Show DRO DR YOUNG discharged for the second time the prosecution find no Evi delice the preliminary examination of dr seymour B young on the charge of unlawful cohabitation was held before commissioner norrell today on a former occasion tife accused was as arrested on a similar charge and ancl was released the prosecution stating that certain witnesses could not be lound found they were found later and today their teotimo testimony n was taken tile the defendant dependant delen dant elat entered elaterid ered a plea of not guilty to the accusation against again at him through his at attorney le grand young mr peters prosecuted MISS was the first witness she testified seymour B R young is my brother lie he is a married man he was married about 1 20 10 years ago to lizzle lizzie riter her youngest child is astwoo two or r three years old she lives at home my brother lives with her I 1 have seen him there occasionally know abble abbie wells state pos positively ively whether or not she to is married a e there is no reau repute te la in the family I 1 y about her I 1 have heard he ar d it rumored that she sha is in my brothers wife dont a tan know where gh she has h A a lived during daring the he past three years year a think she be has been away from the territory a portion ot the time I 1 believe she one went away about four years y ears age ray MY brother has ha been away several times at atone aone time he was in new york at another in connecticut he may have been away from home a year at a time he came from his last trip east over a year ago I 1 think miss wells came back suase quent to that date have seen a child about three years old with her I 1 think she has one dead I 1 have not see seen my brother in her ber company du during i ring the past six years she is kne known to me as abble wells W ells 3 Sed I 1 have known seymour B YOW all 11 my ay life he be to Is m my brother in law his bis wife lizzle lizzie lives with rith him on fourth east street she has several children mr young has been absent from the city during the put past three years be went aws away about two years jears ago and remained a about g out a year I 1 met him at provo on return and came to ta salt lake with him he be got oft off the train rain in the southwestern part of town do not know where he went am acquainted with abbie wells she has one child about three years old she is a women woman of good repute for chastity I 1 have heard it rumored that she is mr r youngs wife first heard beard it about two years ago have not seen the defendant and her bar in company during daring the past four our years hive have never conversed conter coulter sed with ur mr yo young edg about her JUNIUS F WELLS testified I 1 am acquainted with the de fondant fen dant abbie 0 wells is my sister she is married to seymour B young her marriage was before january 1885 she has a living child hannah louisa never ne V er heard any other name my sister to is sometimes known as mrs Mr chapin she has never been known as mrs youn in way may 1885 she left utah she went to new york then to england where she was for about two years then she came back to the states she returned to utah id A august u 1881 1887 she had bad two children then she has been at various places in utah since during the past three years I 1 have not seen mr young in her company in utah saw them together in new york in 1887 my sister bister was then qa traveling witti with me she afterwards went to canada do not know just where mr young went to then do not know whether they have ever lived together as husband and wife saw him at mothers house when my child achild was sick dont remember any other time have not seen him there since abbles return from the east her second child died about a year ago MISS KATIE CHASE te testified stifled I 1 live in Cen centreville treville davis co know the defendant ur mr peters are you yon a married woman witness hesitating I 1 dont want to answer mr peters eagerly you ought to would advise you to say yes it if yo you are witness 1 im am not mr peters why did you hesitate then witness laughing because I 1 wanted t to 0 mr pe peters t e rs are you not mr youngs plural plura 1 wife witness emphatically no sir mr peters you are not witness with still more emphasis no sir air mr peters do you kaow abble abbie wells witness W no sir the witness further testified abble abbie wells has not been at my home mr young has been there but I 1 do not know when was the last time abble abbie C wells te testified stilled I 1 have been known as mrs chapin that is an assumed name I 1 took it three years ago last may when I 1 left home I 1 assumed it because I 1 was a married woman and did not want my real name known was married to mr young april 28 1884 bat at the endowment house honse mr peters who married you witness I 1 do not wish td answer mr peters but you must witness I 1 do not wish to legrand young objected to the question as immaterial mr peters said he wanted to know who married them and the ceremony that was used mr young replied that he had no right to an answer to the questions mr peters has no right to say the marriage was admitted too late in the day that is not his affair the marr marriage iaze is admitted and proven and that is enough the questions are not material to this issue mr peters charged the witness with being unfriendly though the lady had answered promptly ly and frankly all of the questions up to the one in controversy mr young the questions are impertinent m and immaterial commissioner norrell she may answer witness joseph r F smith mr peters who were present besides you three witness there was one witness do not know him mr peters uan can you give the ceremony used witness no nosir air mr peters was your father besent witness no sir mr peters was J dwells present witness no sir air mr peters where did you live atter alter you were married witness at home wit witness ness continuing dr young called on me there in may 1885 1 went to england with my brother JF jewells Wells did not see dr young in england in October I 1 returned to new yo rk mr young and fayed t together as n man ian and wife there 1 came to denver in may 1887 17 1 I remained in denver till august when I 1 came to utah was nas 1 very sick at the time and do not remember who were with me ma lived at mothers till may 1888 1988 was ill a long time legrande LeGi ande young asked that the commissioner instruct the wita e that a ebe he need not answer any ques que silon 0 o n that would tend to criminate he r of an any offense U mr peters objected object ad to the instruction w mr young insisted that the prosecution had bad no right to take undue advantage richt of the W lady y commissioner she has a right instruction asked for she need not mot answer any question that might maht tend to criminate her witness continuing I 1 do not ki know tow how often I 1 have seen mr young since coming to utah have seen balm lalm three times in toe the marsh its is office the court room or on mhd th estreet str e t he be has not called to see me wh when an I 1 moved I 1 hired a teem team the house I 1 live jive in belon belongs to mr aly pratt mr young provides for r me he sends me money for my support mr peters rave have you any letters received from him witness 1 have not got mr peters are they destroyed Tb Th eyare mr reters peters how does he address you mr young that is Impert impertinent li abent and immaterial no commissioner she may answer that witness he headdresses addresses me as mrs chapin mr peters does he be address you as his wife witness no sir mr petersham Peters Has he been at your house witness no sir my child is three years old this mouth month she s be was born bor n I 1 in i liverpool L ver pool my second child was born bo rn in denver july 8 1887 my little girl is known as nanna chapin I 1 took that name as a family name mr young d did I 1 d not suggest it mv my letters trophim from him were addressed to to mrs chapin as I 1 informed him by letter from england I 1 have not lived with nor associated socia ted with him as a wife in utah this closed the evidence and dr young was discharged |