| OCR Text |
Show '" Bcase In :'" p of Atly. General e iur. B "i on B Vol' linllcnlcs That Hop. 'Si KiMthr Mill Hclnln Ills 11(0 I Sent. they B """ lise Jf c '' Wnnilck being an i B'a" ,cnt '" lll Utnh Lcgls they B0"' up for l,cnr,nB ln8t Tuos-"ount, Tuos-"ount, H-ii a lotiK tlmo sln6e ntiythlng 00,000 Bstel moro Interest among bo ' fur- Bople In tills county, ns It In-' In-' the I'lte question whether tills dls-ljr dls-ljr " Bould to reiircsentcd or not. "ural B the Warnlck enso enmo up toUl Blipfclnl order for Tuesday nf-m nf-m la B Representative George F. ounta K, Progressive, o( Salt Lake, "n It H'jcr of the protest against the Per B' Mr Wnrnlck t0 slt '" tho ' his li'll lenders of the allies In Hitt to unseat Mr. Warnlck. lll- , , Hjcnal st'( Iflcatlons In his pro- legis. rplui B national speclflcntloua were CCD B')rt of ""' Boncrnl chargo that h ui Hrolck was not n resident of the Hl'tnh for llirco years at the Mi election to the state loglB- The constitution specified the food ce of throe years In tho Htnto cf the essentials to eligibility h In cither branch of the state i ai B-jrc. 3 first of the nddltlonnl spcclfi-H3S spcclfi-H3S that Charles L. Wnrnlck rlitcrcd as a voter In the First t of Twin Kails on July 13, nil that at that tlmo took tho ttlon oath stating thnt ho was rS6B'Dtnml n qualified voter of the Bf Idaho. B second specification was that t to ll.rch 27, 11)13, ho qualified na -assessor of Bonneville county, ., B taking tho required bonstltu- ' 'Boatli of tho stato or Idaho ut ""IBjieand filing tho samu with the aseiBr clerk of Bonneville county, yoaB narrB'e specifications woro lii tiddl- . Bothe protest already filed, which to'fBethat Mr. Wnrnlck did not re-theBiUtnh re-theBiUtnh thrco years prior to the Id aBM f 'n8t fall ; that ho had so c:ted, and that ho was n mom-, mom-, 'Hi the Idaho legislature during '"B1" 1S11 1912' m3 nnd im- u'iB Goodwin suggested thnt Mr. ol iBck hoglvcn tho opportunity, If ..(slrod.bto reply to the protest. Barn,ck Gicn roso n,ul snl(1: "r!iefuct8 In tho enso arc simple B I shall bo pleased to present M,Ba t0 "10S honornblo body. To .B'a with, let mo say that I ccr. ,Blr will acknowledge residence "llJalio thitBwni born In Utah mid In Utah in'sBaty I was rulsed In Utnh j.nty and voted thcro ut munl- . Id, county, stato and national "'ctlons irwBa the statu of Idaho I have had ts'iB honor to cast my oto and to nd-B10 I" tho stato legislature. Is truo that I was n member on'B tho Idaho lcglslaturo during m session of 1911, during :in ;Otraordluury session of tho ,etBlshituro hold the snmo year; , .Blnltjo during tho session of tho fVlslnturt) In Idaho In 1U13, '.! arknowlcdgo iiIbo that 1 was registered In precinct No. 1 of 'ho Falls, I did not sorvu as -B regular deputy nsuoBucr In JBtinevlllo county, but for ton Brs was a Bpoclal deputy ussos-Bf- In Idaho Falls. Bfittluulug, Mr. Wnrnlck said that BjM not wish to argue his case, but B')' to present tho fnctH. Hu mild as born and raised In Utah conn-B"''l conn-B"''l bo called attention to tho fnct B tho constitutional provision un-B'hlcb un-B'hlcb llllt protest was brought did B'lx'flfy thut'thu residence or the B'nll bo threo eara prior to the B!ul but merely required threo B1' resldcuco In tho state. Br Wnrnlck said ho hud returned B ltlalio tho latter part of Septum-B'l'-,i;t. nnd had lived hi Utah couu-B(0""iuoiiBly couu-B(0""iuoiiBly since that time, that Utaa a qualified voter and n resl-B' resl-B' of bis county for more thnu one B' prior to tho election. His fnm-B1"! fnm-B1"! Ktilil, returned to Utnli in May, B ond ho canio with them as soon B liail disposed of his Idaho Inter- Bl don't know," said Mr. Wurnlck, B't I hnvu vor told onyonu that B"" 110t "' blu statu. I don't B,v ,u"t I linvo uvor t0,tl liyo,ll! B1 ' hianucd to make n permnucnt B11"" I" lUnho. Threo years ago B'ix 'hu winter In Snlt Luke nnd Ba lol' tlmo I havo paid taxes on B1111 property In Salt I.ako. My mn to Idaho lii tho first plnco was BB:ltt'r or business, I had never In-W-ivi ruufilulug thero na lone as 1 Br" ConcludiiiB, Mr. Wnrnlck pleaded Hi tln membora not to consider n In tho matter, but to deeldu hethcr or not tho peoplo of Utnh wiity were entitled to full repre-utatiou repre-utatiou lu tho stnto legislature; iethor or not It would benefit them r dc.r nig him of his seat In the 3c lie suggested that tho mem-' mem-' of Up houso ask him questions wchin,, mio case, The ,L1 caused much comment, J lciui .k attorneys nro divided on Mm - u,u which hinges Bolely as 'Mtucr 1 1 threo yenra residence re-WlM re-WlM i. iho coiistltutlnu must be 'mnndi. k proceeding the election '''wiu' . n could havo been say ton "urs 1)rtui HRel'' uMvo (loodwln, I'rogros-ve. I'rogros-ve. tun Ui pu'Bontiitlvo Morris, Doin-JtfM. Doin-JtfM. bn.h tho lead lu tho dobato to wiui mi Wnrnlck, and Hepvuson. Su 5) "V. llopubllcnn, conducted ") feu. , r,. ti, dofoiiBo. Tho first if1 r" .liMtlod principally along po-'J po-'J lu.ta. when the motion to ro-r ro-r Hit . nip to tho Attorney aenornl tin, " 0l",,ll"i was ndopted by u ino-aiwilt ino-aiwilt t, (u ly Ml. win nick not vot ing. Following Is the result: Ayes-Augurd, Allen, Ilarker, lllack-ett, lllack-ett, Ilrliikorhoff, Child, Croft, Day, j-olkinnii, Fowles, Ilnwley, Hinckley, Horsley, Kolly, Mcsliane, Mabey. Meeks, O'Nell, l'opo, Itedd, Sovy, Stow-' nrt, Taylor, Van Wagoner, Wing, Speaker Anderson 20. Noes Ilovan, Browning, Brown, Burton, Chrlatonsen, Knnls, Fitch, (loodwln, Urimn, Hammond, Heywnrd, Lund, Morris, Nebcker, Oldham, I'nge, Peterson, Shields, Wolstenholm IS, All tho noes were 1'rogresslves and Democrats, while the Republicans, Including In-cluding Brlnkerhorr, Meeks and O'-N'lel, O'-N'lel, Democrats, and Croft, Progressive Progres-sive voted "Aye." o .. . |
