OCR Text |
Show MONDAY, AUGUST 5, 1974 PAGE SEVENTEEN INTERMOUNTAIN COMMERCIAL RECORD In The Supreme Court of The State of Utah 32 A. L. R. 3d 496; and "gratuitous. " The suggestion as to additional authorities that could have been cited supporting my position is ap- v. General Telephone Co. of Cal. , 66 C.2d 503, 58 Film Cal.Rptr. 316, 426 P. 2d 884, 886; Parker v. Twentieth Century-Fo- x 615. 3d 3d 44 A. 89 176, R. 2d 3C. 474 L. 737. 689, P. Corp., Cal.Rptr. 8. 163 Colo. 524, 452 P. 2d 375. Alio recognizing the severe consequences attending the granting of summary preciated: those I did cite were admittedly cited sparingly to avoid needless proliferation so often done in law books. If the desire is to extend citations against the position stated in the main opinion, there could have been included literally a multitude of cases from the jurisdictions cited, and the two most authorities on the subject, all of which are unanieminent and mous in affirming the position I have stated. And significantly, there is cited no authority to the contrary. used with temperance judgments, Professor Moore advises that they should and caution. 6 Moore's Federal Practice, Para. 56. 15 l. -- 10, at p. 2312. well-recogniz- When in commenting on this dissent, the main opinion's author talks about "gratuitous statements" put in opinions concerning summary judgments, it is suggested that he reflect upon the instant case. There is no disagreement herein among the justices as to affirming the no cause of action ruling on sum- It is my opinion that the law is correctly stated in our prior decisions, Therefore I do not concur with the comments made in the main opinion concerning summary judgments. (All emphasis added. ) New Actions Murray City Power 5th So. WILLIAM HARK 309 E. 65046 IC STEWART 500 So. J. DG5INK 1(10 31 oa; LEWIS 800 So. I69 E. wll E. 4800 So. 3 ALMA EARL atty; 8 State JAKES 6661 l6D STOUT LAWRENCE J. DONALD Eastlake Dr. 6665 atty; NNE ROGER 6-5- 560 E. KENT B. 4 So. 55 Murray her: 5992 S. 677 225 E. 4460 So. It. TIDWEIL 247 E. Vine St. ANN L. 6750 6 INC. WORLD OF AUTOS, R. State St. 5757 So. 675 vs New Actions Murray City 65034 Carling, atty 6755 dba 3681 So. BEEFEATERS oa; Highland Dr. $210 agreement; D. H. Schvobe, INN; 2903 atty; 65035 vs ROBERT HORST, JR.; 3480 View G. WALK E- 676 ncy vs 8-7 cont 6773 7-- 8-7 T. 65038 Granite Teachers Credit Union vs PHILLIP R. JOHNSTON L OWEN S. JOHNSTON; 4639 Dar tmouth Dr. Kearns; $26l; agreements L. Bishop, atty 7-- 8-7 ROWS ELL; t JANNEE 1? E, Angelo $27 serv; T. P. Vuyk, atty; 7-- 9-j 7 65044 IC vs Premium 1227 W 7th S. or T. P. ' Oil Co. $117; Vuyk, atty; 6505 IC vs GAYLORD L DOROTHY DANIEL; 1999 V. No. Temple ft serv; T. P. Vuyk $76; FRANK CHIDESTER oa; 7-- 9-7 oa ttyj R. 6776 . N. 7-- 9-7 auto accid atty; 6-- Age J. Carling, atty O KSL, Inc vs ATI ON