OCR Text |
Show f T TUESDAY, JUNE 8, 1971 Page Seven THE DAILY RECORD thus made erratic drivers. In sum, the "helmet law" Impresses me as being at least 95 per cent for the protection of the motorcyclist (which may be a good thing but it is his own business), with the rest of the effect, and a very minimal part, being for the protection of the public. New Actions Murray City Court If the conclusion is to be based upon the possibility that they may become hospitalized, or on welfare, that opens a wide door indeed to paternalistic controls over innumerable aspects of human conduct as to what may or may not be 52095 51971- - ' rr It is well to reflect that history from ancient to modern times is dotted with examples of governments which have extended their controls until they have "controlled" themselves into decay and out of existence. As long ago as ancient Rome, the wise man, Tacitus, declared: 51986- 3. See cases cited in footnote j2 of main opinion. 4. American Motorcycle Ass'n v. Davids, 158 N.W. 2d 72 (1968) Michigan; Illinois v. Fries, 250 N. E. 2d 149 (1969) Illinois; State v. Betts, 252 N. E. 2d 966 (1969) Ohio. NIELSEN- i 51977- 51979- A 51962- - Interstate L. PATRICIA A 1223.65 to Coll act lone v. 1124.90 5202- 4- Knight AQuetaant Bumsu ve. 1411.21 to pltf. Collections vs. HELEN JOHNSONi 1370.15 to - 1192.70 to pltf. Certified dm 5199- B- Inc.ve. .88 e. ARTIS R0SS AKA A. JOE to dtf. GARCIA 52051- vs. - Security Adjustment Bureau Inc .VS. .MORRIS KIDD A ARLENE KIDD AKA A. KIDD 854.38 to 8. R. LINDA - vs. R. LINDA D. TUELLER PA A GLADE A pltf. MIDC0 METAL PROOUCTS to pltf. INC. - Western Statee CredltAesn. H. MAASS 8255.65 to pltf. - Business Collection Agency A. ClATIS 862.27 to RICHARD pltf. 52076- - .femes C. Gilliam dba Doctors Merchants Cadlt vs. BERNELL A. TAYLORi Security Adjustment Bureau Inc. vs. 833267 to COWARD 52071- Security Adjustment Bif eau Inc. va. DIC 5204- 9- Meatem Statee CreditAsen. ve. RICHARD HEPMER 8267.69 topltf. 51999- 5200- 1- pltf. VERTINi 8565 .38 Security Adjuetment Bureau JOE GARCIA msnina MR L. REID I 5204- 2- Collections Recovery Bureau Inc. 5199- 5- Mery S. Fletcher dba Certified Collection Service ve. 831.65 to pltf. w.ir.ri -- REID AkA SHERRY wrvuA RONALD PAULSEN HEBER - MRS. SHERI Mery to pltf. 83065 CLADE ve. 5202- 5- Knight Adjustment Bureau ve. HAROLD MAGEE 123.15 to pltf. ANDERSONf 51992- - Mary S. FMeher Collection Service ve. 52001- M. pltf. S. Fletcher dba Certified Collection Service ve. LARRY C. ever-increasi- ng to Colledtione ve - Interstate 51991- - The statute here under consideration joins the onward march of the volumes of regulatory laws concerning which it is extremely questionable whether the benefits outweigh the burdens in the loss of personal freedoms and the expanding bureaucracy involved in their enforcement. I have interposed this dissent as an objection to what appears to be a limitless process of spreading tentacles of control into what ought to be matters of personal and private conduct. There ought to be a halt somewhere, and in my judgment this (All emphasis added.) law reaches that point. DBA KARMA K0MPANY 1133.90 u L. RICH I NS AKA DALLAS L. RICHENS, 192.00 to pltf. believe there are more instances of the abridgement of the freedom of the people by gradual and silent encroachments of those in power than by violent and sudden uaurpa--tion- s. CUERTS pltf. DALLAS 885 W. JANE DOE BASS0 to pltf. are ve. to pltf. 176.11 WHITNEY v 1153.96 to DIAMOND! PETE RAY 166.80 WENCRf Interetete Collections ve. 1120.00 to pltf 5198- 1- I Callister, R. A CHUCK Knight Adjustment Bureu KL0THIERS1 pltf. Collections BRYSON - Interetete STEVEN Again in the era of the origins of our own government, one of the most perceptive of the founding fathers, James Madison, wrote: ' - Interstate R. DALE 1464.09 to ARCHULETA THAOOEUS pltr. Coll act lone ve. SOLOMON AKA SHIRLENE SOLOMON most multiplied. ts - Interstate to Security Adjautment Bureau T. CE0RCE SHIRLENE LAKE AkA BETTY LOU BETTY CHARLES topltf. 52020- - to pltf. 51975- 9- Inc.ve. Knight Adjustment Bureau vs. E. A KATHERINE FERRO! 