| OCR Text |
Show PAGE FOUR 1972 Tuesday! September THE DAILY RECORD ' Third District Court Calendar In The Supreme Court Of The State Of Utah U.C.A. 1953, construing a Btatute substantially similar to Section found that it could not reasonably be inferred from the language that the legislature intended the negligence of the minor to be imputed to the owner so as to constitute a bar to the owner's recovery in an action by him against a negligent third party, i. e. , the provisions had not altered the dommon law rule respecting a bailor's right to recover from a negligent third person and created a general agency. The Maine court observed that the statute under consideration concerned itself solely with minors under eighteen, as bailees, a group almost uniformly impecunious; and the. statute, as promulgated, was a remedy fashioned to give financial relief to those who sustained danqage by. the negligent operation of a minor driver. 41-2-- 22, Robert Crofts & and Bruce Coke vs Genealogical Index Hal Hlntze & Lynn Foster vs (Jury) Bernlece M. vs Otto H. Vanderberg G.D.Hunt & Harry Fryatt Pettit Rex Hanson 198198 - Arles rf. Hansen vs the court In Continental Auto Lease Corporation v. Campbell between imputed negligence and imobserved that there was a distinction puted contributory negligence; the effect of the former is to broaden liability, while the effect of the latter is to narrow it. The court stated that the enactment under consideration expressed the policy that one injured by the negligent operation of a motor vehicle should have recourse to a financially responsible defendant. The owner of the vehicle is the obvious candidate, for he can easily carry insurance to cover the risk. However, this legislative policy to broaden liability for the protection of an injured plaintiff gives no support to the doctrine of imputed contributory negligence which narrows the liability of a negligent defendant to a plaintiff, who is innocent of actual negligence. 1 5 Vickie Lee B. L. 199949 199534 Erickson (Jury) !Brian 201192 201193 vs United Equities, Inc Robert Merrill & John Anderson 179513 - Joseph E. Jenkins vs Russ Wallace Roofing 199654 Committee Comment - Senate. 11. Ky. , 203 S. W.2d 165, 168, 1 69 (1956). 12. Maine, 140 A. 2d 730 (1958). 13. Delaware, 99 A. 2d 356 (1953). & R. Sums ion Rd Comm vs Heber Valley Milk John Evans & Win. O' Connor and Rich su'd Bell G. Juanita Lola Jones Barbara J.Plckerlng Macfarlane,J. & L.L. Sumne- r- Don C. Moon, etal vs Brian Culver, etal Nolan OlBen & W. Bennett 189057 - Gerald Ames, vs (Jury) Kirk David L.R. Larson & D. Winder - 147055 Farrar Ralph vs Seagull Investment vs Ray Hnith L. Beasley & Ronald Barker zuiffo - Wasatch dhemical Co vs l$b724 - karcella Finlay vs (Jury) 14. 19 N. Y. 2d 350, 280 N. Y. S. 2d 123, 227 N. E. 2d 28, 29 (1967). 15. Also see Jacobsen v. Dailey, 228 Minn. 201, 36 N. W. 2d 711, 11 A.L.R. 2d 1429 (1949); Universal Underwriters Insurance Co. v. Hoxie, 375 Mich. 102, 133 N.W. 2d 167 (1965); White v. Yup, 85 Nev. 527, 458 P. 2d 527 (1969); McMartin v. Saemisch, Iowa, 116N. W. 2d 491 (1962). - vs (Jury) vs William E. Bowen Blaine Davis & Robert Anderson 182475 - Acord & Harris Const, - State of Utah & W. Wadsworth Mark P. Rasmussen - Quentin Grady Glen Rlchman & M. Lybbert John Pearce & Thomas Puffin 196972 - Mt. States Tel Elliott Pratt Dart. Jr. vs (jury) Garrett Howard V. Murphy vs (Jury) (Jury) vs 9. 152 Cal. App. 2d 371 , 313 P. 2d 86 (1957). 