Show THE HE PINKERTON i 1 DETECTIVE AGENCY Confidential Reports on Miners j J Strike in Colorado Offered In Hay Haywood wood Trial PURPOSE OF INTRODUCTION To Show Sh There Existed a e Owners and Citi Citizens Citizens zens Alliance Alance to Get Secrets c c feise o to o Cloo IQ t Ill 11 fl Jr y hl Rebut t 11 al Will 1 Not Nt bo ho Length Ih Holse July Juh 1 IThe The re rl potts r lsOn on the thc strike In 1 which ih ch wel cre t taken from he the d lc to agency neny at nt lt Denver by cro this to 10 t the tho jury jur jur that tbt Is II trying William WIlam D Hay flaY Jl wood sod on rn the charge that tuH he murdered Frank Fank Falk Friedman w WiS wits s re rc to 10 the stand Mand when the trial wa wu wul resumed l and at once Identified several iw lal more nore of the th documents which he ic took look Tho fhe prosecution Interposed no objection tion 11 n to 10 ony 11 of ot the documents and ond Atty Aty Dari Jw at dt lt once beiran rend lend them to the Friedman Identified letters written by hy detective but bul the Ih Ud ld not nol of Co l them In c and de declined dined to oven counsel cunel c unset for fo or the tho tato to co them The first of tho the detectives reports F ted ved that nn on In operative named A AV AVO V O Ortus rat In s handled d the he federations f funds nt ni during the Iho strike that cut down own the tho relief relic r In order older to create CI t against Haywood The succeeding reports dealt denit with lh the federation ton convention In Den Denver D De Dever u ver vor In May Ala 10 and nd June Juie 11 1904 14 the tho action and ld sentiments of pf tho the miners nud the proceeding of ot the le union uhlon meetings it at Victor beor the In 1903 1003 the progress of ot th 3 strike Ht t Cripple Creck Cee and Ild tho the si the tho district con eon ot or the he line Workers 01 of ut 0 America In Colorado in 1902 1 03 HEt The reports are re not Intro 1 for tr r the tho le states for fo the tte Imro e oC o showing that the tho Pinkerton who they claim worn were l employed lW by the tho Mine lII Owners 1 were elo engaged In criminal but hut In 11 order or ler to tg show how that thit th all cIst a I c noral 1 Ion 1101 the mine 1110 oWn rs end and and tho the Cit to 10 secure the secrets of tho union and frustrate their lh h plans for fOl or continuing this the IC work worl of lIt f the Western Federation according to hi II A statement on the thc stand Is li now 1101 em emilo ilo ll ed as us lS u R newspaper r corrEspondent 3 He Jo has bas been heen In Boise liaIse for tOI some days was summoned by b tho the defense be Iule of r statements made by b hIm In a I book 1 by b a I company devoted to 10 the tho Interests lit of ot Hu Ho I I looked upon by hy tho defenso defense as 11 one ot the chief to prove proC a ney 11 on Oil tho purl part of ot tho the rine Ine Owners mid Ild others to exterminate the tho Western CSINI Federation of or Miners CLOSI CLOS FOR FOft DEFENSE The defense de I expects to conclude the the testimony this thin week Counsel for forthe the state fatale now ay say that their rebuttal evidence will vIII wi not nol bo ho lengthy They Thc expect ex ox tn to bring brim witnesses to show allow that Orchard was waR as nt itt It on the day of o tho t hr explosion at l tho Hunker Bunker nud Sullivan Sulon mine minI Mr Durrow Darrow in his open en lug ins said zaid that the tho defense show how tow that Harry flurry Orchard never leer wont vont to tho Bunker Hi Hill and Sullivan mile but hit that t lt ho he was pursuing his avocation ns as a I gamble al at lt the tho time of ot the tho ONlo lon In pursuance nf of this sn three witnesses have havo wor that Harry Horr Orchard wan amb hug 11 In lii II Mullen dulien on the tho day ot of the tho ex explosion e The Thc prosecution vIlt attack wi the testimony of these as It II IIO O llo to tho the very t heart ot of story Hory and It Il Is II vital ItaI IRI to the tho states stateR cayo cao lo In It show shaw that Orchard told the truth coo n nit nil ni Its Iti Io major particulars The Tho position of Ilie tb defense that the calling caling out of ot I ho the during the strikes In the tho Cripple