| OCR Text |
Show PAGE THE TWO WEDNESDAY, MARCH 3, 1971 DAILY RECORD I here concerned with and which was construed by the court in the first Morgan case. It should be noted that the legislature in the 1967 amendment nor in the 1969 amendments did not attempt to deal with oil shale or Kerogen derived therefrom as a separate mineral. are of the opinion that the district court was correct in its decision statute to prohibit the defendants from entering into a lease of the construing oil Shale lands whicireeiTeady subject to-- prior oil. gas and hydrocarbon lease. The judgment of the district court is affirmed. No costs awarded. We a - Milton Wagstaff Motor 198046 Co. vs ALEXANDER EDWARD MAHAN, Pltf$1, 260.00; damages 198047 - Helen vs L. DENNIS (21) James Wallace Archibald, 1454 Burbank Ave (22) to Jananne Daltm 1466 Burbank Ave (18) support H. Burns vs Pltf$5,000; $8,000; $2,000 JEWKES; $126.00; damages E. R. Callister, Jr., Chief Justice HENRIOD, J. , concurs in the result. 198049 - Peoples Finance Co. of Utah vs THOMAS R. and JACQUELINE BRADSHAW; ELLETT, Justice: (Dissenting) $547.57; $190.00 $1,115.18; $330.00; note I - 198050 dissent. The statute (Sec. U.C.A. 1963 as amended) prohibits the defendants from issuing more than one lease for the same purpose on the sami land but does permit them to issue a second lease for other minerals. 45-1-- 18, The lease issued to the plaintiffs specifically excluded coal and oil The plaintiffs therefore cannot develop oil shale but in a "dog in the shale. manger" attitude brought this proceeding to restrain the defendants from issuing a lease to others for the purpose of developing the oil shale on the land. In the earlier case of Morgan v. Utah Board of State Lands. 21 Utah 2d 364. 445 P.2d 776 (1968). this court determined that oil recoverable from bituminous sand was the same as that pumped from a natural reservoir of oil. It is only necessary to apply heat, pressure, or certain detergents through bored I holes in the ground to be able to make the oil in bituminous sands flow to the surface of the land. Financial FMA The prior Morgan case is of no assistance in deciding this matter. The Federal Government recognized the difference between oil shale and oil in State of Utah, et al. , 71 I. D. 392 (1964). There the Interior Department specifically authorized the disposition of land containing oil shale but reserved the oil and gas to the United States. At pages 403 and 404 it was said: It would appear to follow that, if the base land is mineral land and the selected land is both valuable for oil shale and valuable for oil or gas and is situated within the known geologic structure of a producing oil or gas field or included in a producing or producible oil and gas lease, the State may obtain the selected land, including the oil shale deposits upon consenting to a reservation to the United States under the 1914 act of the oil and gas in the selected land. We so conclude. There can be no conflict between a lessee who mines oil shale and a lessee who produces oil through holes drilled in the ground. Neither one would, by its operation, interfere in any manner with that of the other; and neither one by its operation could possibly take any property from the other to which it would be entitled under its lease. I, therefore, would reverse the trial court and remand the case with an order to dissolve the injunction and to dismiss the complaint. Thrift & BRADSHAW Pltf Corporation Pltf $1,786.05; $426.25; $25.00; note - Hubert H. Moes vs LYLE MCALLISTER DBA A- -l QUALITY TV STEREO AND ELECTRONICS , INC 198051 Pltf$100.00; $2500; damages 198052 - Gordon and Bush Investment vs SHERWIN WILLIAMS CO. Pltf$9,040.00; bal due concurs in the dissenting opinion of Mr. Justice Ellett. - Intermountain Farmers 198053 Assn vs bal due AUSTIN Pltf$758. HENRIE; 198054 - Gunnar T. NEIL F. WINTERTON; Syversen vs Pltf$5,262.81 - Howard H. GREENE, 198055 Williams vs MARK M. D. ; DR. Pltf and damages - Midgley Manor, Inc. vs 198056 36409 - Marvel City Federal $10,000; contracts - Charles 198057 Anderson and H. Susan E. Anderson vs TIMBERLINE Pltf$2,425.00; contract INC; - Peter Lawrence Assoc. Inc vs Larry W. PECK AND EDENE PECK Pltf$410.00; $1,554.35; note 198058 198059 - Peter Lawrence Assoc. Inc vs HAROLD H. TEEPLES AND LEAH Pltf$670.00; $4,020.85 TEEPLES; note Credit Union vs JOY A. DENSMORE Pltf$634.23; $12.20; $190.00 31 38121 - Services Discount, Inc. dba S. 0. I. Agency vs BRENT K. PETERSON; 31 $50.00; 38122 dba S. Pltf$169.30; $6.80 - Services Discount, Inc. D. CARNELL; $50.00; I. Agency vs JOYCE C. - Bullock Glass & Frame Company, Inc. vs OMA STRONG; Pit $50.55; $8.20; 31 38135 - Doctor L. G. Benson and Dr. Donna Benson vs ROY TAYLOR Pltf$62.44; $7.40; 31 District Court - 197033 vs Vernal ELECTRONICS ine Products Co. CORPN DEVELOPMENT Pltf$2,554.55; $25.00; 225 CAR0LYNE M. 31 $10.60; 188372 - Margaret Cooper vs MELVIN T. RICHES0N AND REVA C. RICHES ON Pltf$5,000; 225 197589 - Spiegel, Inc. vs DELL GENE STEVENS AND MRS. DELL GENE STEVENS; $64.20; $8.60; 226 Pltf Miller Finance Co. vs ELDORIS B. RAWLINS vs Davis County Bank garnishee; $110.95 garn Judg 226 38273 - Barker, Ryberg & McCoy vs RICHARD M. HAMILTON; Pltf $817.54; $10.00; 38174 vs 31 - J. Keith Hansen ei al IKE OLSON; $8.00; 31 Pltf$473.76 - 198041 N. BURNS; ALDEN auto Ruby B. damage NIELSEN; 198043 JOHN C. U. F RONALD IRA MOWER AND SHARON ELLEN MOWER; - C. A. Bailey dba Bailey Const. Co. vs F0RCHT 170197 198044 Comm vs Electric Co. AND ROSE V. Pltf$5,000; note - State of Utah, RICHARD ANTHONY Road MADRID; damage ERICKSON, AND STELLA $1,117.53; note ; Pltf$304.00 $250.00; $34.60; 225 197587 - Howard Mattingly vs JESUS RIOS; Pltf$1,100.66 197803 DON - Brunswick Corporation L. DOCKSTADER; $1,719.8; $25.80; 225 vs Pltf - Progressive Imports Co. WALTER RAY DBA BECOMING WIGS Pltf$782.10; $23.60 SHOPPE; 225 WILLIAM C. H. HANEY; Pltf Melvin Graddy, 364 Cottage Ave (23) to Henrietta Augustine Binmons 364 Cottage Ave (27) Edwin Deral Bishop, 929 Serpentine Way, Sandy (29) to Deborah Lee Drake, 152 E. Utopia Ave (25) Trujillo 97 So. Mine STRAND & Smelter Supply ELECTRIC, INC Carl Paul Dalton, 1522 Michigan (23) to Norma Lee She liman 1522 Michigan Ave (19) Patrick Richard Riley, 1049 E. 6th South (20) to Ruth Ann Roily 3781 So. 3020 E. (18) - James E. Kropf vs BEL AIRE SECURITIES, INC; Pltf 226 - Ryder Truck Rental, Inc. D. WALKER, TRANSPORTATION; DBA EAST-WE- ST Pltf$30,742 187128 - Knight Adjustment Bur. vs J. B. SHAN DREW AND VERDA SHANDREW; Pltf$305.43 $24.40; 226 4925 Ernest Decker Drury, 6634 So. 2700 West Jordan (23) W. 4625 Granger (24) W. Virgil Daniel Cooper 217 3rd Ave Joseph Vigil, 548 E. Raymond 4th South (18) to Linda Thelma Alires, 826 So. 1st West (17) Douglas Francis Steele, 1468 W. 4th South (21) to Martha Lee Todd 3173 Millerama Aye, Granger (21) Way M. (23) Craig, 1887 Mary Dott to Lynda S. Nlnomiya 132 No. Main, Midvale (21) Rilllip C. Davis 765 Parkview Dr. Summit Park (20) to Rebacca Ann