1711.85 JOSEPH see how this court's decision can take much comfort in mere a to reference "greater number" of jurisdictions as giving it support. Considof erations legal concept, reasoning and policy should carry much more weight. This statute is a good example of the continuous process of imposing ever more limitations upon individual freedoms. This results from the combined bureaucratic and legislative ingenuity discovering practically everything everyone does that can be regulated, then implementing it with the imposition of multifarious duties, applications, specifications, procedures, inspections and fees. Howso-- I ever necessary this may be in certain phases of our complex society, caution and restraint should be exercised not to destroy the spirit of individual liberty which has nurtured the initiative and enterprise which created the whole structure and upon which its continuance depends. Personal freedom should be given prefer-- ! ence, except only where there is some compelling, or at least preponderant reason to restrict it for the common good. When the government is most corrupt, the laws 5200- Security Adjustment Bureau 1156.25 LAKEi Asss C. Cillismdbm Doctors Merchants Credit ft. ARTHUR L, KIMBALL 110.70 tOfttr. al- 2- Inc. va. A I do not , 5200- CAROLYN 52158- - good for one's individual health, morals or safety. The difficulty is that if the obliteration of individual rights is permissible whenever there is any possibility, even indirect or remote, of injury to the public, then the line of demarcation as to the permissible intrusions of law, and its implementing functionaries, into conduct which should be one's private and personal concern becomes blurred most to the vanishing point. Knight Adjustment vs. 1243.42 to pltf. 0PCNSHAW to pltf. 8149.11 TUELLER AKA 860.04 to pltf. In the District Court, Probate Division, in and for Salt Lake County, State of Utah C. J. , concurs in the views expressed in the dissenting opinion of Mr. Justice Crockett. To footnote 3 of the main opinion, which adds a reference to this dissent, I make these comments: Once this court acquires jurisdiction, it decides the case on the merits on all issues. The parties so assumed and did not raise that point. Nor, according to their briefs, did either party regard the quoted colloquy as a "stipulation. " 5. - $33000. A Michael Ross. Jobs - $176,500. 5301 2A Bi Clyde A Lee Mast Obnst. Jobi Obnst SLC. Bt Sams S 935 of Unit Apt Bldg. New vs. J. 50149- JAMES WOOD to pitr. 50431- - ARTHlfl A pltf va. tA pltf. F to pltr. 51219- - 51868- - H. 838.50 to WATERS Devid E. Yocom vs. Inc. s. - BOBCO RICHARD 51779- - Inc. ve. to pltf. -- J Collection Sorvico, A KRISTINE MASCARENAS pltr. Craft Utah SUSAN DENNEY DBA A MCPHCRSN Silver Streak 1965 it: House Trailer to pltf. 52007- - CHERRVL 8191.B0 DESIGN for tiie sun ot Securit y Adjustment Bureau TNRHY MITCHELL AKA CHRISTY MITCHELL A CHRISTINE WILLIAMS to-w- $80.08 it: v AMARILYN HUDMAN1 to A.D. 19 71 , pltf. - Knight Adjustment at nine 5209- 2- Knight Adjustment Bureau MICHAEL . WILLIAMS 8752.99 o'clock A. m. the 16 day of June , at the Courts Building, Third District Court, 240 East 4th South, in Salt Lake City, Salt Lake County, Utah. Bro WITNESS pit f vs. Wednesday , has been set for hearing on $64.68 the following terms, , and upon as appears from the return of sale, filed in this Court, - JERRY 995.00 cash to pltr. to pltf. vs. tyler $22.54 Knight Adjustment Bureau REED C. THOMPSON, JR.! $611.10 52082- vs. D. Max Novelty vs. CUSTOM the Clerk of aaid Court, with the aeal thereof affixed, this to Eldred J. Wilde, Atty 6l6 Judge Bldg, pltf. Allied Collection Service, LAPRCAL ti'-w- to 52084- - Knight Adjustment Bureau vs. KITTY LIKEN8ACH1 877.13 to Inc.vo. Royal E. Wight, Jr. ENGINEERING 51391- - Ulympuo Crsdit Agency vs.1 L0UISC PAPPASi $320.87 to pltf. ANNA 1106.00 to L. Wight, Executrix deceased, to pltf. 52084- - Allied LaRue Mr ion of 57895 Personal .'rayir.o ior confirmation of sale of the following described real-e- s RAY R. B. Hoy dba Carlton Coffaa Shopj 1148.37 to pltf. 51507- pltf. 5208- 3- Knight Adjustment Bureau Uraon H. Gygi, NOTICE WIGHT of the eatate of DBA CHRISTENSEN! INTERMDUNTA1N TOW SERVICE A INSURANCE SALMA CE C0AP. 51933- Employee federal Union va. CARY CLllS0N $67.60 S S 0. Allied Collection Sorvico, IRA JR. DBA 8356.67 to dtf. Gilliam dva Doctors James C. Merchants Crsdit vs CINCER RUDD) 839.25 to Credit Inc. e. Inc. ve. A 50960- - 51781- - LA THAN, 866.85 HUBY MART INEZ A E. AKA ROYAL - $122.72 to Interstate Collections R. JR. 51908Point A Piston Service Inc. vs. R08ERT GUOMUNDSEN A CHARLES Actions Streator Chevrolet Co. MERRILL WIGHT, NO. Murray City Court $185.60 Murray City Court 49469- - E. 99-1- 03 Trent G Jeppson; Obn-- str of Brick Duplex with Variance for sldeyard. Msple St, Mvl. ROYAL of Actions New Midvale Building Permits Metier 0f tbi In day of June W. STERLING 5209- 3- Knight Adjustment Burs au vs MICHAEL L. WILLIAMS! $666.44 to pltf By EVANS 1st , A.D. 19 71 Clerk Douglas Thornier. Deputy Clerk ver . Y'- - I 1 1 |