OCR Text |
Show TUESDAY, JANUARY 26, 1971 THE DAILY RECORD PAGE SEVEN T In The Supreme Court Of The State Of Utah E. R. Calliater, Jr., Chief Justice F. Henri Henriod, Justice : l v . Campjry, UO-i- FILE!) ' i ii c V., il t.. lj . t C oi-rv- i . ir.c., A'ef-catior- ., 'mm'iasior. oi Marriage Licenses 2?, i'll! .anu-ir- y i. L. M Cvnm p.-- , GU-s- f . a grer .! grar L'ght Company, whirl, ha? r V, :. tender electric utility service in Sar Juan County dit'.r.g .c ir.-to this have set ii ccirr review and correct '.t clartfv r tde; r 1. 5evice Ci.mrnissirr. concerting the rigv-- grarte-- L th- deler-ia.r. e rJecrr-.!. tc operate an electr:c service Awo: .atr-'-por'.ir. m. .; Coirv ir. the general area surrounding Monticello 'tu exrl .i: g ir ihe certificate and which, ir. fhe Ttcrfst of i.irly r . v vvi tru e ic a F. the noire Certificated Area. Li ih Power & h-s- i : . V : : 1 p ut-.i- x t . de-:rdi- td -- 'une ef 19b9, Empire Electric filed an appli'ation .c expa-- d th: vae ihen renoeung in Sar. Juan County. Utah Power fr Light l r i :eJ h- - proceeding as a preteetant. Hearings cr the application wen hi .r. b ;t.i sion intermittently from September 3 to October 1, 1969. C'r. conit. tr.rtetc, and alter having received and considered br'efs tiled bv '.he :ht Commission, on January 12, 1970, isued its Report and Oioit p.ii i .v favor cf Emoite Elnttric and. granting i a Certifir lie cx C.'r.vfer . ro.-the additional portions ol Sar Juar. County ar requeues. .iv to irv ,,. .i i- . 273 Lnberg. 1 Shill Anderson, C:-nnu- f (39) to Christina Mr. 273 So. 400 E. -- 'ii-rv- e Pcwer nuv. cor.ctdes that upon the has. a of the ev.der,-he: i. .. a .a wurfcient showing made to justify the Commif id.' ? finding ex and neie'? ity ar.d the issuance of the author. ty grafted to pop. i i"r: Empire L.ccTic in what we have called "Empire Certiiicatec Area." Ihe arise? from the contenticn of Utah Power that m tor.re:fr. or' ii.e-- n ; v .h arar of that authority, the Commission went beyerd The ccpe --A thi r - ore er.ttd ,r. the :r .. dir.pute between these utilities, ami tcoh ucca-.icwhich the authority Kej.'r. a:.i Order t.o make certain recitals concerning hi- -' .if. a ranted t:- Uah Pewer to serve in San Juan County in 19S5 - an V. is app- : 'i t ittcmpt to redefine, ar.d impc6e some limitations thereon. scrnev.hat anomalous in adversarial litigation, but plaintiff's opponent, with that contention. If ceeh' or.ly u F.tnpi'f Electr c, docs net disag-e- e Lerti-.t"- ! iuv-i.rhp Report and Order as to the rights granted it in the Empixe L'r. e -- Vance Lee Christensen, 1868 Village Rd. (20) to Linda Arnettc Anderson 6911 So. State, Midvale (21) - . r Ae. M i r oreier to he ir.teres' f confining the effect of the Commission ated C.ertifthe Empire Area, c ur'-t-l i. roper ly before it, thit if :i r.e ipp I....,! 1 i and filed with this court Jir its with respect to the Repr rt am: Order: cdliiwirg stipulation et:.ve e rt-.-.- l, i, r,a::es have deviled he t r.nd een'entf which now reads: i- i 5 i "However, concerning the area for which Empire Electric Association is seeking certification, and the issues raised in this proceeding, the franchise just referred to merely permits Utah Power to construct, maintain and operate its lines along and across the roads, highways and public places of San Juan County for the purpose of transmitting and supplying electricity to the County, its residents, and perbons and corporations beyond the limits thereof. " The first sentence of the second paragraph on Page 9, which now reads: "If Protestant, Utah Power, now seeks to serve San Juan County after having failed to serve it at least in the portions for which