OCR Text |
Show WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY TNE DAILY KECOftD PACil 17, 1971 1 largely indebted, and when he has not sufficient property8 remaining to satisfy his debts cannot be sustained. . Trust Deeds Defendants further assert that the trial court erred in setting aside the conveyances of the Grows, individually, to the grantee. Defendants urge that plaintiff's claim against the Grows, individually, is a tort claim which has not been reduced to judgment, and, therefore, their liability has not been established. The findings of fact and conclusions of law do not support defendants' assertions. Although there was evidence of the plaintiff's separate civil action against the Grows, the trial court set aside their conveyances on the ground of their personal liability on the corporate notes and mortgages and subsequent deficiency judgments. Defendants further contend that the trial court granted relief in excess of the prayer in plaintiff's complaint, namely, that the deeds be set aside as void and fraudulent. The trial court ordered that the property be sold to satisfy the deficiency judgments that had been rendered against the corporate defendants. Defendants' argument is without merit. This entire action was predicated on the fact that the grantors had placed property beyond the levy of their judgment creditor. The judgment by the court declared the conveyances void, solely for the purpose that plaintiff might satisfy the deficiency judgments. 525 546 551 Negus etux tolst 706 Fed 707 708 1704 Herbert Are 567 Harry R Barker etux to Murray Th Ray Martlneau; 1409 W 8th So E O Keith danoook etux to led 709 711 Be Kener etux to let See St Bk Blacks Title; ,,16000, 280? W 7460 so, West Jordan 576 Paul 578 Charles H Falser etux to 1st Seo St Bk Blaoks Title; 17500. 2752 W 7500 So, 1W Jordan 588 Kenneth P Kotter etux to The Lookhart Co Wsst St Title; $8988.65 6972 Chris ane, Holliday 2365 589 W ' 597 trial court is affirmed, Costs are awarded to 601 Clifford P Ertmann $16000. 4903 Kathleen St 717 Kelly 719 plaintiff. Janes Edward Obekayne etux to The Lookhart Co West St Title; 721 603 621 723 Herbert P Uhgrioht etux to Are Fin Ser; $50000. John E Boomer etux to Murray Th Kay M Levis; $14427. 491 Spaoeraaa Dr 1st 727 A. H. Ellett, Justice J. Slmer Ramsey etux to 1st See Pioneer Title; $15800. 729 Bk Boyd C "iehards etux to 1st Seo St Bk Pioneer Title Ins; $16000. 731 422 426 427 etux to Wlkr Bk; Kenneth $16000. 2070 W 7673 So, S Cox W Westergard etux to Wlkr Bk; $15700. 2070 W 7685 So, W Jordan John rid L Strong etux $11350. 931 3 4125 So Da Naoad $770. 1439 rid Gene Moen etux $14550. 2406 E 76OO So I to 472 436 Edward Bk Bolke etux to 498 Wkr Bk; 1st See Pioneer Title Ins; $19600. 3709 So 4265 Geo H Moody SLCo 639 Triangle Dalian Cox etux to West Mtge Pioneer Title Ins; $16200. 3841 W 4990 So W Roy Brown Marie Fehler to S Home Ben 641 etux to Valley Bk Aoord Ins to Valley 643 514 Sav; Home Bldrs to Triland Ino MoGhie Land; $14000. Exquisite 65O Roderick Enterprises to Navalco; Bk; $13000. 1st Bernard Ruis etux to Mur Kay Lewis; $3980.35 Th 1st Powelson Cons to to Yfast Sav; R45000. 4497 Zarahemla Dr 522 Sonja Lee Brown to West Mtge MbGhle Land Title; $16000. Theo Dennis Brasher etux to West d Title; k$l6000. Mtge MoGhie 4512 W 3855 So Kenneth G Topham $16000. 3221 So 4100 W 736 etux to PFS; $32000. Co Const Ino to Jr to Exq Home Bldrs MoGhie Land etux to PFS; West Mtge Title; Haselhurst Dr $13000. Tierra to MoGhie Mtge In; $13000. Am W 3860 So W 3860 So -- and Tr West Ditto 678O Ditto; $12500.' SLC 737 Ditto 738 Ditto PFS John S Young Jerry etux to PFS; Title; 658 Hubert W, 75 Rrrtn Co Beekman 661 664 W Aba; $12950. 4805 So, reams John F Hardin Jr etux to Nat Mtge Co Bckraan Aba; $11500. 4243 W 5615 So Keams Riehard W Hard man etux to The West St Tit el; M 11th E Torres etux to West 3691 So 610 675 Mtge 682 Kq SLC 766 Dale Dr Robeft Wilfred Poirier etux to Horn Ben Sav $14500. Garfield Joseph LeMay etux tolst Seo See Title; $16000. Bk John S Robb etux to Seo Title; l6000. 1889 No SUr Dr Bk No Star Dr R $22700. 1st See O'Brien etux to PFS; Lit to Uh Title; $12500. 7675 So, Const Groneman G W Jordan W Jordan to pFS; $22800. etal to Neilson Bert P VAn Komen etux to PFS; $18300. SLC 1st Th 776 778 Sav MoGhie Land W Smith Wardle etux to Betti-ly- on Mtge Seo Title; $16000. W 5820 So Meeks Wirthlin etux to PFS; $45000. SLC 686 James P Robinatt etux to The Lookhart Co W st 5t Title; $6000. 