SALES; $200; R. 6788 J. Carling, atty $613; oa; oa 6-1- ft RECR- Cinnabar ACS E- DENNIS ft MRS. 4-7 vs MARI- 3500 S T. P. Vuyk, atty W vs 5-7 5-7 SHEPARD $ to pltf $91 vs LEROY ft CONNIE 7070 W 3500 S. $l62 EUGENE LARS EN dba INC.; 3066 S. to pltf; 5-7 $112 to pltf; 6929 KAB VS RICHARD X. ffORGEK SEN; 116 Pioneer, Midvale or 6o E. Center; $40 to pltf; 3-7 VS DONNA IO83 Weneo Cir. H. NATTER $107 to pltf WSC VS CHARLES E 2880 S. $185 WSC VS DARRELL D. ROWS ELL to ft FAYE CAS PER; 13660 S 3rd E. $62; serv; T. P. Vuyk, atty 6-1- 7-7 6793 KAB vs C.W. ft EDNA WELDON 2828 So. State 9; $26; T. P. Vuyk, atty 6- -1 7- -7 6811 IC VS M. JUANITA COOKE; T. P. Vuyk, atty 559; oa; arv; 6950 to pltf: 695 Price Brothers Automotive $903 185 2300 So. $555i 7-2- 3-7 Inc vs KEITH L. ROBINSON 1 267 E 2980 S. $19 to pltf; 5-7 6986 33 UC VS BRUCE ft JOYCE LONG E, 7635 So. $10 5-7 Co. vs BEAUTY PRODUCTS; W K. ft ROBIN 218 E 500 S MARIE ESXELSON; 6-1- 7-7 6825 Wasatch Chemical oa; to pltf; 6999 WSC 6-7 - 6-7 vs ERNEST L. ft ELLEN .1622 Indiana Ave WRIGHT; 190 to pltf; 65055 SAB vs LARRY K. OLSEN; 389 E. 200 So. $166 to pltf 9-7 65068 Doc. & Mer. Cdt vs VARLO 1102 E. 500 S $952 to pltf; 65080 KAB vs JAN MARSHALL 1623 Northwood 6; $79 to pltf; 65092 KAB vs GAIL A. ft HELEN 7-2- 9-7 VS LAMAR 3135 V B750 S to pltf REESE AVERY $225 to $15 ' 2653 Vespa Dr. pltf; Cr Union ETUX GARTH D GARDNER etal & Inv LANCER CONSTRUCTION to to pltf; CLARK. to $2900 ETUX KAUFMAN LEONARD to Univac H $5000 359 W RALPH 555 HARDY ETUX to BUILDERS to to Title, to Tr $3000 CRAIO L POSSELLI ETUX HENRY Officers: Pres.: Albert Sands Lippert, Sousa Dr., Charles Point, NY; Ln., Felt, Oak Ridge Searington, NY 11507; 7 Hayden E. Davis, V-- P.: V-- P.: Wey-brid- ge NY , Great Neck, VrP.: Fred Jaraslow, Chestnut Rd., Manhasset, M WOLKMAN ETUX Charles Bryan Smith "h, Kent Red Spring Colony, Glen Cove, NY 11542; Sec: Felice Lippert, Sousa Dr., Sands Point, NY; Tres.: Manny Mark, 3 Lake Rd. N., Great Neck, NY 11020; 11542; V-- P.: Controller: Richard M. NY 11803. Dr., STEEL & to to etux $114,000 New Corporations New Corporation filings are listed for the entire State of Utah as recorded in the Secretary of State's Office. 702ADAIR RIPPY, INC., P.O. Holman, 4908 W. Pasco, Washington; H. Kenneth Sec: Univac SLC Em Cr $2158 620 190 KENNETH P LEAVITT ETUX to Kirton Land etal $2800 191 INC. , Ross Bldg. , Richmond, Virginia. James Nixon, Barbara Jens on $3000 769 INTERNAT- WATCHERS V-- P.: to Security France. 