Show S r mf TS RIG RIGHT T Tf f TM f T Discussed at al Length in the Senate In Ill tile the lie Case of Mr Ir Buchanan Buchanon Minister to Panama LARGELY A PARTY QUESTION publicans Support President ent Jew flew ocr ls Oppose While Mr Ir Spooner Has lias Washington Jan 3 In nn In executive of 41 I the Iho senate enato today lolay lion tion of ot W IV I L to 10 be le minister to ua discussed ed for tor more than t to o hours the Iho b being con lined he eI l almost entirely to 0 the constitutional right ot at tho the to appoint Ii ler to the new republic public without the cooperation oC of the tho senate cnute The rhe point was vas as raised by the Democrats that tic tte pt to Mr Lr lloU M nominated was not flOt In existence hen th appointment was made and anU tit tAt tie the had hati ha 1 no right tight to vie cre create cr crate ate thi th position except t with the con nt of ot the senate The Democrats who hO thiS position were Hen en Morgan III Bacon Pettu and in it Th The sen Hen store alors tori the action rt C the tho th president They de tie clarc i acted wholly within lila his con limit UluI Ml ni prerogative Tho Fh principal on Oil i that sUe cf of the sere re made VatI e by h I Senators lodge Cullom Spooner und and Al AI AllOa moo lOa No io O decision was vas reported and an ant It t was ws s that tho the matter would t be considered again on In Monday M The TM status of at Mr Ir who Is II I no eoa cW nt It Panama virtually nt M n of ot the United was ns tu sed at Bacon uni Ballo BatlY In hi their Ipe che that KM the I wM nt either cither usurped the tune tunc tI n of the by h a n i minister to whoso hose nomination had lad not nol been or had sent Mr Ir r there us as an 1111 ai envoy or without color of oC law Tty They hid held that as ni the tho Is U in inWon Won m on th president lawfully could coull not nd a 11 minister to a 0 foreign coun countrY trY rv rY without tho the anti ani consent of oC the tors and Int bakA took teok the position that the t 10 Went tI u a perfect right t to nominate a t minister mini Iter to 10 the tM f l that t no such previously They claimed however that Mr Ir Buchanan was sus IS not acting ns u a mill mm lter Itu sad find that tho the president had not him OH ni such Ho He was wasp they ay a merely a IL personal represent aUa th of or the to toP P on n fl a U diplomat mission ml and alone to tho president A Arr rr for tor this was wa cited cite In Inthe inthe th the cC cw of oC Mr tr Ir mount wO vio sa sent to In Hawaii lawn by Cleveland and nn 1 who authority wu WIL paramount not notwithstanding withstanding the fact that an 1111 American wan sva at Honolulu exercising diplomatic 41 I function The general current cUrr nt of the debato dMM on party lines lilies though lions tors propounded by Ly Senators Sooner Spooner J l I lI hurn both fV f they the neil sonio doubts of nt Mr Mv 1 11 at B to III tilt legality s M It until ho he is WI 5 i minISter by tho the senate enatO When tho the went vent Into executive word won Wily was passed about aboul among th n that Hint when the arguments ments ei practically exhausted a II mo ma molion malion lion hould bo ht made to table toLlo Senator Morgana Morgn resolution to tha th nomination A motion of ot that charac charlie character ter Dr U is not rot debatable Homo Home of or the ar nr by b the Democrats I It ft In III ball ull thorough consideration and the plans Huna of oC the tho to conclude the debate te were cro not nol carried curried Into |