Creek Creak district of Colorado Colordo was Wil unnecessary nod and was ian a 1 part ot or the tho con can to exterminate union ullon labor will nho Il o ho by tho the state In rebuttal wll witnesses SS R for fOl or tho tha have havo hlo fW sorn rn that at tUb tiro tl time the lie camo cale into the tho district and up to the time nf of the tho explosion I at lt tho the Independence depot pol the tha district r was WS entirely peace pence ful til til This opens up an nn opportunity lOT for the Ih state Itao to show hov that n a number of ot ns as and Ind murders had hod b en committed riming during the Iho early cony period of the tho strike mid nonunion met who rho ware h are of ot cRam again I It In Is r n n II alleged the has mis hiI evidence In II Irve to tn pho 1 I that ho the of oC a I of ot these nonunion minors fibers were discovered dl I OF Ol CASE The rhe closing of the Iha case ue will be c miNI filled with developments If It tho the t or ot both botti Bides mo uru good Is nn tiit of ot find sensational s it fI JI r oh ni Ii but bill bu I on Oil i Ines I provo to III he Without an n good foundation V Ith tho the opening of ot tho the trial today Mr 11 r Dm Datrow row for tOl the lilt doone c I to In the stand Friedman ho Ih Monographer her employed at nt tho the J D of ot lilt tho deice detec tive tte agency Friedman J III d by hi the Iho defense to lo expose the Pinker ton tn methods of ot dealing wIth wilh Western I of or Miners Miner I Friedman spent spout the tile half hour ot of n hl his a tuy on tho the this tilts In m from front BO so which ho hu h tys ays hu maZe mado of ot t white while In III time tho o K Un tin Mso Ilso Id three lattora said to A n been written by II Jamen Mc Me Pa of nt time tho Pinker tons In 11 the tini west und end time Iho records of ut for Cor H tim Ihl B state naked n to 10 the letters signed by Mr dr 11 but hul IUS refused I l hove not mUL decided whether to 10 otTer Orr r these tJelle letters In evidence Mr AIr and OItI white io I t do ito not lint Willi want I lo to appear I muni 1 tot for 01 tint Uio The fhe Ito prosecution alTered no In tn II tile Hid of Qt reports of II 10 o in mummy mallY of ot were r lo to UI lii Jur Jury by lIy till Mt WilY The object In Iii putting them In Iii was ullin tn in the Ihl testimony or given give II to 10 Iho lb effect that lust Ihn tha spits In lit the tho dif dlf 1 ull of ot hits F nf ot with to o dully t report r d was from Op OJ No Nil 4 A Q D It U Will wu u Denver June 29 Wl Will woi In III U ot PC relief to the tUv f 71 fi I Ii i 4 j F T s e JAMES PINKERTON DETECTIVE I Photographed J hoto l for fot the lime cw es In I miners minere In n lil hi h report No Ko o ti Mild some of o the thc men m 11 were asking If It lit lib thought the tho strike would be settled soon oon I f told them ho wrote that thal t I t nothing of ot n settlement lI or anything that would Indicate a tt settlement that the th strike would last a long time yet el also that I 1 believed tho the union would ouI have to give up hy by h next fall all It ir we die dlo pot not win by b that time Lime Now NIH that the convention In 5 over er 1 will tal personal charge of ot the tho roller relief work and Ind will carry out the In Instructions from Mr Cary Pit kerton korton manager about a IL week ago ngo In regard to cutting down the relief at IU much no nH fa to ns as 11 to cause dissat dissatisfaction and get et the men against thi union I T will Iii 11 put lt time the blame for not tho o men more as much at atI U ki UI kiI I can on W V D Haywood by thai thlu hiLt hiLtI 1 I am ant out ont his Instructions FROM FitO HO OPERATIVE NO O G 5 Tho The next two reports from room Oper Opel Operative No 5 S were detailed accounts of oC the proceedings at Ut the tile Western esl rn Fed Federation Federation of Miners convention which he attended n ed ns os n It delegate There was out of ot the In iii the pro proceeding e and no speeches of or an matory character Mr Darrow next read reports from Philander P 1 Halley BaIley known as Oper Operative alive No o 9 s They dated daled from tram Victor ictor Colo Cob during time the Creek strike