4960 S 4900 W, Keams 687 Curtis L Pettit West St Wayne 4080 Riehard E Long etux to The Look-ha- rt West St Title ; $4t5.l6 4888 So 4860 W, Keams Co W W, Bk Const See Title; $22000. 1372 Crandall Ave SLC 665 Jordan l6000. Tr; Ity A 762 E Tim Carter etux to Murray Kay M Lewis; $4445.88 6968 So 160 E, Mdvl Emp W Bk Fenstermaker etux to Wlkr L Jerry 2070 770 Co 7705 So, Herron etux to Wlkr Mark Bk A Fisher etux to Nat Mtge W W 7677 So 2070 Bk See $12000. Linn ell etux to Wlkr Tr; $17500. Tr; $16000. etux to Mataulufotu etux to 1st See 3860 So D 2098 752 T Dean Thomas W James ft $5550. Pioneer Title Ins; "16000. Verl 6758 Ditto Alono SLC 519 $12000 Lookhart Burton F Ho Lean etux to Mur 1st Ih Kay Lewis; $8939.32 1885 $25000. Me Dirid P Riddle etux to Wst Mtge MoGhie Land Title; $16000. 6757 10742 So 3200 Douglas F Graham etux to Mur Th Kay Lewis; $5251. 1192 Waysaide Br, Sandy 1038 E 517 734 SLCo SLCo 458 2365 $18700. SLC 456 Bk 735 4786 3817 Lorn $10000. 453 to 1st See 750 Riehard Wayne Wealls etux to Zion 1401 So 513 452 Sorrels etux to Fanners St Bk; $8000. W Jordan Marvin E W Ln Rashelle Bain to West Mtge Ghie Land Title; 16000. 4494 w 3805 So L 5827 SLCo SLCo 500 443 733 So Ray Barton etux 634 SLC 499 L 3940 W Ditto; Mat Bk; $29700. 5000 So 938 E fU7 Bk; Tr; $16000. 628 1st 479 K16000. Title; $13400. $16000. 218 E 9585 So, Sandy 475 PFS; Creek Rd, Sandy r 432 to Granquist to Wlkr E 469 Jordan B D Bk A Ditto; Trust Deeds 420 Kearsley etux to Valley Ryan 627 Allan Crockett, Justice Dreeksel etux to West Mtge H 3883 Lorna Dr Ut Title A lbs; $12000. 1987 Gunderson Lane F. Henri Henriod, Justice $16000. 3794 Lorna Dr Ditto 6509 626 Title; 4517 Thayn Dr 3911 Lorna Dr, Granger R. L. Tuckett, Justice Alan MoGhie Land 1356 Ramona Are WE CONCUR: Patriok Lee Struhs etux to West 3772 Lorna Dr St etux to PFS; Johnson etux to PFS; E Mtge MoGhie Lend - Geo Mtge $16000. 715 SLCo The judgment of the etux to West Watdoups den L Garland etux to West Mtge MoGhie Land Title; $16000. 6555 W 3850 So 725 594 Jd 713 3579 So 2700 E well as capital that the grantee can suggest the question of maintenance. The issue, therefore, is essentially affirmative on the part of the creditor. He demands gross income. The grantee's position is one of recoupment, of offset, so far as maintenance charges are Ditto; $12500. W Oriole Cr $16000. 4882 Kathleen Are $6475. 4238 "aekay Dr 590 3860 So W MoGhie Land Title; 3675 So 658O W 1460 Burbank Ave Convey- Ditto; $13000. 2545 lbs; $13616. The Hone Ditto; H25OO. 6734 1st 565 , Aa 3846 Mooregate Are "ad sen etux to West Sit Even S Ditto; $12800. 3866 Morregata Ln; $25600. he has collected; and by the same token he would have no affirmative action against the creditor for the cost of upkeep. It is only when the creditor demands income as . . C MoGhie Title $13000. 3838 Mooregate AVe Sav; $34000. 1767 Oakridge Dr Thus it is apparent that, so far as maintenance expenses are concerned, the question is academic unless the creditor comes, either by way of an equitable suit to avoid the transfer and for an accounting as incidental to the principal measure of relief, or by way of a quasi contractual action for the income, after a judgment at law sustaining a levy upon the property. If the creditor merely levies on the property and does not follow with a suit for income, the grantee keeps what concerned. . Norman Tierra to West Mtge Am Land 238 So 1200 E Str Finally, defendants assert that this matter should be referred to the trial court for a determination of the grantee's equitable interest in the properties. They claim that the grantee's expenditures for repairing and preserving the property subsequent to the conveyances vested in him; an equitable interest. The following excerpt from Glenn, The Law of Fraudulent ances, Sec. 249, p. 335, resolves this issue. 705 Brighaa 0 Holbrook etux to Marilyn J Russell See Title; 120000. etux to The Tltl; 1528 Evergreen Lane Lock-ha- $8380. rt 816 Wither etux to Wlkr Tr; $5428.08 Gordon E Bk A 119 B Str 817 Golden R Muir etux to The Lookhart Co West St Title; k$13020. 4069 Montaia Dr, Granger 830 Ronald W Simpson Sav; $16000. 3838 So 6460 V; etux to Home Ben |