Show Firm f t l fIG T I I l WI Family Quarrel Results in Death 01 of lien R n Haddock Formerly Third Precinct Constable Constable WAS PROTECTING HIS IllS DAUGHTER George Geor e F I Porter a n Young Man but Years of Age ARC Cause Of if the time Tragedy As Aa n a result rr ul of a quarrel with wih his son inlaw followed by a I desperate fight Hen lien R Haddock who for tor many years cars watt was constable of the Third precinct lied died last nl ht at nt this home 52 North Seventh West street from Injuries re received reo In the struggle E Porter 21 Ills Ils George DEAD MANS SON TALKS According to 10 Robert nobert Haddock the stead dead mans ton son lon he went vent ont over oer to the tho Porter Portor housa hu o anti found Porter stanch smash smashing stanchIng h ing timings things tight right and left heft ler George anti Ind Rosa HOln were ero quarreling over Oer a n stove stoe said he Rosa Hosl said It would not draw uhra and nn George Gcorge said It I would Fiman George smashed things up and mind threw a I lamp at nl my 1 to sister Papa Iaia lapa heard heart tho row anti and nn came camo running over o r Mamma was with him A i soon ROOn as itS I fattier father stuck his imis head hd In the tho door George grabbed him anti and anI threw him down daa and then mamma took a n hand In InI It I Mrs Irs Haddock told practically the tho same story as her hr son TAKES TAKEN TO ro TIlE THE TIE MORGUE Early this morning the remains of Haddock were wore removed to the under undertaking undertakIng taking parlors of William Toy In fa falor lor br Until an autopsy Is held the time au nu authorities thoriUM will wi Ibl not l t know Imol whether to charge Porter with murder or not AN OLD RESIDENT NT Haddock was n about 60 to years cn of ago al has han resided In this city for many litany years car He lie Je had imail hAi only one arm and Int for tor many years rear was constable In imm the Third Precinct MARRIAGE AND BRAWLS About Aholt 15 1 months AgO ngo Porter married daughter They got along alon well veIl wel enough tom for a n short horl time tle but then began gan quarreling Haddock did not nt like bike his and Ind they time hind had fre frequent quent lUent rows row rowl HADDOCKS FAMILY F I Haddock leaves a I wife and ant six chil years of age Is locked up UI In the tIme city jail Jol and all will wi probably be bo charged with murder His IR brother brothel Charles K E J Porter Pore Por ter In is also In custody mind and Ind will wi be he held as a n witness s In the case cata The Time trouble occurred about 10 last night nt at lt atthe tho the home of or George Georgo Porter which Is Just next door to 10 tho the Haddock home humn 1 shortly before time the trout trou trouble Last night short tou I ble ide occurred tIme the Porters Porter were vere packing their household goods gools preparatory to leaving beaving for tor Ogden where young Porter had secured employment on the South ceo ern Pacific railroad He lIe had previously been working for time the Oregon Short Line here but lost his Imis 11 Job Will e packing their goods good I Porter anti and Isis his hil be bc became became young wife haddocks Haddock daughter came Involved wie In a quarrel about the tho th drawing qualities of a n stove stoe It I Is II saM said that Porter became enraged and began b san breaking up the time furniture He lie smash smashed Is alleged ed eti a n and ond then timen It threw rl a I lamp at nt his hl wife cutting A n Adeep adeep deep gash In iii her head hend The woman Iash find Robert Haddock Son eon 01 ot t the dead i i ni man aman ran r to his father and tout told him that George la Is 11 trying to kill kil Row Ioa TO HIS IS DAUGHTERS RESCUE Mr Me Haddock ran to his hl daughters home and struck Porter In tho the face Then hOle rhel time the th two men grappled and fought Haddock who hind had only emily ani one ono hand was as no match tea for Porter forter who Is II a 1 powerful young fellow and Ind wow WI ns thrown to the tIme and choked While Porter was choking loor Haddock the tho wife wie en entered terell time the room and amid pulled Illet her law away awny from rol rota her husband huband DROVE PROM FROM I nO I TIm THE SCENE Porter then took his wife brother and atmil climbing Into an nn express wag in drove away avay to time the home of ot Porter mother on Second North between Fourth l and Fifth I West streets WALlOW WALKED HOME 10 1 TO DIE DI Haddock was able to walk to his home html but hit It was Wi evident that he hue WIS suffering great relt pain pail Ho Ito went to lied bed and his children worked over oer him for tor some santo time to relieve the time pain ho ito hI suffer suffered sU er ed In Iii his hla sIde aide Mrs Haddock ed for tor tho the police but hut as al they the tile ibid did not respond as us quickly as iii IS HIO sime thought they time the should hould she nho left lef time the for tor the tho pur lur potto 1010 of going to the time police pollee station Sue Rho also tried to Kd get It n a physician hy lelan hut but wax was unsuccessful Before imo returned her husband hU was lead dead Ho lie 10 did 1111 not live 10 livemore more than of an hour front from frol the time time of the light fight LIFE WAS S EXTINCT Sergeant Hers ant and 11 Officer lIve CIo went vent to tho the hoime at nt Mrs h Haddocks request and found the time man dead They he also 1110 tried to n get Iet u it but LUI It II vita nearly 3 this morning be before bl toro tore Dr Mayo Ino anti Acting Coroner Clark reached rea tIme the scene OFFICERS LOCATE Tho The at once started out to lo ho locate cAto cate Porter Portor They rhe found him nt sat lt isis his hl mothers home whore where he ito and antI wife had hll retired Hn hut 11 was WUI placed under tinder ar arrest rest anti and taken to the police station staton His Is Ill wIfe cried and 1111 tutu pleaded with wih tho time 01 erR cots not to take her imer husband amid III Him simo roundly abused her h r father for or Interior Ing 11 In the tho melee She was not then therm thel In Informed orated formed of her he fathers athes death Porters brother was taken to the tho station also MEAN IMN TO 0 KILL Just being helm locked up lP tho the oil 01 cars eels told Porter that Haddock wIts wax WIH dead Ho lIe professed R 1 great surprise but bUI was perfectly cubit calm cAhl Well you 01 cant say Hay la I Intended to kill him ho he I lIon ubon see seo R O Oho how ho I could have isae hlo killed 11 him Ho lie le canto camo camoIn cantoIn In anti attacked 1 me ama I auth 1111 I choked him himI n a I little bit was Wi glad 1111 to got get Iet out of the mess when the old lady l lh piled lulled pled on me le leno HOW no TROUBLE STARTED Tho Time way WA tho the trouble started was vas 1118 like Ik this timis I 1 picked up all an nn old guitar that 1 thought was as not nt worth moving smashed It I A of It mit Ht my 1 lit on un time the head and cut her imor n a lit Ill little l tie tle Then tho he t old man 1111 camo en mao en ani over tc and cause cunio nt itt II me lime I grubbed him tho time neck In a I strangle hold and ama choked chinked him hint a I little lite throw him to 10 the tl hoer 1001 Then the time old lady bail Jumped on both of us 1 I b had no 10 Idea of hurting hurling the tho badly old Injured 11 did not know ho iso wax was WIH tiron dren The rhe he latter later are Mrs Rosanna no annn Porter aged 23 aged 17 who IH is employed nger at lt Ida Robert Ho rt 15 May II 13 John Lee Iel 10 and 8 S years CIt I a |