Empire seeks certification, it cannot assume such a position uiless Utah Power obtains from this Commission a certificate indicating that the public convenience and necessity warrants the granting of this additional authority. " should be reworded to read as follows: "If protestant, Utah Power, now seeks to serve that portion of San Juan County, which it has failed to serve and for which Empire seeks certification, it cannot assume such a position unless Utah Power first obtains from this Commission a certificate indicating the public convenience and necessity warrants the granting of this additional authority. 11 It was not within the duty or prerogative of the Commission to import into the proceeding and pass upon matters which are not properly indluded and presented therein. In conformity with this doctrine, and upon the basis of the stipulation of the parties, it is our judgment that the plaintiff should prevail to the extent that we make the following order: Insofar as the order of the Public Service Commission grants the application of the Empire Electric Association to render service in accordance with the area described therein, the order is affirmed; but insofar as it may purport to go beyond the issues before it and limit or adversely affect any previously existing rights of the Utah Power ( Light no force or Company to render service in the rest of San Juan County, it has effect. No costs awarded. WE CONCUR: ail and E. Mr. and strom , Mr. and Mr. i'.ol Paul L. Pugh, 4460 So. 240 E. (43) to Marclle W. Eatchel, 4626 V.lllian. J. LeJraai' Mrs. Eryci: Clawson, 510 Mrs. Thonus L. Behunin 39th Couth, si'ii Mrs. William 2. i.euer- Sandy, daughter Mrs. Keith J. Btacer, Bountiful , daughter Mr. and Mrs. Von R. iick&iison 172 Cannon Road, (laughter and Mrs. Richard W. Baer 4306 Fernwood Dr, son Mr. and Mrs. Jesse T. Kelson, 1135 Bronze Ln, daughter Mr. and Mrs. Alma K. Richie 1884 Hollywood Ave, son Mr. and Mrs. John R. Brown, Mr. Russell St. (44) Rodger Joseph Marsden, 1357 Downington (31) to Myrna Esther Earl, 1316 Downington (27) Riverton, son E Mr. and Mrs. Dick Duff in, 28o4 6th East, son and Mrs. George Thomas Mr. Elliott Arthur Davis Hunter, 477 Garfield Ave (21) to Judy Ann HOLY Sandy 1314 Yale Ave, daughter CROSS HOSPITAL Mr. and Mrs. Kelly M. Lether 7325 So. 1700 West, son Mr. and Mrs. Martin L. Turner III, 4444 So. 4000 West, Granger Births son Nr. and Mrs. Merle A. Bennett, 1214 Dupont, daughter Mr. and Mrs. Doyle G. Davis, 2732 So. 200 West, Bountiful, son Mr. and Mrs. J. Reed Sherrett 2201 E. 3380 south, daughter Mr. and Mrs. Byron S. Maxwell 8l4o 535 Bast, Sandy, daughter Mr. and Mrs. Daniel A. Burch 7065 So. 17th West, Midvale, son Mr. and Mrs. Frederick D. White, 480 H St, son Mr. and Mrs. Gus J. Levis, 472 Granite, daughter Mr. and Mrs. Wellyn L. Koontz 4764 649 East, daughter Mr. and Mrs Janes V. Langlois 3210 So. 4100 West, son Mr. and Mrs. Clarence Janes Lennon, 3775 So. 7200 West, Magna, daughter Mr. and Mrs. John E. Riley, 637 9th East, daughter Mr. and Mrs. Jorn M. Stohl Louisville, ond , Colorado 2t, son LDS HOSPITAL 'but tud franchise merely permits Utah Poer to c or. struct, maintain and operate its lines alorg ami - t f .j. the roads, highways and publr places San : l.r.urty for th purpoi e of transmitting iud zy-g electi icity to the county, its reyicenti, ,:i' pen or. a and corpora itna beyond the Urn': J II should be reworded to read as follows: Re:: hairji ho. 12th West, sen Mr. Michael Walter Erickson, 1893 So. 23rd E. (23) to Shanna Arline Meier 1921 Jeremy Dr. (19) fn the main paragraph or. Page 8 r 2121 Wellington Ave, daughter Mr. anil Mrs. St even R. Ccck,80yo Oak Creek i'r, .son