118 to Town Ind Fin Co; Evagelia Probate of Will Albert R. Bowen. atty K. - THOMAS 132 --OLSON CONSTRUCTION, 1549 S. 300 W..SL6, UT to ICM Div ofWheeler Machinery; dryer, stereo. Fin Serv; Grngr, Ut to Town Ind Fin Co; HHG, guns, bowling Hll71 Bessie Centry Fin Co; furn, appli. L. , 415 Mur, UT furn, appli, con balls. 970- - HEATH, Equip & 998- SHADOAN, SKIP 2847 W. 8250 Co; Hearing 112071 61531 - Phibbs,. Bertie F. Letters of Admr. Richard R. Neslen,atty A. M. H6v. LINDA, 6319 Sumac Way, SLC,UT 84121 to Matheson; LEO, Woodlake 408 E. Dr., Apt. 38, Call , " Fed Machinery S . & RENNAE, & V RENTAL, SLC, UT State, & to Centry Fin Co;' Norma 123-- A SLC, to Valy Bk MIKE 997-KOC- 968ADAMS, STANLEY D. & LOUISE, 2538 S. 600 E., SLC, UT to Town Ind Fin 969-LYM- & & BETTY Equip Co; equip. H. 3580 S. 7175 W., Magna, Ut 84044 to Jeannine C. Rokich TED to 84110 console. - ROBERT 158- - CHELATRON DIVISION OF INTERMOUNTAIN LABORATORIES , INC., P.O. Box 633, SLC.UT VIVIAN GAY, 3011 122- MYRICK, M. & JAY. Rd., Range - 3902 Lockwood Way ?29, Grngr, Ut 84120,, to .Ben Fin Co; HUG, S. 2910 W., Grngr, Ut to Metro Fin Co; stereo, furn, appli. gds. Probate of Will D. Cassity, atty W. 3, 84107 toAvco William Marshall, atty, Hearing II207I 61533 - Bartholomew, Betty Stephen 84118 9 67 -- HANSEN, HAROLD Admr. 112074 trlr, Trst Co; hydvalic chairs, dryers with chairs. 996- -HOGGAN, RICHARD D., 5004 Piper Blvd., Krns, Ut JACI, 429 Hearing II207I 61528 - Kochonis, Ernest Hearing 1096 C, UT 84117 equip. - 3548 S., appli. HHG. 120- SWETT, RICHARD 157- GODDING, 119 - JOHNSON, DICK S., 2139 E. 2700 S., SLC, UT to Metro Fin Co; HHG, scuba Postal SL THOMAS Commercial Code Filings: Probate of Will Hearing 112074 61529 - Foard, Mina to SLC.UT Employees Cr Union; Uniform Commercial Code Filings Hearing 112071 61527 - Kochonis, John A. . Dr., ' JOSEPH Roosevelt Ave., to Metro Fin Co; UT - EDLER, S. 6000 W., SLC.UT 84120 to Blazer Fin Serv; furn, 348 E. SLC, 7780, snowmobile. Curtis Oberhansley,atty 61526 - Monson, Gladys Conde Determination of heirship Loren Dale Martin, atty Heariwng 61535 - Farthelos, Gary M. Pet. to settle claim Letters of J. PETER, Box Mur, Ut84107 to Wheeler Machinery Co; loader. 994- -MATHIS, HENRY G. & BEVERLEE A., 855 Pine Way Ltd; 1411 Deseret Bldg, Realvest, Inc. Robert W. Grant Mac far lane, atty Hearing 11207 61525 - Garcia, John G.Jr. Hanson and - II992 - Village of U2071 - Parks, Lucile Probate of Will HHG. 991- KIEWIT, -- RINDLISBACHER, 445-1- 18 S., J., Martinez and R. furn. 1481 R., Redondo Ave. , SLC ,UT 84105 to Valy Bk & Trst Co; piano. 990- - SMITH, ARVEL 3164 S. 7200 W., Magna, Ut 84044 to Captl FinServ; Windsor Management; C Victor Sagers, atty Hearing - GALEN 989- JONES, - Utah Real Estate and Investment Co. ftaly Admr. 6152I4 piano. 156- to Metro Fin Co; SLC.UT -J- Kenneth Heinhold Nolan Olsen, atty Hearing II207J4 61523 - Dunoskovic, June Q. Letters of 988 OHNSON, CHRIS W., 3409 S. 620 E. , SLC,UT 84106 to Valy Bk & Trst Co; 11991 II207U - Karris, JA Donna Probate of Will Code Filings Newport Beach, Calif. 11990 - Heinhold Investment Company, Salt Lake City Duane Heinhold and Pet. for approval of Hearing Uniform Commercial 11988 61518 - Stevenson, Ida B. 61522 The statement of the main opinion, quoted above, completely departs from any known principles in the law of contracts. New Partnerships Probate Court " Justice; (Dissenting) 364-197- 5 For Quick Quality Repair Service We Service AH Makes and Models Save This Ad for a 40 Discount on your next service call. Salt Lake Copy 361 E. Second So. ROYAL' Limited to One Per Customer Expires Nov. 30, 1974 |