10. See West's Annotated California Code, Vehicle, Sec. 17150, Legislative - Della 201816 Calvin Bosse,etc Edward McDonough & Ray Berry - Brown Fowler Monday, September 11,1972 19989O - Elmer Stahle 182993 , M. Wm. Lawrence Wednesday, September 6,1972 206202 - Gendex Corp H. Guyman Robert Maack & L.E. Midgley Ben Bagley A Don Blackham Magneslc Corpn Richard Carling Thursday, September 7.1972 206572 - Alva Fairbourn vs the instant action, the reasoning in the cited cases impels the concluU.C.A. U.C.A. 1953, nor Section 41 sion that neither Section 41 1953, requires that the contributory negligence of the minor driver should be imputed to the designated responsible person in his action against a negligent third party. These statutes were designed solely to protect innocent third parties from the negligence of a minor driver by providing financial responsibility; there are no provisions therein that may be reasonably construed to deny an owner the right to recover for a wrong done to him. This case is reversed and remanded for a new trial wherein the negligence of defendant's agent, if any, and the damages sustained may be determined. Costs are awarded to plaintiffs. In 22, Salt Robert vs McRae - 34891 T.Blonquist M. Adams Lake & City D. Slagle Hartwest Productions vs - Mid Utah and Earl Sp afford 199801 - j&ate of Utah.Rd vs June vs Sandy City Corpn M.M.Nebeker & R. Crofts 198452 - Don C. Holladay Stephan N. PutnamF.- B.McConkle & B. Tanner - 201964 & Comm JYancis Nielson - 161277 (Jury) Broadcasting & G. Rlchman Service Reed L. " vs James E.Debenham Big Horn Nat. Gas L.V. Summerhays & Wm. Cayias Leland Ford & V. Sagers 196803 - Gerald B. Walker vs Byron Laddie Shaver, 20 Capri 25 Legal age to jjliard, (27)- - Wi 11 isms Villa t.ioL Massey Foley, Prairie Village, legal age to Joan Morris, 1958 Brownsing Ave, legal age Brian Conway Gough, 203 Westminster Ave (24) to Linda May Tavorian, 3026 Rainer (21) Ronald Michael Hlndmarsh,1177 Gillespie Ave (20) to Sandra Jo Mayer 1261 E. 6200 So. Sandy (19) Glen Reed Dial, 267 No. 7th West (21) to Vicki Lee Civ ish, 423 Pleasant Ct. (21) Tyrrell Harman Toone, 212 LD3 HOSPITAL Mr. and Mrs. W, Ra- 91 ST. MARK S HOSPITAL to. and Mrs. Wade, 2759 Thunderbird Dr. son Jay Lee, Grant s- - Loveridge 3351 Beehive St. son WEST Reinhard-.Erich-berger- COTTONWOOD HOSPITAL Mr, and Mrs. Gregory M.Barr-o6370 Ashwood Dr. daughter Mr. and Mrs. Dennis C. Hansen 2479 Camelback Rd, daughter Mr. and Mrs. Michael R, Keener 2796 S, State St. daughter to, and Mrs, Jeff R, Peterson 1014 E, 5645 So. daughter to. and Mrs. Phillip Evans, 763 E. 9th So. son Mr. and Mrs, Douglas E. Man- son, 322 Alta View Dr. son w, Raymond Duane Peterson, 446 Adams St. (21) to Sharon Alle-n- e Creenwall 6820 Virginia Hills Dr. (21) Blaine Kendall Smith, 1361 Blaine Ave (21) to Rebecca Sweeten 2207 So. 2200 E. (21) Mark Evan Vrancs, 344 Coats -(23) to Diane J. Lane, 176 C St. (25) SOUTH Richard Hyrum Clark, 2751 Grandview Clr (21) to Christine Stacye Anderson, 2583 Lake Sr. (21) DAVIS COMMUNITY Mr. and Mrs. Donald L. Fernel-iu- s 752 W, 2175 So. Woods Cross son Mr. and Mrs. John R. Calder 2501 So. 450 E. Bountiful, son Douglas Gale Mortensen, 1230 So, 13th So. (22) to Victoria Lynne Allen, 700 Northcrest (22) to. and Mrs. Dennis O'Keefe 320 E. 100 So. Centerville, son LEGAL SIZED BINDERS perfect for all legal size documents, court exhibits, etc. 2 $3.45; 40: $3.00; $3.75; 10-1$3.65; 20-3Provo Lake and (.Salt only) 7 ROBERT..SYKES, 1218 3rd AVE., SLC, rings, Third District Court 9: 9: 363-909- Tuesday, September 5.1972 Tuesday, September 5 1972 202725 - Myrine Boatman vs (Jury) Evelyn S. Davis