OCR Text |
Show THE DAILY EECOED FACE FOUR In The Supreme Court Of The State Of Utah him was initiated by a procedure criminal in form, while other putative fathers similarly situated were served by the less severe civil process. The courts have ascribed to the arrest provisions of bastardy statutes as for security purposes, but this factor does not alter the proceedings from a civil to a criminal status because the object of this remedial legislation is not punishment by fine or imprisonment but a judgment compelling support. The State has granted to the mother or pregnant woman two alternative remedies. A "remedy" is defined as the means authorised by law to be employed in preserving or enforcing a civil right; it is the. procedure by which 4. 9B U.L.A., Uniform Act on Paternity, J 17, p. 528. 5. McCoy v. Severson, 118 Utah 502, 508 222 P. 2d 1058 (1950). 6. Pelak v. Karpa, 146 Conn. 370, 151 A. 2d 333, 335 (1959); State v. Mottet, 73 Wash. 2d 114, 437 P.2d 187, 188 (1968). relief is obtained. In State v. Preston MONDAY, JANUARY 31, 1972 OTC QUOTES $12,000.00 Residence, rough basement, carport, Lot. 43 White City 14, Carl R. Ohran Inc. 1198 E. Turquoise Way bldr. same $12,000.00 Residence, rough basement, carport. Lot 45, White City 14, Carl R. Ohran Inc. 10090 S. Marble Street bldr. same $10,000.00 Residence, rough basement, garage, Lot 4 Paulson Acres 2, Mahonri Faber, 1341 West 6235 S. bldr. Faber Const. ' the court explained: $12,355.00 Residence, rough basement, carport, Lot 365 Skyblue Acres 3, Tierra Construction 270 E. 9th S. bldr. S. W. Pederson The cause of action itself is distinguishable from the form it assumes in its prosecution in the courts. The facts constitute the cause of action, and the legal form used to enforce the action is the remedy. . . . ... In Arizona Copper Co. v. Hammer, the State of Arizona had provided injured workmen with three alternative remedies; the employers asserted that this system denied them equal protection of the laws because it conferred upon the employee a free choice among several remedies. The court rejected this argument and responded that an election of remedies is an option very frequently given by the law to a person entitled to an action; an option normally exercised to the claimant's own advantage as a matter of $12,353.00 Residence, rough basement. Lot 307 Skyblue Acres 3, Tierra Construction 4973 Vaileyview Drive, bldr. S. W. Pederson In the instant action, there is a rational basis to support the legislative determination that an unmarried pregnant woman may deem herself insecure and desire a means whereby she can be assured of the appearance of tiie putative father at the trial. The legislature has preserved this remedy for her benefit, but it has also granted her an alternative remedy if she prefers to proceed under the Paternity Act. These two alternative remedies do not deny defendant the equal protection of the law. Construction 4927 Valley View Drive, Bldr. S. W. Pederson course. In the area of economics and social welfare, a State does not violate the Equal Protection Clause merely because the classifications made by its laws are imperfect. If the classification has some "reasonable basis" it does not offend the Constitution simply because the classification "is not made with mathematical nicety or because in practice it results in some inequality. " Citation "The problems of government are practical ones and may justify, if they do not require, rough accommodations - illogical, it may be, and unscienCitation "A statutory discrimination vdll not be set tific. aside if any state of facts reasonably may be conceived to justify it. " Citation $12,355.00 Residence, rough basement, carport, Lot 302 Skyblue Acres 3, Tierra Residence, $12,000.00 58 Lot Spring Valley carport, Center Building 2, Valley 2332 Edgeware Lane, bldr. same $3,359.00 Commercial Unit 38, Bldg. 6 K, finish baths, hall, wardrobe, bedroom, Richard Prows, 4960 S. 900 E. Bldr. same Commercial Unit $738.00 46, Bldg. 9B, Remodel fireplace, Richard 11 Circle, bldr. same b err in its rulings in the instant action; this case is remanded for further proceedings. The trial court did not WE CONCUR: $17,000.00 Residence, Lot 91, Harwarden 5, rough basement, carport, Midwest Construction 4354 Harwarden Circle, bldr. same R. L. Tuckett, Justice F. Henri Henriod, Justice $500.00 Demolish 1 unit Jack C. Brown, 1927 West 6200 South, Bldr. same A. H. J. Allan Crockett, Justice $20,800.00 Residence, partly finished basement, attached double garage. Lot 585 Willow Creek 1, Grant Hills 8397 Willow Creek Drive, Bldr. G & M Enterprises 7. 