OCR Text |
Show PAGE WEDNESDAY, MARCH 1, 1972 THE DAILY RECORD SIX 1 Financing Statements In The Supreme Court Of The State Of Utah with the City. - the jury could have found that their failure to say anything resulted in a contract. To say that a contract that must be established by at least some substantial and clear evidence was established by such type of proof based on such nebulous and flatulent evidence as adduced and recanted in the main opinion is not only provocative of flight from the simplest elementary principles of contract, but draws the shades on Williston and Corbin. It iB obvious that such tenuous evidence bound no one, and the jury should not have been allowed to speculate on it. SLC - 290609 - 290611 den Av, W le 150 Mitchell, to Pac Fin; Stero. Eugene S - Larson Watts, 712 Gar SLC to Pac Fin; TV, hhg. Park, 4861 S Fid Ind Cr; hhg. 290625 St, SLC - Eldon Lees, 539 Jeremy to Bene Fin; hhg. SMte 1 . j, S 290685 E, SLC - Donna Swim, 830 to Bene Fin; hhg. SLC 1700 E 290630 - Rick Neslen, 1004 Indiana Av, SLC to Bene Fin; hhg. 5, Uvl to Gen Cr Co; t ire Arms. - Frank Blatnick, 4837 Poplar St, Mur to Bene Fin;hhg. - Diane Warren, 3073 SLC to Bene Fin; 290632 Grace St, hhg. - Marueen 1 5135 S, Kearns Cc; M'g. R owe 11, 4766 to Ford Mtr 290635 - Wesley 7800 S, W Jrdn d . 29C''47 SLC , to City 2782 tin; - Willis Madsen, 1879 SLC to City Fin; Ltahna Dr, Mi. 290448 - Hike E S, SLC to CU; IV. "arvidakis, 740 SL Postal Em 290458 - Verne Hagen, 1026 E 7150 S, SLC to Capitol Th Ln; nl;g . - Willard Heaps, 857 SLC to Captiol Th Ln; Park, 290459 hhg. - Gary Sheets, 2979 branch, SLC to Capitol Th Ln; 290460 hhg. Douglas e, Sandy Veater, 7860 Carroll, to Wlkr Bk 290477 Tr; - Larry Regis Jr, 918 290478 - Marvin Campbell, 1221 Miss; on Rd, SLC to SLC Water Dept CU; PU, hhg. 2904798710 :- Jorgen Hansen, 147 S; Sandy to E1ML CU; Auto, hhg. 290480 2 N, hhg. W - to 142 Gabinet, EIML CU; 1629 W to Bene Fin;hhg. i 11 W, Boat.- N - S Lawrence Hanney, 918 ale to - Charles Klenk, SLC Main, 290599 to Bene Fin; hhg. - Steel Fabricators, 1577 Delaware Ln, SLC to VI Bk Tr; Mtr, Eq. 290600 W 7 N B & B EIML CU; A Wm 5999 Mur Th Ln; Con Gds. - Jerry Fancier, 157 SLC to Pac Fla; hhg. 5585 N SLC - Gloria Molema, 445 to Comm Cr pi; hhg. E 3 Plan; hhg. - Devon Johnson, 4761 View, SLC to Nation W 290698 E, SLC - Bruce smart, 3129 S to Comm Cr Plan; hhg. 9 290702 - Geraldine Tyson, 777 S Tmpl, SLC to Farmer St Bk; E Furn, Stero, hhg. 290655 - Rex Bennett, 8716 S 1300 E, SLC to Cent accept; Con 290705 21 - Ttan Steel Corp, 205 SL to Datafax; Off Eq. Gds. E 290657 - Wilfrled Kleemeyer, 1191 Laind Av, SLC to Cent Acce; Con Gds. 290706 3571 S - Lee Whaley, 142 Lucy Av, SLC to Cent Accept; hhg. 290707 - Michael Mason, Wlkr Bldg 401, SLc to FMA Leas Co; Off Eq. - Michael Northrup, to Cent Accept; 23 S, - Regional Sign Sup Inc, 2 W, SLC to FMA Leas All Eq. Co; W 290708 1756 - Diehl S 6 W, Lumber prod to SLC Co; Off Eq. - David McNeill, 2993 Av, Grgt to Cent Accept; FMA Leas Bk Inc, NEED MORE SPACE? - Calton Royall, 245 Poplar Crt, SLC to AVCO Fin; 290661 S to Bene Fin; hhg. Openshaw, 4532 oss, 290697 - Kanna McComb, 1577 Woodland Av, SLC to Comm Cr A. WARREN COLLINS hhe. Butterfield Cr, Grgr to 290605 Wilsoiv, - - - Edward Con Gds. Fin; hhg, Fum. 290604 S 290703 - Ralph Lehman, 54 E 200 N, N SL to Farmers St Bk; hhg. LeMay Stero Con. 115 W, Mur 