Gary Frank & Don Hansen L. E. Midgley & D. L. King 200547 - Gregory J.Moncrief vs (strike) Pacific Union Wm. Bradford & - David vs R.R. N.Kettner K. Passey Cotro-Man- es vs (jury) Beneficial Standard Robert Moore & Jay Jensen 201855 - United Pac. ins. Co vs Dewayne E. Iverson Robert Bayle & Rex Lewis Irene Warr 202759 - Mildred Blanke vs Craig Kemp, Granite School Nick Colessides Miller 203446 - & Buehner Robert slock Co. vs Hart Investment Co. Thomas Puffin & R. Walker 202921 - Jeannette E.Hurd vs Salt John Lowe Lake City Roger Cutler and C. Keith Rooker 201764 - Mac Zamora & vs Lorry K. Walton David Dee & Mont McDowell 2C335? 193780 - James D. Kimberly vs State of Utah Robert Miller & M.Iybbert David Slagle. L. L. Sumnerhajys Forgery D. Lease, Inc. A R M A Corp Jos Henrold P.CotroManes & 200625 - State of Utah,Rd Conm vs Clifton Hedgepeth S. Ward W. R. 198708 1972 Clyde G. Ferguson John Ellett & J. Hill 24445 C. Nemelka - Fidelity Indus. Cr. vs Frank Carley " & - Carrol Puts on A. vs Sharon M. Kent Chamberlain & J. Pearce 201340 - James H. Francis vs Michael Harris Del Rowe & Jackson Howard 201394 - Burke vs L.Bridwell Mick Colonna J.F. Allred 206173 & etal C. Sessions - Herbert B. Maw vs William R. Porritt Richard Walker & Nolan Olsen 199743 - Lydia Salazar vs ' Lee Montoya Grant Kesler 1d3656 & G.D.Hunt - Continental Thrift vs Attempted Gr. Larceny FhiUip Thomas Tan jack Grand Larceny G.W. Robbins Robert Moody, Richard Moffat Sam Hill R.VanSciver & - Peter Rayner vs Robert J. Walters Alan Met os 201743 Mann Burg 2nd Deg & Grand Larceny vs Stanley Robles, dba G. L. Rudd 194682 ,Wednesday, September 6,1972 24433 - Reid Allen anith Grand Larceny L. Brown 23990 - Allen L. Murie Grand Larceny S. J. Hatch 24452 - Rick May and lYederick Fridy, - September 8. 195564 Rhode Leroy Axland & toller Ben Spence 24495 - Fredrick Stevenson Shank, Jr. vs (jury) Joyce Christensen Allan Larson & W, Ashworth vs Bob WiUiam Forgery vs(jury) L. L. Summerhays 201854 - Master - 24323 Grant Kesler & G. Ross 19857 - Walter E. Mullins Ralph M. Evans Robert Bayle & L. Foster 200999 - Robert 0. Pusey Calendar P. daughter 4980 So Don Glenn J. Hatch & L. Long 19978 - Linda Bywater S. Ignacio Salazar Riverton City & W. Bennett 199468 - June 3. Cornia , Third District Court Criminal Cases vs vs HOSPITAL Mr. and Mrs. 3396 Tottenham Ct B.R. Parkinson & G.Hunt and Nolan Olson 203384 - Doris Raddatz Lake, daughter Mr. and Mrs. Steven Siminson 2919 Morningside Dr. daughter Mr. and Mrs. Elwood VALLEY Grant Donald Beck 5084 So. 4620 W. Kearns (24) to vllle Mr. and Mrs. RLchard D. Olsen 400 No. 225 E. North Salt 203252 (19) to Vicki Lee Smith, 58 W. 3rd No. (24) Cline, Stanley to. and Mrs, ville,son mona Ave Deborah Lynne 938 E. (19) Brent Maxfield 3125 East, daughter Mr. and Mrs. David M. Evans Jr. 1922 E. h5th So. daughter Mr. and Mrs. Gordon Jolley 10 Villa Capri, No.3, Midvale , daughter Mr, and Mrs. Frank J. Jamnik 310 E. 630 So. Murray, son Mr. and Mrs. Val C. Gatehouse 517 No. 8th West, No. 1, so Mr and Mrs. Robert F.Finn 224 Medical Plaza So.U of U son Mr. and Mrs. David C. Cardenas, 1152 Navajo, daughter 3-- So Paul J. Frampton Births Marriage Licenses L. Brown Ii44b2 - John Val ace Grand Larceny D. Brown Friday, September 8. 1972 23961 - Kent Davenport Burglary Galen Ross 24453 - Tern & Gr, Larceny Jaramnio Rudolph Gonzales Burg 2nd Deg & Gr. Larceny Nebeker 24l64 - Bryan M. Walton Following too close causing accident M. H. J. Knowlt on Escape ftran State Prison J. Allen 24275 - Lawrence P. Leary Bastardy LeRoy Manchego |