7 05 --WEIGHT IONAL, INC., P.O. Box 180, Montana. Timer, Big Officers: Pres.: Ralph M. Holman; P(0.:Boi: 180, Big Timber, Montana; to 0 ALENCO 5250 Whispering MX Bloomfield, Vest Oak, (8033; Directors: Bur tr urn ' 5. Mellott, 5760 Crabjtree Rd., Birmingham ; ML 48010; John A. Gallagher, P.O.. Box 6, Andrecieux Boutheon, BASIN to QUINNEY ETUX Univac SLC Em Fed $6000 919 WALLACE C BRAZZEAL ETUX Beverly B Citheroe $1300 619 208 MICHAEL DOOLIN ETAL 266 er Fisher , IRON, Inc $7000 DAVID C CLARK ETUX GARY Alexand- Ut 84107. Fed SLC Em Wilbern L McDougal $1082 695 Troy, 2-- C, Ut; Greg Morrison, 2330 S. Main, SLC, Ut; Richard Parker, P.O. Box 7206, SLC, Rogers Jr etux Award Homes 404 J. Mllllman, Coachman Dr., Apt MI 48084; Sec: P. Harold INC., 431 S. 3rd E. Suite 511 SLC, Ut 84111. Trustees: Benjamin G. Midgley, Jr., 2330 S. Main, SLC, Ut; LaDeen Midgley, 2330 S. Main, SLC, to DAVID LEON EWELL ETUX Charles V-- P.: HEALTH PLANS, $5016 .127 48013; MI Samber, Majestic Realty & Inv $10 588 LEO WEST OVER ETUX to Univac SLG Em Fed $10,195 63? 217 KELVIN E MILLER ETUX to Univac SLC Em led Cr $7000 618 108 EDWIN CHARLES MADDQX ETUX J. Donald MacPetrie, Tiverton Rd., Bloom-fiel- d, Plalnview, to ETUX Wilcock $2000 W c.: 1953 NY to H JOHNSON ETUX Kirton Land 185 V-f- 139 $13,500 ' P.: 30511 Georgetown Dr., Birmingham, MI 48010; Eletor Kotwick, 24700 Urges Dr., Southfield, MI 48075; 11023; University Utah 636 173 V-- R"d. 635 57b LAMAR WALKER ETUX to 0 Ihayne Acord etux $5800 939 JANES CORPv, 20800 Coolldge Hwy., Oak Park, MI 48237. Officers: Pres.: Leo J. Lapwing, 4978 Mallbu Rd., Bloomfield Hills, MI; William R. Brink, 7-2- 9-7 Second Mortgages pltf 3-7 KAB VS LAMAR 7-2- 6-7 3-7 7-7 6791 $237 to pltf; 65020 IC vs GERALD D. b SHIRLEY WRIGHT; 609 N 100 W 3 $125 5-7 UC VS TONY ft DARLENE VANCE; 91 W. 955 So. 2839 HAY ft BONNIE DAHL 6-7 319 YVONNE 300 W. $330 690 to $8 Wyo. V-- P.: IC vs Carole ALBERT ft VICKI 3l60 S 060 W. PARTS, WSC E 9-7 253 PLATTE B Cir. 5002 Jones 6902 6939 5 2000 S Security Title, Tr $3300 5-7 3-7 HI-L- KAB vs LA VERL ANNE WINTERS ; 3069 6-1- 6-1- S. ft GE- R- 5-7 6890 717 R. POWELL; 2950 W. 2960 So. $81 to pltf; 65019 IC vs NILE R. ft ROCHELLE LARS EN; 121 Serpentine Way 7-2- 5-7 0 Downington; TRUCK Fon 25 vs to pltf; 6891 ACS vs Tr. Co. vs DONLEAVY; ACS THOMAS; taine Bleu Dr. $72; cent; 7-- 8-7 WALLY 6889 R. SUSAN pltf; So. 7-2- 3-7 to pltf; $165 R. TIPPETTS; Tey Col Bk b ACS KAB 65OO9 W. 6-7 JOHNSON; Andrew Lanham, Rawlins, Wyo.; Sec.: Ginger Lanham, Box 1288, Rawlins, Wyo.; Tres.: Charmaln Ball, 3871 Swan ton, V-- P.: - pltf; 1913 So. 3871 Swan ton, Casper, Wyo. Officers: Pres.: Boyd Ball, 3871 Swan ton, Casper, Casper, $421 to pltf; vs LONNIE L. ft JANET Temple; 65001 9-7 232 to pltf RUTTENBUR; 3-7 37l6 So. Highlsnd Dr. 51 $470; agreement; L. Bishop, 65042 IC vs 6888 Center, Mldvale; $06 J. Carling, atty; 115 E. 65037 Continental Account Serv House vs GARY L. THAYNE; atty; DAVID pltf to pltf; $170 DOUGLAS 6772 Business Collection T. P. Vuyk. atty 65036 Ted Hay vs ED PERRY; 291 No. 5th E. Sandy; $500 per day rent; agreement ; K. G. atty; ACS RUSSELL L. HALL; C $598; Burk G. Pinkus vs to BLAINE to pltf; 6887 2-7 Dr. $249; agreement; Hansen, State LEE V. AVERETT; M. Blanchfield, P.O. Box 287, New Castle, Colo. 81647. 