Mr. aii.i Mrs. Larry Bridge, jo5 Midvale (19) Jo. 4th East, twins, son, 3'9v'4 dau-h.tc- Mr. and Mrs. Lewis Albert Lopez, 319 So. State (Sandy) 23 to Norma Christine Conzales, 864th Ave. (18) State, Erickson L. e Michael Kay Burton, 948 American Beauty Dr. (22) to Ruth Weenlg 1324 Logan Ave (21) Lawrence 8804 So. Jei Violas .irunt sville, son Brent Lee Zlnrnerman, 2940 Morning-aidDrive (22) to Kerry Suzanna Peckham 6466 So. 1865 E. (19) Richard Copier, 431 E. 4555 So. (19) to Sherrie Ann Tucker, 786 3630 So. (16) Mr::. So. .jOO List, son Mr, ruii Mrs. V.'illiwr. Parker, ''.7 1.. 4tli jouth, son Mr. an.l Mrs. L:ury iiuiTis, 8 jo Windsor Jt, sou Mr. an i Mrs . M.rlin K. Jenson, l83; L. 3990 South, daughter Mr. and Mrs. Brent E. Mielsen, Mr. and Mrs. Tracy Brian Moffett, 1172 Kensington Ave (19) to Muriel LaDene Mclnelly, 1180 E. 3rd So (19) i- - mv.i 3j'j ; g Mrs. ll.ilip J. Munioy ..Voiiorcst L'r, ."olluiuy un-- 5,!'M5 Ronald Jay Pope, Midway, (23) to Patricia Mills, 312 No. 1200 West, Orem (23) I! : Edward Eugene So. 400 East Mr. (30) i i . A. H. Eliott, Justice u Ur.. - R. L. Tuckett, Justice Ky, son Mr. and Mrs . Dale C. Josephsun 3531 E. Oaks Dr, daughter Mr. and Mrs. Joel II. Izatt, 474 St. daughter Marvin R. Bronson, 1573 Meadownoor son Mr. and Mrs . Lyle W. Harlow Mr. and Mrs. Grant sville, daughter Mr. and Mrs. V.'. Heaton, 3196 So. Crestview Cl, Bountiful son Mr. and Mrs. C. Lynn Gilbert, 4283 l4th East, daughter Mr. and Mrs. Robert 'j.Souter, 220 Crusades Dr, Murray, daughter Mr. and Mrs. John H. Warwick, 1052 E. 2200 South, Bountiful, . Mr. and Mrs. Dick Barel, 340 So. 6830 West, son Mr. and Mrs. Gale L. Jensen 101(86 Buddies Dr, Sandy, son Mr. and Mrs. Lawrence Davis, 127 1st Ave, son Mr. and Mrs. Geoffrey Lunt, 1462 E. 8125 South, son Mr. and Mrs. Wilford Stratton 4051 So. 5375 West, daughter Mr. and Mrs. Jack Eugene Ellis Grant sville , daughter Mr. and Mrs. David Porter, 1329 E. Parkway, daughter Mr. and Mrs. Donald V. Filotti 347 E. 4090 South, daughter Mr. and Mrs. Gregory Klore, 942 Belmont daughter Mr. and Mrs. Gerrie, J. Mooy, 1612 W. Jolly Cl, daughter Mr. and Mrs. Donald L. Kertig, 3745 Bannock, son Mr. and Mrs. Thcmas Brown, 1177 Victoria Way, son Mr. and Mrs. John F. Vassilliades Jr. 1208 9th East, son Mr. and Mrs. Glen Ulmer, 1755 Stardust Dr, sen Mr. and Mrs. John D. Longaker 135 3rd East, son Mr. and Mrs. Paul Werrett, 1530 E. Farkway Ave, son Mr. and Mrs. Richard Callaway, 1371 Roberta St, daughter Mr. and Mrs. Iynn Sheppick 3129 9th East, daughter Mr. and Mrs. James G. Olson, 19 De Tobriand Si, Ft. Douglas, daughter Mr. ansi daughter Mrs. David Bean, 10834 Sc. Stute, Sandy, son Mr. and Mrs. Larry J. Strang, 933 E. 3rd South, son Mr. and Mrs. Kent Morgan, 4052 So. 5200 West, son Mr. and Mrs, Tim G. Christensen 9737 So. loOO West, Riverton, son Mr. and Mrs. Eugenio Barbiero Frovo, son Mr. and Mrs. Raeldor. Henry L. Cox, Jr. 52b C St, daughter Mi, and Mrs. Charles 0. Lewis, 325 7th Ave, son Mr. ar.d Mrs. C. Dee Sandgi'en Mr. and Mrs. Mr. and Mrs. Gerald J. Dent, Layton, daughter Mr. and Mrs, Roy Haws, 413 University Village, son Mr. and Mrs. Steven Bergstedt 2651 E. 3120 South, son Blaine Anderson 4171 13th East, daughter Mr. and Mrs. Dallas Jackman 2852 Robidoux RJ, Sandy, daughter Mr. and Mrs. Dan Ii. Frost, 1094 Glendale Dr, son Mr. and Mrs. i. Tooele, daughter M. Baudino Tooele, daughter C0TT0KW0CU HOSPITAL Mr. and Mrs. Dahl Ray Jackson 2751 Blair St, son Mr. and Mrs. Steven E. Jarvis, 114 W. 7500 South, Midvale, son Mr. and Mrs, Christopher J. Palaz- zolo, 2S19 E. 4510 South, son Mr. on! Mrs. Ronald D, Vernon 3478 Bi'ockbank Dr, son Mr. and Mrs. Steve C. 2upan, 3140 Taft St. Midvale, son |