817 S 10 Ind Cr; hhg. hhg. 290660 - Patricia McLean, 364 B, SLC to Nationw Fin; - Arnold Schmidt, Adm Kearns to Nationw Fin; hhg. S, 3 N 3, SLC Con Gds. to Bene Fin; hhg. 290695 290696 290659 3636 to 290694 - Bert Rosenquist, 6715 S 1680 E, SLC to AVCO Fin; hhg. Fin; hhg. 290658- 3347 2, - Robt Novasio, SLc W, 290654 - James Hamlk, 2332 Redondo Av, SLC to Cent Fin; 290603 - Francis Padgette, 4217 Benvlew Dr, Granger to Nat 290481 - Donald Bourell, 3500 W 3800 S, SLC to EIML CU; Hrse Trir, hhg. 290482 SLC E, 290601 Sandra SLC S 2 290564 Kearns Bldg, SLC to Navajo Leas Co; hhg, Off Eq. W - Kathleen Sine, - Steven Scoville, 11 W Stratford, SLC to Bene Fin; hhg. 90690 290693 - Maynes Masonary, 518 5400 S, Mur to Val Bk Tr; Eq. 290653 - Michael. Russo, 7883 S 3620 S, W Jrdn to City Fin; hhg 290583 290688 - Tape & Label Co, 135 2 S, SLC to Lang Wayne Eq Div; Eq. 290649 - Lester Larsen, 9881 Sego Lily Dr, Sandy to Nationw Meadow Accta Rec. S 6 E E Fin; hhg. 290582 - Industrial Design Corp 4461 W 800 S, SLC to Val Bk Tr; - Richard Costello, 832 I 2, SLc to Gen Cr Co; hhg, 290687 290692 - Glen Johnston, 2942 9 E, SLC to Adm Ind Cr; hhg. 290651 - Lloyd Harris, 177 Westwood Av, SLC To Nationw 1 Snowm. 250446 - jicrotliy Lowr. WR. - Gun. E hhg. Salt Lake City, Utah 84115 290476 S 1800 290686 - Richard Carter, 361 E Truman, SLc to Gen Cr Co; hhg, 290691 : 290633 -- JR Hildebrand, 4931 S Lake Pinea Dr 6D, Mur to Bene Fin; hhg. 290652 stock. - Donald Cavin, 3390 S 7 to Gen Cr Co; hhg, Guns. W 290631 and secretaries like 290475 - James Davis, 3892 Ruth View, SLC to 1st Mur off; Live Lu Ann Belt, 942 S to Gen Cr Co; hhg. 290627 - James Reid, 1050 E 7625 S, Mdvl to Bene Fin; hhg. - Gary Whittle, 448 Lan ce St, Mdvl to Bene Fin; hhg. Financing Statements 7286 E, SLC 290629 Jc Jatlg jEecorfr - Dennis Hoyne, - 290682 9 290684 - Bryan Egan, 725 E 3333 S, SLC to Gen Cr Co; hhg. S, j 290444 - Richard Davis, 2547 S SLC to Inter lake Th; 290681 Highland, hhg. Fin; hhg. 1397 South Main 290680 - Morton Nielson, 2284 S 9 E, SLC to AETNA Fin; hhg. 290626 - Roger Delis, 4300 S 4710 W, Grgr to Bene Fin; hhg. 290628 Quick Service Printing Phone 290676 - David Morse, 4206 W 5740 S, Kearns to AETNA Fin; 290679 - Richard Dahlberg, 128 5900 S, Mur to AETNA Fin; hhg - Bryon Cassell, 1191 290624 Then let us help you with 487-065- Con Gds. W For get me not, Sandy to Bene Fin; hhg. Need Help With Your Briefs? I - Udell Robison, 2093 Brewer, SLC to Mur 1st Th Ln; 290674 bourne Av, concurs in the dissenting opinion of Mr. Justice Henriod. For the service lawyers 290673 - Marvin Smith, 5596 S 1610 E, Sl to Mur 1st Th Ln; Con Gds. - Robt Wach, 474 Lam SLC to Bene Fin;hhg. 290623 - Rodney Miller, 4178 S 224, Kearns to Fid Ind hhg. 290634 - David Kindred, 1746 Dowington Av, SLC to Bene Fin; I 290670 4000 W Cr; hhg. - Larry Birch, 3005 Map SLC to Bene Fin; hhg. Wy, - Stephhn Zimmerman, 143 Olive, SLC to Interlake Th; hhg. 290621 - Robt Bennett, 3610 S 6885 W, Hntr to HH Fin; hhg. 290622 8 2 Ransdell, 1320 to Pac Fin; hhg. 290614 - Craig 3600 W, SLC to n, - Michael Carpenter, 152 Evergreen, SLC to GFC Corp; hhg, Fum. 290666 290669 Erma SLC SLC E, 1339 S 290610 - James Smith, 2447 E 3900 S, SLC to Pac Fin; hhg. that which was either not as yet conceived or unenforceably stillborn. J., 290608 162 N; 7 The balance of the main opinion has to do with matters other than