7 03 - ROCKY MOUNTAIN IND. , INC. , 7 04 THE VALERON Frontier Finance Co. vs 65000 ft Co. vs ACS vs JAN R. ft CONNIE CHRISTENS EN; 203 E. 1300 $229; oa; G. HOLLAND; $800; eat; L. K. Wimmer, N- Terrace 7-- 1-7 7381 RYAN; 5-7 WILKINSON; ft JO WEST; 122 3rd E. $41 1-7 7-- 5-7 KAB oa; S. Barton, atty; R. $208 5-7 1-7 WSC VS JAMES St. S. So. $595 to pltf; 6878 ACS vs BERNARDO ft BONNIE GUTIERREZ; 219 Wilson Ave. 2518 New R. J. TREASURE HOMES; 'V Larry Deelstra vs CHRIS 18 S 6th E 1 $536 ALDINE EOCLES; 1-7 7-2- 6-7 LINDA 7-2- 6-7 9-7 6812 IC vs CO; 6-1- pltf; to pltf; 6532 Sears, Roebuck 687 pltf; N- D W. ft MRS. REEVE; IRISH; 67 Ln. $53 So; 1515 R. Box 1288, 7-2- 6-7 7-2- 3-7 ROBERT LARRY M. CHRISTE- Claret Cir.; $172 to 7-2- 3-7 Continental Asso. Ind. port Cir.4 $175; Carpenter Paper Co. vs JOHN PERRY $67; J.. Carling, atty vs J. FEENEY; dba JOHNSON SAND ft 2375 S. 300 W. East 6100 South 6910 4IC 65031 6376 IC vs LEONARD R. PELLW dba TEX'S AUTO ft BARBARA K. PELLIK5 426 Creeks ide Dr. or to 1375 So. Main St. $3 691 1-7 GRAVEL 06 to pltf; KAB Judgments Murray City Court to 2710 R. S $25; note; 6-1- W. 7-- 5-7 6395 Williams Oil Co. vs Custom Inc. Thrifty Rent a car vs GUST M. JANIS 1638 W 7700 S. $107; cont; R. J. Carting, atty 6753 Frank Edwards Co. vs THE BROADWAY 250 135 S. SEN; $6 to Box 287, New Castle, Colo. 81647. Directors: Larry R. Schmuesser, P.O. ..Box 287, New Castle, Colo. 81647; Adair Rlppy P.O. Box 287, New Castle, Colo. 81647; Pauline Rlppy, P.O. Box 287, New Castle, Colo. 81647; Wyo.; 65023 IC vs JACK A. ft LELA A. STREET; 8167 W 3100 So $273 6th So. $652; LS Qt; 1059 note; B. Hash, atty E pltf; atty JOANN LYMAN; 6751 C CORP. 300 vs WSC E. SHEA so. Way 0-7 E. H. Fankhauser, 6832 IC vs ft PHILIP C. FOU 0. KELVIN FRANK Barton, atty; 41 400 Creeks ide 5516 Toyota 1-7 oa; 63 DEWEY ALL MINERALS vs 1-7 5460 So. 121 East KATHY 7-- 5-7 Elaine Dr. $239; cont. a W. GARTH Sonata. Dr.; $27; chk; R. L. Lord, atty 65033 Metropolitan Finance Co. 678 4 dba ENTERPRISES; 1111 CAMPBELL od SAB vs ROBERT E. ARELLA88 NO ft SHERRY ARELLANO; POPE , GARTH CAMPBELL E. ft FAY VS CARL SAB atty; JANET JULIA atty 7-- 5-7 All States Dist. Co. vs 65032 5530 So. Vuyk,. atty Victoria oa; atty; Vuyk, 6l8 Roosevelt Ave. $63; serv; E. H. Fankhauser Three Fountains 725 E. atty SHARP; BECKSTEAD E. B. Hash, chk; GEE MICHAEL P. CHILDERS; 132 6417 So. 990 West DOYLE St. . 