OCR Text |
Show THURSDAY. ADCUST r:u r,, 1171 DAILY RECORD V.E In The Supreme Courl OfTIm Siaie ()i I tf U.v 1 ah I ons " v , ;t . iourl . - 'n, m utility for the purpose of taxation is ni' i - rca.-.ou.il.li- The decision of the court below is .ifi -- .ia ,tr, vi.'i- - i V I, i h i 't; ,::r 'T. m r . - , Oi L 1 t'nntiniu-- FIVE 'er . .Li I hers i ' . i ; ilba oTters , t' .74 . r, ntty '!n WE CONCUR: A. il. lil 1 1.M.I '; .1 , st - , 1 'tii rcu s C, . .y 1 r Qt r ft;, . M:im. .331, Ml N. h . 2'JO; Walla Walla l .Cm S.Ct. 77; Eli; v. Walla Walla U.S. I, .11, Co., le.-tCo. v. 150 it. k Milwaukee E. 189; v. 64S. N.C. 407, Bank, City hn:i-sauke... i iv"A rishin hi rl Railroad Com. , 153 Wis. 59?, 142 N.W. 14 N. J. 186, 101 A. 2d 855, 47 A. . . .d 17 MleadinMe 4), If. Am. Jur. 2d, p. 730, 5 7. 3t-- ! K hi : !: 2. Illinois Bell Tel. Co. v. A'-'- s, III, (yn.on n C.h ."is' Co. , Cu of the Justices, H4N.II. 559, 149 A. 321; Salt I 34 Utah 38, 95 P. 523. St. Paul v. St. Paul City Ry.Co. 7(3 , 43 17?. Watt-- tr 7:.., i1 . r-- Mil l 11 t vcf, , 3L ' i dv-soi- been for be . rfevtiy m,- '.m - I . : . :i . ' .i.-- v. ' ! . - ' ' I'Y i n -l h.a- - 1 d. "- ... c- . - ; K 1 1 b- A-- -. . - . - '.ii very ,f .. . ... - . -- ( ; 1 : ; ' ' ; f i , ; -p ; .a , r- : t f If-- , ' '.Vc-ve, - neckaf y . . r ro-ir- i - ;l : .:i , ts. un t - , t i v - be a condition that would seen: .o b- - .iot requiring height of poles, placement (,i tr;.n: . facilities, safety measures and t!.'- ' . ni i v : . atirns fur sncc. .11-- fl '. i t m ruv, ' ' ! i ' ri. r-- atty -- . :e . ; a 'i'--; .1 .. n - CfJlIII- pp-f- ; 1 ,i- That the powers of the city are strictlv limited to tVsose lit rlieo expressly granted, to those lunw-- :;i .u i v or and to those e in or incident to the powers expresslv rnr.teo, of the corporaessential to the declared obiecls mh: purposes S I bl in v. Tit this law state. akp is settled utcr, tion, Utah 53 3, 2 lb V. 234. - :ar d! ; : d.cs, "tty I i'n .;) rv.Rs . . vs. i. . viccsj mm , . oovery . I . itEf.'E r.rr vices; . iiv , : it i " ' . 1 ; l " C-- ; ' . ;r r ; - I1. J "ft ; ! m - l ovary ' : lot.- v. Robins. n open Me, ' : r t . . !" -- . - . . - vires f1. "c.vrry .... 1; F . 3 i i.. , . ip r 3 : "in lieu" amount. . en.ck ; t i r i I services t , . j e'1 The only question, as i i: e would .ui own I think our cases " pro- Cio:,, perfectly legal "in - a doctrine we havin the city, implied e:-quire but a few cases to be rep'-rteA in as any place else succinctly stated where we said: i . b. ; -.i' - u u; i I '1' c.'vcry , x i.. : a-- "s 1 4, ! i r, t d ;u 5 3, as atn-.-f U.C.A. n !'.- C v.i i:.:,s i;. that cities Ch. 28, Sec. 1, provides n.ay idectr.c !:cnt w.ir.--:- , tenance and operation by others' o; "a is v s i: ant ho ria! ion telephone lines" etc. Invariably ar.u ccv.' :.ii.,.t:d ..in a contract, with terms and conditions. i'1 a : ;u of those conditions legally could be j pri tae perce: a nicii as iou.il of oi.e substitute, resst'n, taxes, or, gross sales "in lieu" v. .Id nroteetua against arbiis synonymous with "taxes," - ail ot would trary increase under Art. I, Set. 10, f tin I. S. Cuii ititution. t:This ' 10-8-1- t i':,n"KhCfJc iim iv. .d- h; i: : - . : V'-- . " r.ii" - - r n d-- y 1 I . to enter tV.o - C 'Y I I ' I i . prv'-u- i J-- . . i in,' 5s. ;c . v .t v.' r that the city "in the absence of .xpre-.