36A Words and Phrases, Remedy, pp. 552-55- 7. 8. 173 Ohio St. 203, 181 N. E. 2d 31, 36 (1962). 9. 250 U.S. 400, 430-4332 S. Ct. 553, 63 L. Ed. 1058, 1071 (1918). 10. Dandridgev. Williams, 397 U.S. 471, 485-48- 6, 90 S. Ct. 1153, 25 L. Ed. 2d 491 (1970). 1, . County Building Permits Tierra Const. 4227 Bluejay Street, bldr. S. W. Pederson $12,787.00 Residence, Lot 393 Skyblue Acres 3, Tierra Const. 4225 Whipoorwhil Street, bldr. same $12,787.00 Residence, Lot 371 Skyblue Acres 3, Tierra Const. 4242 Whipoorwhil Street, bldr. S. W. Pederson Demolition Commercial store State Road Commission 66 E. 3300 S. Bateman Construction $13,000.00 Residence, rough basement, storage. Lot 28, Maple Meadows, Practical Dwellings, 2506 W. Oriole Way, Bldr. same $13,000.00 Residence, rough basement, attached carport. Lot 86, Valley Downs '5, Flyco Land Dev. 4228 W. Wendy Ave. bldr. same $13,000.00 Residence, rough basement, storage, Lot 36 Maple Meadows, Practical Dwellings 3206 S. Mockingbird Way, bldr. same $14,000.00 Residence, rough basement, attached carport. Lot 73 Valley Dovwis 5, Flyco Land and Dev. 2954 S. Wendy Circle, bldr. same $14,000.00 Residence, rough $15,000.00 Residence, rough basement, attached garage. Lot 36 Fairlane Heights Maple Meadows '4, James Quintana 4246 Falcon Street, bldr. Discovery Home Inc. Residence, rough basement, storage, Lot 17, Maple Meadows Practical Dwellings 3263 S. Mockingbird Way, bldr. same $13,000.00 $14,000.00 Residence, finish 2 bedrooms basement, Practical Dwellings 2512 W. 3185 S. Starling, Bldr. same, Lot 2 basement, storage, Lot 3, Maple Meadows, Practical Dwellings 2502 W. 3185 S. Starling, bldr. same Demolition one house. State Road Commission 2293 W. 3500 Bateman Equip. Demolition one house, 53 W. 3300 S. State Road Commission Bateman Construction $18,950.00 Residence, rough basement, attached double garage. Lot 588 Willow Creek 1, Grant D. Hills, 843S. Willo Creek Dr. Bldr. G & M Enterprises Commercial $55,000.00 Office Bldg, rough basement, Gordon Christensen, 1348 E. 3300 S. Bldr. Triangle Const. $3,000.00 Remodel Kitchen William A. Atkin, 2469 E. Neff Lane, Bldr. Olympia Kitchen Center ... on the Go! THINK . . . $12,000.00 Residence, rough basement, Lot 42, White City 14, Carl R. Ohran Inc. 1190 E. Turquoise Way, bldr. $35,000.00 residence, finished basement, attached garage. Lot 14, Mt. Olympus Cove 6, Milton Muir Inc. 4448 Cove Crest Street, bldr. same . Residence, Lot 109, Harwarden 5, rough basement, garage, Midwest Construction 435 Hawarden It is enough that a solid foundation for the regulation be found in the State's legitimate interest. . . . $12,787.00 Residence, Lot 358 Skyblue Acres '3, S. $18,950.00 ... can then ACT with the NEW XORKLCO 88 PORTABLE IDEA MACHINE DICTATING LIGHTWEIGHT VISUAL INDEXING BUILT-IMICROPHONE FULL-FEATURE- A D N same $11,000.00- Residence, rough' basement, carport, Lot 44, White City $13, Carl R. Ohran Inc. 1208 E. Turquoise Way, - & Bldr. same KEY $11,000.00 Residence, rough basement, carport, Lot 49, White City 14, Carl R. Ohran Inc. 10075 S. Marble Street bldr. same BUSINESS MACHINES, INC. 21 KELSEY AVE. SALT LAKE CITY . UTAH 84110 TELEPHONE t 'v Prows 4960 900 E. Bldr. same . . . the Fourteenth Amendment gives the federal courts no power to impose upon the States their views of what constitutes wise economic or social policy. Ellett, Justice SALT LAKE CITY County Building Permits (801) 322-228- 4 si v |