One of ot these letters was w pure Iy ly formal detailing the Lime 01 ur U ura II n a union meeting The lime letters devel developed developed against the law and amid order ord r ruf ot of tho Iho us ns having been h on men inca mentioned mentioned by h the th speakers or interviews with members of ot the union Following Baileys reports clime camo those of ot an operative named Rolner Bainer In iii Cripple Creek declared under date late of ot o Sept Sent ti 1 1803 1003 that the tho miners claimed to havo huO all the best liest of ot It but hut unless I there was WEIS a L break brea k in the Iho Mine Owners association the tho operative thought their claims were doubtful that ho him beard no radIcal talk or ot threats from Crom time tho minors mIners and Iud that each miner acted as UR 0 a n committee cl of ot one to 10 silo ston nil all disputes and diSturbances The sol sal soldiers tIters diers und end seemed to 10 be lie growing groW big quite quit friendlY and many of the soldiers expressed sympathy for tor or the tho strikers IN JK I COAt COAL To show that lint time the Invaded the coal mining fields of Colorado where the Untied United Mine Workers of ot America controlled tho thu miners were acre read from operative No Na II It Smith The Tho convention Smith attended ct wn 1 Oi open to the tho public but he tie reported at length lell lh as to the tho routine proceedings LONDONER Mr tr Darrow I next read two lengthy re reports 1 reports ports from Pinkerton J 1 i N now superintendent In the Denver D The Tho reports were froth from Victor Colo Coin at the tho time of ot tho Iho Independence depot explosion June JUliE 6 1901 Londoner told graphically of ot the ih Intense excitement In tho tb CrIpple Creek district at nt this time lIm and the titu throats mado madl against the union I was wall made a n deputy n TiC nil soon us liS 1 t showed my amy HI face I r wrote anti and told laid to III kill any union man mall or sympathizer e who spoke lo to Inc me meTho The Tho operative added that at tho the time iliac of or bin wilting there was ian strong talk taik of 0 the tha lenders of ot the union from fromI the Iho I Ii o bull hull pen non and ami hang lug them I lien Th citizens demanded the thc resignation rl of ot Robertson Hobl tie lie declined They got cot n a OlO NIK Told put n It about his hl neck Ito wis Imi given jive minutes In lii which to Iu decide looked nt at atthe the tho mob Jilt Jin thou then tat Slit down own and iid wrote his hiM Roys nus ho 11 1 said I r know you OU have not IIO Ia ito tho drum drop on me time und and I 1 know hang lianI mo me If It J 1 1 dont donl U resign II n Londoners reports told ot or tho the speech mali mado by it C C seers tat of or the tha Owners association HAmlin bud less len than live JIlIn UIl H whon when tho tiring began There la is I no doubt that an all to 10 kill ki I I 1 I ho he added IOns it Its ono ot of tl u l Ills bit bl Am ED Ion Fort DEATH D ATU Tho Time wino out timid and 1 some Nome wore vere stationed on house housa tops tOilS Without n II request lo In they thoy to Urn 1111 Into Inlo Unto Union hull bull und continued until untila a 11 white flag II lilt was dl In III Union hull hal cove tt I 1 tics lire I bar bartola lit r tola rols of ot timid and u it 1 big bag supply nf of found IS 1 men killed 11 n itI t Victor Ictor Under data dale of ot June 29 0 1001 IDOl t ed rain Victor that I Ito t III In it u scorch of It I hut thu I II Union hall huh lie hail had found th Ih tile of ur tw macli 1111 11 On 1111 buck ot or cacti was a 11 cross Till it Land I J B nut told Is IN tho plan of lit 1 marking for tor Ju Jut JUst t beame 1 00 the tho luncheon recess wan true token Inken Mr began lo the leports or of A J H JJ who vImo of tit the union at III Colorado Cy City und who In tu charged by lIy tile Hie defense with liasIng n much toward lbs strike which lOll lad to 10 ml nil tile tho Cripple Creek Cre k dl 1 dis Cranes Crane reports report wora tore elm lm ply detailed nf tit hl 11 his dally daily his hili ron with tha thamon mon and lits hili iu to them In II hold out html wa win the tho strike van wac o p m rn t d |