- a: edes of taxation. not its contract away power ture, may if the leg'shitu n- - giw s it I:. at could contract away its power 3 power. Such a conclusion pretty clearly is i,;fie .t il in 17 A. I.. I1.. 25, and that such contracts are eno', et seq. and the cases therein cited, ' able under Art. I, Sec. 10, of th U. S. Co ,s: ':: nsr' f o .! ntir-isobhu-the laws against iir.pjirina : .ry a i : a u 1 i ' : f- t- , :e 1 Title d . 'i respectfull it the power, the contracts with these .:.i;i.Es c. n o valid, except for the city's gratuity that they ouid not c period of time, - but that is ..!. it no'u' 1 H , rovry i'!i c . . i.a.d i ! HENRIOD, Justice: (Dissenting) The only point then, is whether Ogdt-'.L the contract. The main opinion'" w:u n . and that is the law of this can" and with which I disacree as evidenced b thix power under the statute for the follow: ,e re i r. .' 7f Oj "t f i. . . - At ou-c- . I VolCF r ! j n, 1 I 1 'waren, . , - , if-- 1 tn., (i ' ' . h.-t- T i , ; 1. JE rp'i tract; i , 1 Ji.lity AtTH F , ; i. . r e.: ; y s The decision in the instant .t .i i aj. :'l .i m-- atirai- t I r m r i II IB. ! . o t,V MJIi'--, 'r.; U - V- : . r tm i'rs t i ' ar.v - d. 'VI. ': ; specified tiine. i.c-.new business and the "percentage f qr.s-attractive one for those who might have risK. anii,'.; Besides, it appears to this writer that I'nTcnbaui in.'1 for - .m . . - L I .City 3n); . Ic ; Ik W S!c.ns,.-- ut.rp-cute- to min' d fit i n , i. Allred, l'lUm1 ;. 2d .: rTrHER , 'ael.- - in tin- F r 11.ni i. X '.. ntfs r s !.;: I'.'u , ta n , n m-- . ' . , i w : . t i ' .in' M , .i pa ' l Vmy. 11 rt c t' d'1-- ' rni.tr ii u tiisseiit mg pmi m t Mr. , ; 1. I t il tf, IP Credit S335.S5 v os dhn ' . a Qual- tMl'LA . tc . ' - ..ei Tire & Diet. uF.trilC H:!1FFEN- -'. ' In' : r- ; : Henriod. ..-- ' r I' -." : . I USE THE DAILY RECORD FOn YOUR LEGAL NOTICES or-.w- 'Mbs . t; ..... dit .2 A Credit . l1 vs' Tu-l- ,''f r (.1 1 l i j ; f ifneurs " I "a reCUi re lb and in Inod fa ll.. reverse this case and , - r tun IT 1 in I so-cdle- Callister, C. J. v ;. . . ul il live up to their terms strictly i. t.t c.:. Urn ..d-:- '-. would 'f i v promises of municipalities are not ':l.h !' written. The largest city in this state has a good faith by joining Ogden with hr'-but at all, simply "amicus curiae" brief I . i ities o r m be r.; Inn i np now must realize th.n ment may prove fruitless and perhaiis a 1":"K hesitation on the pa rt of cities, when the former an r , T ( l L . ;i - . 350 (1968). 2. 77 Utah 168, 242 i 317 P. 2d 597 (1957); S. i . o n..v. : illegal. This sort ot umlaieracv m and breeds suspicion in the minds :i ih.e T' to do business with public nffii. i.d s 1. It is interesting to tmte that this court in 1888 wherein Salt ake City ag r. Building and grounds forever, in S. .C'h racit - . ' i when it deemed it convenient, sayirg In k, 5. e4 -- Utah's 'u'on.iii.j a 3it i i . . - Itltr. 'lie .tpVI M t . ..: u 7 Diet, V. u bSTF-ic- - ritr. -, |