the facts necessary to justify a finding of a parol contract based almost solely on parol evidence. It is submitted that the facts recited in the main opinion itself, together with the concessions of Ewell, will not support a contract based on either actual or ostensible authority and that it was reflected by nothing positive, but only by the conjecture that silence breathed life into Callister, C. - Charles Colen, to Pac Fin; hhg. 290607 The main opinion sanctions a statement in the conversation made by the city engineer, that "he understood the railroads and Ewell to have an understanding or that they soon would have, " in support of the decision here affirming a contract. The justification for the admissibility of such cloud-nin- e ' testimony was that, though a borderline question (which obviously it was not), the engineer was a professional man, interested in the subject matter, and subject to all of which was within the discretion of the trial court, and which this court thinks wasn't very prejudicial anyway, seems to be a non sequitur so naive as to disembowel the corpus evidentia. This erroneous permissiveness on the part of the trial court is like permitting the fans in the right field bleachers to call the balls and strikes at home plate. The main opinion fails to reveal that not only was the city engineer allowed to testify that he thought a couple of other people executed a contract, - (particularly where one of them participated therein in deathless silence) and in obvious usurpation of the prerogatives of another profession not his own, but permitted others, in gros, equally to demonstrate their expertise as to the elements requisite to create a contract, - thus cqmpounding the error of the trial court. It appears that the main opinion partakes of the hor doeuvres of this case but fails to jawbone the meat of it. It is no answer to say, as does the main opinion, that Ewell had a right to believe an engineer for one of the railroads which could bind the latter by silence, especially when Ewell's own evidence is based on what a batch of strangers thought was a contract, epitomized by one's less than clear gem to the effect that he "understood that the parties had an understanding or that they soon would have. " Such evidence may not only lead to silence but to an aberration reflecting incompetency to contract. Furthermore, the concessions made by Ewell in his own testimony militates against theexistence of a contract. When he was asked about the railroads' representatives' participation in the talkfest, he said that none of them agreed to pay him any money for the footage expense extra in the tunneling process. It.is akiomatic that a litigant's chain of testimony is no stronger than its weakest link, and it is no answer to say this positive evidence given by Ewell himself can be substituted by the silence of his adversary. cross-examinatio- - Allen Passey, 947 SLC to Pac Fin; hhg. 290606 Dreaden Pi, Ucol font ate SuIch ft Development 290662 - James Orr, 133 E Commonwealth Av, SLC to AVCO Fin; Con Gds. ('OMMKHCTAL 290i63 - Paul Whitehead, 1368 6 E, SLC to AVCO Fn; hhg. S - Evelyn NeilBon, 1529 Smiley, SLC to Bene Fin; hhg. 280664 1st - Kenneth Jung, Bonnie Brae Av, SLC to 290665 hhg. 2937 Bene INDUSTRIAL I K ASKS AlAimiKNTS CONTINENTAL REALTY 487-596- 3 1473 South 11th East Fin; Salt Lake City, Utah 841p5 |