9-7 oa E S 3-7 U.S. A; Pres. L. J. Lambrow, 207 E. 4050 So. $520 to pltf; 7-- 5-7 dba Grain C. G. UI.D,- vs Market ger's Wester W. KELVIN T. KAB 3500 7717 $5; T. P. Vuyk, atty; 65031 KAB vs ERNEST L. ft ELLEN J. WRIGHT; her: 1622 Indiana Commercial Dist. Ave, him: T. P 25 S 400 W; $168; 6737 Lyle Grainger ALL EN BACH GLINES ANN W. 95 6-- 7-7 L. BACCA So. 115 West THCKAS oa; $105; E E pltf; UNITED CAMPGROUNDS TAYLOR 220 S 1350 Vuyk, atty T. P. to $75 3-7 Ouray; $596 to 5- -7 PACK; JOA- Crown 0 1 Starlite 5991 him: EDGEHAN; B. WENDELL HOWELL; 6822 The Baltimore Hilton vs 7-- 5-7 VS LARRY ft PATTY KAB atty vs VELDA CAROLAN; rv 2665 Highland Dr. $135; T. P. Vuyk, atty 65030 KAB vs MICHAEL ft PATRICIA -7 6717 C NIELSEN L. R. L DUSER; 18 "A" serv; T. P. Vuyk, PATRICK - 65029 6-- 5-7 5329 So. 580 East D ELLA C. KVAALL I83 W. 5900 So. 20 RICHARD 7- 3-7 Bee-chvo- HUKUEL 5323 So. 560 E. PAXELA JOHNN oa; $58; 6691 IC vs ARCHIE THOMAS LANE ft MICHAEL LANE aka MICHAEL 366 WILKINSON; Archie: Rd. Michael: 137 W. Lennox St. 5; $56; serv; T. P. Vuyk, atty REYNOLDS 115 Unlimited vs VAN $5; LUNDIN 5470 So. 235 E. 6-- 6688 IC vs - . atty; vs KAB LEE PERSXNGER; 0 Vuyk, T. P. Vuyk, serv; vs BLAINE Admiral Industrial Credit Co. vs JOHN R. SMITH; 830 9-7 7 19-- Way 7-2- 3-7 Carnation Dr. pltf; 65073 T. P. ft SUSAN Serpentine $10 to pltf; KAB 7-- 5-7 W. 5648 So. 300 W. JOSH II C, THOMAS 5341 Hillside Dr. L. Guns $17; oa; C. LEON 1101 KINDER; 103 HEINZ ft KATHLEEN 61 S 9th E A; $57; oa; T. P. Vuyk, atty 65028 KAB vs LAWRENCE ft DEBBORA b JANET FRECKING;'3l6 Vincent St. $10; ehk; B. Ha ticKEE STRING FELLOW RANDY Manhattan Dr. - 65027 6-- 3-7 22G 4476 So. 3rd West LOUISE B. SAGENDORF 4518 So. 3rd West SHAN 6- vs 3815 vs IC vs KAB 65067 9-7 $863; Ver- CLYDE T.fc JUNE Bridgeport serv; T. P. Vuyk 6-1- vs Letter Service 65065 Vuyk, atty 6833 IC vs NCLA V. BERTUL; 11th 1352 So. H. C. $0; oa; T..P. DELX DOUGLAS 4919 So. Letter Service vs KAB SYJHES; 3-7 8-7 G. ft JUDY 2661 E. STEINMANN; 7-- 9-7 BEARD; So. Eastlake Dr. 4931 dba NOAH'S oa; atty; WOOD XC VS KENNETH 6831 JOE AUER; 3558 So. 805 East H. C. Verhaaren $636; 22 J. Carling, atty: atty; Corp vs 7-- 9-7 65052 Moench 4930 So. Eastlake Dr. DARRELL Murray City Court Ave. $128; 7-- 9-7 29 J. A. atty; East; $373; oa; haaren, atty; 17 LOIS BARTHOLOMEW 875 E. 5070 So. DOUGLAS 6829 ' So. $66 ne MALIK FOSTER; BRUNDLE 580 Vine John-Malo- 65051 Hoench SCOTT 4867 So. NANCY R. KYRNA Fashion PI. Murray; oa; H. C. Verhaaren, $998; ELLISON Center St. ARK; 701 E. 4800 So. 4951 T. P. Vuyk, CRAIG PAPADAKIS MICHAEL H. H0U1ES SANDRA 165 E. ft E 667O 7-- 9-7 65048 TEAZK GAITER CELIA VS RALPH COOLEYi New Corporations Judgments Murray City Court COTTRELL 309 E. ed and other respected authorities cited. mary judgment. Consequently, it seems to me that the comments in the opinion about the character of the rule do not touch upon any controversial issue herein; MARTHA are unnecessary and that they therefore Pettis Ireland, LEGAL BRIEFS XEROXED & PRINTED Alphagraphics can copy and collate . st H per copy. Overnight Service !plfiQpaiiIiiGS 28 West 1st South Salt Lake City, Utah 84101 Telephone 364-645- 1 224 South 1300 East Salt Lake City, Utah 84102 2 Telephone 582-828- |