Cook, 4116 So. 1540 W. (18) Alan Ken Milliner, 3330 Joyce Drive (21) to Debra Suzanne Said 4584 Dartmouth Dr. Granger (21) William Arthur Peters, 2645 So. 8900 W. Magna (21) to Rosalee Tolley 4800 So. 4180 W. (19) 406 Penny Ave (20) Glllett (21) $662.50; $29.71; $328.00; $25.40 ERVIN W. South, Kearns (21) to Iris Gayle Gillette 3139 So. Breeze Dr. (16) David Lynn Hoggan, 1536 Indiana Avenue (21) to Jeanne Coleman 5895 South 75 West, Murray Pltf$39,332.98; $3,539.96 $28.40; 226 197483 Allen Joseph V. Anderson, 377 Maxwell Lane, legal age to Dorothy Ellen Elder, 377 Maxwell Lane, legal age (21) to Leslie Ann 191298 - vs Ave (20) Gary R. Moore, Vandenberg $3,081.89; $22.00; 226 198045 - State Savings and Loan Assn vs ROBERT E. ERICKSON AND J. JONES JEANETTE 194152 State of Utah, Road Comm KEE BAHE; Pltf$149.50; Pltf$70.38; auto SARA Pltf$40,000; COMPANY; 197405 - United Bond and Finance Corpn vs JAMES LEROY JONES AND vs 4th Joseph George Nielson, III 972 E. 3385 So. (19) to Lana Kay Griffin 363 Troy Way, Murray (20) Robert Co. vs damages HANEY i Pltf$884.62; 198042 - General vs FRANK NIELSEN vs Stroberg vs Simonson 266 (73) to Vera Samyn, Provo (23) - L. U. 354 I. B. E. W. Federal Credit Union vs 197814 Suits District Court' - Budget Loan and Finance Plan vs KATHY CRUNDVIG; Pltf$403.17 $10.60; $120.00; 226 35752 - Pltf$677.58 Pltf$185.13; $7.00 31 36786 37252 BANflORD; Harry Loren Olson 254 So. 3rd E. (19) to Patricia Lynne to Gloria Jean Button, 4371 So. $23.40; 225 37879 - Bonded Adjustment Bur, vs ROBERT DEE BANFORD AND James Leonard Buckley, 2765 W. 7160 South, West Jordan (22) to Gail Curry, 4566 West 4835 So. Kearns (20) James David Rush, 4816 Judgments 3800 Midvale (27) to Linda Joyce DeCisto, 76 Locust St. (23) Midvale Pltf$268,400; $51,238 COMPANY; 225 38138 Timmerman (20) Dennis Lee Hogan, 5091 Wesley Rd (33) to Julia Lee Cox, 118 Apricot Donaciano COMMERCIAL CONSTRUCTION CO. INC UNITED STATES FIDELITY GUARANTY ELECTRIC Judgments Way Timothy Joseph Riley, 26 Q St (19) to Kristine Margo Gibbs 2801 E. 3400 South (17) $1,934.00; $75,000; pers injury Bud City Court Barbara Robert Keith Graves, 1385 Dupont (19) to Lanette Claire Robinson 661 Post St. (17) Pltf$710.06; $25.80 . Lillie Belle DUANE $235.85; foreclosure 225 CROCKETT, J. Michael Scott Trower, 1751 Bryan Ave (20) to Marcia (29) vs GEORGE HEBER SWAN, JR. AKA GEORGE H. SWAN, JR. AND MARILYN SWAN AKA MARILYN M. SWAN; bal due Such is not the case with oil shale, for oil cannot be made to flow from the shale. It is necessary to mine the shale, and when it is brought to the surface of the ground, there is no oil in it. There is a substance in it called kerogen from which petroleum hydrocarbons can be derived by the application of heat and subsequent refining. This is shale oil and not petroleum. It is a black waxy oil which freezes at room temperature. See the article by Felix Jaffee in Mineral Industries Bulletin, Vol. 6, No. 2, March, 1962, published by Colorado School of Mines. Stanley Allen Levinson, 5525 Willow Lane (29) to Jerye Lou Motchman, Anchorage, Alaska Hebblethvalte M. TAYLOR, - George 198048 III SALT LAKE SCOT SUPER STORES INC. ROBERT STAGG AND ROBERT I CONCUR: Marriage Licenses Suits District Court Ray Porter, 860 Park St (27) to Cheryl Mae Schwab, 622 So. 5th East (23) Billy Victor Edward Leeks, 44 So. 3rd East (32) to Barbara Williamson 258 W. 650 South, Bountiful (29) John Milton Whitworth, 3095 W. Lehi Drive (64) to Sophronla Bernice Crosby 3191 Mar Kave (54) |
